Where do I hold short?

CaptBill

Well-Known Member
Taxiing out of Raleigh Durham this morning to takeoff on 5R we were told to hold short for landing traffic. The weather was overcast with light rain. As we approached the runway there were two hold short lines - one for the ILS and the other was the traditional hold short line. My FO asks "When do we use the ILS hold short line and when can we cross it and use the non-ILS hold short line? I thought it was a great question and fortunately I did know the answer.

Does everybody else know the answer?
 
I have heard it mentioned on ATIS before, also had the controller specify. I really can't offer more than that. It is a good question.
 
I have heard it mentioned on ATIS before, also had the controller specify. I really can't offer more than that. It is a good question.

It will be on the ATIS, and ground will tell you.

Here's what it is

3-7-5. PRECISION APPROACH CRITICAL
AREA
a. ILS critical area dimensions are described in
FAAO 6750.16, Siting Criteria for Instrument
Landing Systems. Aircraft and vehicle access to the
ILS/MLS critical area must be controlled to ensure
the integrity of ILS/MLS course signals whenever
conditions are less than reported ceiling 800 feet or
visibility less than 2 miles. Do not authorize
vehicles/aircraft to operate in or over the critical area,
except as specified in subpara a1, whenever an
arriving aircraft is inside the ILS outer marker (OM)
or the fix used in lieu of the OM unless the arriving
aircraft has reported the runway in sight or is circling
to land on another runway.

PHRASEOLOGY-
HOLD SHORT OF (runway) ILS/MLS CRITICAL AREA.

1. LOCALIZER CRITICAL AREA
(a) Do not authorize vehicle or aircraft
operations in or over the area when an arriving
aircraft is inside the ILS OM or the fix used in lieu of
the OM when conditions are less than reported ceiling
800 feet or visibility less than 2 miles, except:
(1) A preceding arriving aircraft on the
same or another runway that passes over or through
the area while landing or exiting the runway.
(2) A preceding departing aircraft or
missed approach on the same or another runway that
passes through or over the area.
(b) In addition to subpara a1(a), do not
authorize vehicles or aircraft operations in or over the
area when an arriving aircraft is inside the middle
marker when conditions are less than reported ceiling
200 feet or RVR 2,000 feet.

Here's what YOU need to know as a pilot:

4-3-18 a. 8.

If a pilot is expected to hold short of a runway
approach (“APPCH”) area or ILS holding position
(see FIG 2−3−15, Taxiways Located in Runway
Approach Area), ATC will issue instructions.
 
Honestly Mike I was hoping to drag this out a bit with a few more "Heck if I know" or "Ahhhh, you got me" type responses. I figured that all the smart folks on JC who would know the answer had gone to bed already. :laff:

That being said, I better get some beauty sleep here in Mexico City. :bandit:
 
at my home base, whenever it is MVFR pilots always hold at the ILS line and the tower chews them out. Usually tells them "he never advised" and that "its VFR, ILS is not in use blah blah"
 
It raises the question that if the weather is at or below 800' / 2 miles and the controller does not tell you to hold short of the ILS critical area, are you required to? In other words, is there a clearance inferred by the weather alone? Can you defend yourself from NOT holding short simply because you weren't told to? :confused:
 
Honestly Mike I was hoping to drag this out a bit with a few more "Heck if I know" or "Ahhhh, you got me" type responses. I figured that all the smart folks on JC who would know the answer had gone to bed already. :laff:

That being said, I better get some beauty sleep here in Mexico City. :bandit:

LOL.......

Thats what I get for working the night shift sitting alert for launch. Whole lot of nothing puncuated by mass get-a-move-on when the alarm sounds. :D
 
I would play it safe in IFR conditions if I didn't receive any instruction, I would ask the controller. Hell I would rather be chewed out for holding short at the ILS line then cause interference with an aircraft on the ILS.
 
Funny side note, in the 1900, we were certified for cat II approaches. One of the requirements was for dual flight directors... so in the flight director mel, it stated that precession approach minimums were not authorized. Sure did suck, shooting ils after ils raw data... to not be able to suddenly when the flight director was shot. Point of it, was that, it said precession approach, but only was intended to apply to Cat II approaches.

This makes me wonder if some of the Precession approach protected areas are not infact for normal Cat I approaches. Seems that I only get told to hold short when the weather is really in the crapper, or in boston taxiing around the bend to 9.
 
If you've been on ground freq you probably don't know whether or not there even IS somebody on the ILS. I'd go all the way up to the runway unless told otherwise. That's what you're cleared and expected to do. It's the same as crossing a runway while taxing to the active. You're not gonna hold short of that either, unless they specify.
 
......working the night shift sitting alert for launch. Whole lot of nothing puncuated by mass get-a-move-on when the alarm sounds.


Just so you know Mike, the Mexican Airforce will not be a threat tonight. I saw their entire fleet of 3 fighters tucked away tonight as I landed in Mexico City. However, keep an eye open for those Canadians as they are a sneaky bunch. They disguise their fighters and bombers as Snowbirds demonstration aircraft, then when you least expect it - BAM, they will drop a load of Mark 84s on your roof. The only alarms you are likely to hear tonight though is from Qgar needing a massage or Toria wanting a ride to Nordstroms. They seem to think they can just snap their fingers and we pilots will come running. Just the other day, Toria told me she had a tumbleweed stuck in her grille and asked if I could remove it? Seriously, where do they come up with the idea that we are here to serve them?
 
Just so you know Mike, the Mexican Airforce will not be a threat tonight. I saw their entire fleet of 3 fighters tucked away tonight as I landed in Mexico City. However, keep an eye open for those Canadians as they are a sneaky bunch. They disguise their fighters and bombers as Snowbirds demonstration aircraft, then when you least expect it - BAM, they will drop a load of Mark 84s on your roof.

LOL......I told them I wanted a night off from ultralights tonight!

The only alarms you are likely to hear tonight though is from Qgar needing a massage or Toria wanting a ride to Nordstroms. They seem to think they can just snap their fingers and we pilots will come running. Just the other day, Toria told me she had a tumbleweed stuck in her grille and asked if I could remove it? Seriously, where do they come up with the idea that we are here to serve them?

Bow chika bow wow? :D
 
at my home base, whenever it is MVFR pilots always hold at the ILS line and the tower chews them out. Usually tells them "he never advised" and that "its VFR, ILS is not in use blah blah"

That's funny. As far as I know, there's no maximum hold short distance. I suppose you could "hold short" on the ramp, but I never tried. I find it interesting, though, that a controller would chew out pilots for being conservative. Even so, I'd rather have one of those than the kind that involves calling the FAA.
 
At a non-towered airport, you are expected to hold short of the ILS critical area when the weather is at or less than the prescribed 800-2 minimums. We've been into an airport in western Virginia in such conditions. As we taxi out, we hold short of the ladder line. A certain Saab operator taxied out behind us and jumped on our case for not pulling up to the runway hold short line while waiting for a release. I politely reminded him that the weather was less than 800-2, so we'd be holding short of the critical area until released for departure in case there was an aircraft on the ILS. Still not sure if he understood what I was talking about.
 
Says who?

I know that you will never receive a specific instruction to hold short of the ILS critical area at an uncontrolled airport, and the AIM advises that the ILS critical area is not protected at an uncontrolled airport. However, if the line is painted there, why wouldn't do your fellow airmen a favor and err on the side of caution?

I don't know about you, but I typically get my IFR clearance with a "hold for release" at least 10 minutes prior to departure if at all possible. I then load up the pax, start up and taxi out. On the way, I call for release if I can see that I'll be #1 for departure when reaching the runway. If low visibility conditions exist, I can't guarantee that someone hasn't joined the approach between the time I got my clearance and the time I started taxiing out. Therefore, holding short of the ILS critical area is the only logical thing to do.

Sorry, I shouldn't have said "expected to".
 
Therefore, holding short of the ILS critical area is the only logical thing to do.

No argument. I only objected to the "expected to". While it's harmless for a pilot to assume that he's "expected to", it would be foolish for an arriving aircraft to also assume that any aircraft holding short has an obligation to do so.
 
Personally, I always hold short of the ILS critical area with conditions less than 800/2. There are some airports where I've experienced wild glideslope deviations when an airplane pulled up to the hold short line (MDW, SAN), which required me to click off the autopilot to remain stabilized.

This is one of those situations where the regulations are gray, so it's up to you to decide whether you err on the side of caution.
 
Toria wanting a ride to Nordstroms. They seem to think they can just snap their fingers and we pilots will come running. Just the other day, Toria told me she had a tumbleweed stuck in her grille and asked if I could remove it? Seriously, where do they come up with the idea that we are here to serve them?

Bow chika bow wow? :D


I rescind my earlier comment.


I posted before I saw this utter nonsense. You boys are despicably naughty scoundrels. Calcapt, you are tarnishing my reputation. MikeD, beware, Calcapt will only lead you down a path sin. Both of you boys are utterly naughty.
 
Back
Top