Where do I hold short?

Just so you know Mike, the Mexican Airforce will not be a threat tonight. I saw their entire fleet of 3 fighters tucked away tonight as I landed in Mexico City. However, keep an eye open for those Canadians as they are a sneaky bunch. They disguise their fighters and bombers as Snowbirds demonstration aircraft, then when you least expect it - BAM, they will drop a load of Mark 84s on your roof. The only alarms you are likely to hear tonight though is from Qgar needing a massage or Toria wanting a ride to Nordstroms. They seem to think they can just snap their fingers and we pilots will come running. Just the other day, Toria told me she had a tumbleweed stuck in her grille and asked if I could remove it? Seriously, where do they come up with the idea that we are here to serve them?

Sigh....you know me sooo well. Who spilled the beans? :crazy:


I rescind my earlier comment.


I posted before I saw this utter nonsense. You boys are despicably naughty scoundrels. Calcapt, you are tarnishing my reputation. MikeD, beware, Calcapt will only lead you down a path sin. Both of you boys are utterly naughty.

Sooo much better than just plain naughty! :D
 
Taxiing out of Raleigh Durham this morning to takeoff on 5R we were told to hold short for landing traffic. The weather was overcast with light rain. As we approached the runway there were two hold short lines - one for the ILS and the other was the traditional hold short line. My FO asks "When do we use the ILS hold short line and when can we cross it and use the non-ILS hold short line? I thought it was a great question and fortunately I did know the answer.

Does everybody else know the answer?


The ILS critical area becomes guarded at 800 & 2 (800 ft ceilings or less and 2 miles visibility or less).

If it's near or at that, or the active ILS is in use, you might as well stop short of that as a courtesy to landing aircraft. I know the -145 the autopilot flies like a drunk if there's even a wiggle in the localizer signal. That may well hold true for others.

... not to mention- what if somebody breaks out low and left or right of course and you're snugged right up on the VFR hold-short line?

Don't ask me where I remember 800&2 rule from, but I do know that's correct. It's in the AIM, I think.
 
The ILS critical area becomes guarded at 800 & 2 (800 ft ceilings or less and 2 miles visibility or less).


Don't ask me where I remember 800&2 rule from, but I do know that's correct. It's in the AIM, I think.

Did you remember it from post # 3 of the thread?

:D
 
It raises the question that if the weather is at or below 800' / 2 miles and the controller does not tell you to hold short of the ILS critical area, are you required to? In other words, is there a clearance inferred by the weather alone? Can you defend yourself from NOT holding short simply because you weren't told to? :confused:

I specifically remember reading on this forum one time, DE727UPS saying that a UPS crew had this happen at MHT. The weather was less than 800-2 and they did not hold short at the ILS hold. However, the controller also did not tell them to hold there and supposedly they are supposed to do that. It ended up being that both parties were faulted because there is supposed to be some redundancy where ATC tells them to hold short at the ILS line and the crew is supposed to do it without hearing that anyway.
 
I specifically remember reading on this forum one time, DE727UPS saying that a UPS crew had this happen at MHT. The weather was less than 800-2 and they did not hold short at the ILS hold. However, the controller also did not tell them to hold there and supposedly they are supposed to do that. It ended up being that both parties were faulted because there is supposed to be some redundancy where ATC tells them to hold short at the ILS line and the crew is supposed to do it without hearing that anyway.

I gotta head out the door for a trip, but I'm pretty sure the AIM says that it is the controllers responsibility to advise an aircraft to hold short. It is part of a taxi instruction: "UPS123, runway 5, taxi via Charlie, hold short of the ILS critical area, contact tower when you're holding short of the critical area."
 


Calcapt, you are tarnishing my reputation.

MikeD, beware, Calcapt will only lead you down a path of sin. Both of you boys are utterly naughty.



Tarnished reputations are common around this place. Anybody who knows calcapt already has the mark of debauchery forever attached to them. As the pied piper of nonsense and naughtiness, I welcome friends like MikeD and SteveC to my world. The question is: Are you going to join the utter naughty gang or will you opt to stay on the side of decency and properness? We only have a few memberships remaining so don't take too long to decide. And Qgar, your membership application is being reviewed by the committee - give it a few more days.....
 
Tarnished reputations are common around this place. Anybody who knows calcapt already has the mark of debauchery forever attached to them. As the pied piper of nonsense and naughtiness, I welcome friends like MikeD and SteveC to my world. The question is: Are you going to join the utter naughty gang or will you opt to stay on the side of decency and properness? We only have a few memberships remaining so don't take too long to decide. And Qgar, your membership application is being reviewed by the committee - give it a few more days.....

I'm always open to learning new techniques for partaking in what Obi-Wan described as the "wretched hive of scum and villany":D
 
Tarnished reputations are common around this place. Anybody who knows calcapt already has the mark of debauchery forever attached to them. As the pied piper of nonsense and naughtiness, I welcome friends like MikeD and SteveC to my world. The question is: Are you going to join the utter naughty gang or will you opt to stay on the side of decency and properness? We only have a few memberships remaining so don't take too long to decide. And Qgar, your membership application is being reviewed by the committee - give it a few more days.....


So, I'm not naughty any more? When the hell did THAT happen?! :panic:
 
Just so you know Mike, the Mexican Airforce will not be a threat tonight. I saw their entire fleet of 3 fighters tucked away tonight as I landed in Mexico City. However, keep an eye open for those Canadians as they are a sneaky bunch. They disguise their fighters and bombers as Snowbirds demonstration aircraft, then when you least expect it - BAM, they will drop a load of Mark 84s on your roof. The only alarms you are likely to hear tonight though is from Qgar needing a massage or Toria wanting a ride to Nordstroms. They seem to think they can just snap their fingers and we pilots will come running. Just the other day, Toria told me she had a tumbleweed stuck in her grille and asked if I could remove it? Seriously, where do they come up with the idea that we are here to serve them?



The air reeks of sexual tension. :)
 
Late to the party (spending more time reading about approved methods for repairing wiring and such, yay new job) but if the weather was below 800-2 and I was not told to hold short of the ILS critical area, I would ask. Maybe I'd sound like a knob, but hey, I'd rather ask and be sure.
 
ATC will normally issue instruction to hold short of the critical area when < 800-2. However AIM 2-3-5(b) states...

When the ILS critical area is being protected, the pilot should stop so no part of the aircraft extends beyond the holding position marking. When approaching the holding position marking, a pilot should not cross the marking without ATC clearance. ILS critical area is not clear until all parts of the aircraft have crossed the applicable holding position marking.

To me this seems to imply that you are expected to stop at the critical area even without specific instruction from ATC when < 800-2. (although the AIM says you "should" stop, it doesn't say you "must" stop.)

If the weather is <800-2 I generally ask if they need me to stop at the critical area.
 
If you've been on ground freq you probably don't know whether or not there even IS somebody on the ILS. I'd go all the way up to the runway unless told otherwise. That's what you're cleared and expected to do. It's the same as crossing a runway while taxing to the active. You're not gonna hold short of that either, unless they specify.
:yeahthat:

E_Dawg is correct. The answer is not well defined and the best reference I can find is FAAO 7110.65S, paragraph <?xml:namespace prefix = st1 ns = "urn:schemas-microsoft-com
><st1:date alt=
</st1:date>3-7-5, which addresses the controller's requirement, but does not specify the pilot's actions. However, the logic for only holding at the ILS Critical Area line when instructed to do so (by <st1:stockticker>ATIS</st1:stockticker> or ground control) is that the controller cannot see the aircraft when the weather is that bad and their instructions are based upon the assumption that the next aircraft for takeoff is at the runway hold line. The controller's timing does not include the additional delay while the number one aircraft taxies from the ILS Critical Area line to the runway.
 
So, I'm not naughty any more? When the hell did THAT happen?! :panic:

The committee returned your application after discovering you were not naughty enough. Apparently they had a Private Dick on your trail and he reported back that your lifestyle is pretty boring.

The Committee Chair indicated that you may submit another application in Vegas if your naughtiness ratio improves. There will be on-site trainers in Vegas to assist if needed.

Sorry, I didn't make the decision.....
 
The committee returned your application after discovering you were not naughty enough. Apparently they had a Private Dick on your trail and he reported back that your lifestyle is pretty boring.

The Committee Chair indicated that you may submit another application in Vegas if your naughtiness ratio improves. There will be on-site trainers in Vegas to assist if needed.

Sorry, I didn't make the decision.....

Hmm, that's strange...I never felt a Dick on my trail...
I do, however admit to being a bit boring of late. :o

Sigh...no Vegas for me this year. I'm sure the on-site trainers will be able to assist other NJC'ers though.

If you're reallllly concerned about my naughtiness ratio improving, you'll convince someone to hire me as a FA pronto! :p
 
ATC will normally issue instruction to hold short of the critical area when < 800-2. However AIM 2-3-5(b) states...

When the ILS critical area is being protected, the pilot should stop so no part of the aircraft extends beyond the holding position marking. When approaching the holding position marking, a pilot should not cross the marking without ATC clearance. ILS critical area is not clear until all parts of the aircraft have crossed the applicable holding position marking.

To me this seems to imply that you are expected to stop at the critical area even without specific instruction from ATC when < 800-2. (although the AIM says you "should" stop, it doesn't say you "must" stop.)

If the weather is <800-2 I generally ask if they need me to stop at the critical area.

Hmm it seems to imply to me that "being protected" only occurs when ATC wants it to. Just because the weather is less than 800/2 doesn't mean it's protected; there needs to be some controller action associated with a previous post's quote of the AIM.
 
Hmm it seems to imply to me that "being protected" only occurs when ATC wants it to. Just because the weather is less than 800/2 doesn't mean it's protected; there needs to be some controller action associated with a previous post's quote of the AIM.

I can see how that would be a valid interpretation as well. But the reason I prefer to hold short of the critical area and ask the tower is that AIM 2-3-5 states that you are to hold short of the runway hold short line when instructed by ATC to "hold short" of the runway. For the ILS critical area is states "...a pilot should not cross the marking without ATC clearance". It makes no mention that ATC will always issue a "hold short" for the critical area, only the runway hold short.

I know I probably am reading into it too much. But if the FAA is going to put it in the AIM, I am going to do exactly as it says and let them deal with any grammar errors that may exist in their book. I have never had a tower get upset at me for asking if they want me to hold short of the critical area.
 
I specifically remember reading on this forum one time, DE727UPS saying that a UPS crew had this happen at MHT. The weather was less than 800-2 and they did not hold short at the ILS hold. However, the controller also did not tell them to hold there and supposedly they are supposed to do that. It ended up being that both parties were faulted because there is supposed to be some redundancy where ATC tells them to hold short at the ILS line and the crew is supposed to do it without hearing that anyway.

After reading this, I am going to continue my practice of asking the tower when not advised to hold short with <800-2.
 
Back
Top