My personal opinion is that PCL and Velo call it like they see it. Some people can't handle it because it's not what they want to hear so they say they're being argumentative.
Tough noogies. That's like a woman getting pissed off if you tell her no, those pants do not make you look fat, your extra weight does.
If it's the truth and you can't handle the truth, that's your problem, not mine.
Sometimes, the stuff they say is pretty inflammatory, about as inflammatory as telling your girlfriend she looks fat in those pants. "Calling it as they see it," doesn't need to include remarks that demean others, you can "call it as you see it," and still be professional and chill. Doug calls it as he sees it, however, most of the time it seems people don't notice because he's subtle about it.
As for the truth, there are many versions of it, and none of them may be right, and as for interpretation, when two people don't see eye to eye on an issue, its both of their problems, not "that guys an idiot because he doesn't agree with me."
This thread is pretty much hijacked, and rapidly starting to veer off course. Back on topic.
As for the guy who went to ATPs and has all of the SIC time, ehh, its up to you, I wouldn't even bother. I know a hell of a lot of guys from ATPs that logged all of that Safety Pilot time, and nobody seemed to bat an eye at their interviews. I think a lot of this has to do with how we think the interview process is going down, when really, for the last couple of years, at the regional level anyway there has been very very very little emphasis on this kind of stuff. Mesaba offered me an interview last year and I thought about going, I asked the HR lady what I needed to bring to the interview they said, "Yourself, a photocopy of your medical/pilotcertificate, a copy of the last page in your log book, and a smile." If you get on at a regional with 1000TT or so, by the time you get to a point where you can go to a major (DeltaWest/Continental/etc.) you'll have 5000-10000TT or so. Do you think your 250 ambiguous safety pilot hours are really going to matter? I doubt it. They're going to be more concerned about which airframes your typed in, how demanding your flying was, whether you have any incidents/accidents/LOIs etc. That's what you should be concerned about.