Windy days - flaps anyone?

Baronpilot244

Killick Stoker
I'm curious to see what technique different CFIs use in windy conditions. This afternoon we had winds ranging from about 8 - 9 kts on the low end ocassionally gusting to about 18 or so. Not really a crosswind, in fact it was almost straight down the runway, however it was pretty gusty and we were using a C172.

I got the student to land with no flaps initially then got him to use full flaps and finally we used 10 degrees. I wanted him to see the differences in the handling characteristics using the various settings.

How do you teach landings in windy and gusty conditions in a high wing? Which technique do you prefer? What say you?!

Just curious,

Bp244
 
Well, been a while, but IMS, I'd teach a no or approach flap approach, but also make them land with full flaps in a reasonable crosswind. My philosophy was that I was teaching them how to fly and use their own judgement, rather than adhere to rote numbers.
 
Well, been a while, but IMS, I'd teach a no or approach flap approach, but also make them land with full flaps in a reasonable crosswind. My philosophy was that I was teaching them how to fly and use their own judgement, rather than adhere to rote numbers.

Agree with teach'em to use their own judgement but in a skyhawk to avoid 10 degrees on landing. they seem to be meant for takeoff assistance and not to get down with. My experience tells me 10 degrees just makes you float more. Either put in enough to have a useful effect to the situation or don't.
 
IMO the pilot should be taught to land with no, partial and full flaps. In whatever wind conditions. Unless there is some limitation, the wind and it's velocity an d direction is irrelevant and strictly a matter of preference. In a 172, the only one I avoid in practice is no flaps because I just don,t personally like the view out the window with the more nose up attitude required to maintain proper final approach speed.
 
I teach no, partial, and full flap landings. But when it gets really gusty, I recommend that they use partial flaps (20deg) in the 172. At 20deg I have them fly the approach speed for that flap setting 70kts. That way it gives them more control and a bit more of a safety factor for wind shear.
 
I'm curious to see what technique different CFIs use in windy conditions.

Just curious

In an earlier spin training thread, you, TwoTwoLeft and some others urged me to get acro training. Great advice. Thanks. With a few other students, I snuck off and did it to avoid the disapproval of our CFIs and school who are afraid of spins. We also found some other threads here talking about bush pilot and glider techniques. That's one place we ended up. Glider acro training, cheap but eye opening. Real flying. Those guys love spins.

http://forums.jetcareers.com/threads/holy-spin-training-batman.124123/page-4#post-1722346

One unexpected side benefit of it was looking at their landings. For landings they don't rely on engine power, so even in no wind conditions they Final In fast, faster during windy conditions. More nose level than in powered craft. In the flare they use cross controls to bleed/slip off the airspeed. Practically skid over the runway sideways until they're ready to touch down. In cross winds they just cross control (rudder) into the wind, with opposite aileron. That takes care of wind drift.

I realize this technique isn't completely unheard of to power CFIs, but glider and bush pilot rationale, and the extreme to which they do it amazed us. They think differently about aerodynamics.... no engine flight. Speed is controlled only with attitude. For them it's just a normal day at the office to come slipping down the runway sideways, no flaps, no engine, just plenty of exess airflow over the wings. Most of these guys fly powered also, and they use the same philosophy. Nose down dive onto the runway and slip off the speed at the last second before touching down provides all the cushion they need for the unexpected.

I'll be teaching soon enough. Does anybody else here have a foot in the glider mindset? I'm leaning towards teaching it.
 
Well, been a while, but IMS, I'd teach a no or approach flap approach, but also make them land with full flaps in a reasonable crosswind. My philosophy was that I was teaching them how to fly and use their own judgement, rather than adhere to rote numbers.
Now that's just crazy talk there.
 
That's a really bad sign.

What? That we snuck out without telling them? Or that our CFIs are not comfortable with spins and unusual attitudes? Or both? (one of our older CFI's is not scared of them but he says the school doesn't want him doing them. it's the newer CFI's who shudder when we bring it up.)

I have relatives that grew up doing acro as solo/private level students, and to them that was flying back then. But when I ask about it here, all I get are puzzled looks. "It's not required." "It's too dangerous." "You'll get a demo during the CFI training phase." Demo?

What gives? Seems like that's standard thinking now days at most all schools. Spin demo only at advanced levels, no spin proficiency, no acro. Landings, by the book....... no fancy seat of the pants landings by feel like bush pilots dropping into a valley.
 
Them being scared. If your scared of it, you don't understand it.
Good for you going out and learning something, that while not required will make you a better stick and a far safer pilot.

Don't tell me they're afraid of a full stall to.
 
I can't believe your instructors are "afraid" to teach spins! That's absurd... Perhaps they haven't actually had spin training?? I think spins are not only super fun but essential to learn to be a better pilot. I feel bad for those CFI's who are afraid...what do they plan to do if they ever find themselves in a spin? Cry all the way down?? Sheesh!
 
Them being scared. If your scared of it, you don't understand it.
Good for you going out and learning something, that while not required will make you a better stick and a far safer pilot.

Don't tell me they're afraid of a full stall to.

Thanks to my relatives and JC members who urged us to get the training. But I can't blame the school or CFIs since it seems like pretty much and industry norm now.

And you're right, if you're afraid of a spin then you don't understand it. Just a stall, not much stress on the plane if done right. After we got comfortable with them we were a little worried about the standard training regimine we're getting. I can't understand how stall training is complete unless you're also getting the next step, unintentional spin entry from the stall. Our instructors stress "stall and spin avoidance" as a substitute. Hence, no need to actually practice them. Why practice something you're never going to need? :sarcasm:

I signed up for the missed approach and turbulance avoidance training also. That way I don't have to learn how to handle them either.
 
I can't believe your instructors are "afraid" to teach spins! That's absurd... Perhaps they haven't actually had spin training?? I think spins are not only super fun but essential to learn to be a better pilot. I feel bad for those CFI's who are afraid...what do they plan to do if they ever find themselves in a spin? Cry all the way down?? Sheesh!

Yes. But when we checked around we found that was a common attitude at most schools, especially big ones. It wasn't that we couldn't find it. It's just something the pilot mills avoid until CFI levels for economic and safety reasons. And even at the CFI level, they do the minimum in order to pass the check ride. "Fun" is not part of it. Older CFI's, ex military CFIs, bush and glider pilots, independent CFI's seemed more open to training in them.

Do I have that wrong?
 
18 knots isn't really that much in a 172, I only really messed around with lower flap settings once it got to 30-ish IIRC.
 
Back
Top