I started the ATP program May last year at the Houston location, full 150 day fast track, went to CFI school at the Vegas location and was hired on as a CFI in Oct. I can tell you right now that our experiences of ATP couldn't be more polar opposite!
First off, all the instructors at the DWH location busted their asses in every way possible at all times to help their students. The DPE's at Houston are not being paid under the table or in ATP's back pocket to pass any student, and are held to the same standards listed by the PTS as any other flight school would have. Nothing is handed to you in the training, and as a student you are expected to pull your end so that you can make the deadline of a fast track style training. Which isn't for everyone, maybe yourself included.
Second, I went to the Vegas location for CFI. Oh, which when I called ATP and requested Vegas over Jax they gave me the green light. Funny, I'm a paying customer and got to choose my location!! The entire crew at Vegas was the utmost professional group of trainers again. Mike, the CFI instructor there was working 15 hour days minimum to both teach and fly with us. He was extremely patient and easy going, and busted his ass to help us get through a tough 14 day course. I've heard a lot of bad things about Dan, the manager, but IMO they aren't true. Dan actually took the time to do mock orals with me, simply because I was nervous about the oral exam. And the reason I was nervous is because my DPE had a bunch of negative reviews, which couldn't have been further than the truth.
Third, ATP is hiring as many instructors as they can! There were 12 in my stands class, 14 two weeks later and have a new class of around 12-15 instructors every couple weeks. Everyone that I know that has completed the course, regardless of a few bad reviews has been hired. There are two new Stands instructors, both of which are a professional, and a joy to fly with. My eval rides were with the chief pilot at CRG and John A., and I can easily say those two rides were one of the best learning experiences I had to date!
Now I'm an instructor in Nashville. Our planes are superbly maintained, have a great group of both students and instructors, an FBO that loves us and a great place to fly and build hours. I honestly can't complain about the pay, its inline with most flight schools, and its based on how much you fly. Oh and a nice little $100 Christmas bonus was a nice treat.
I have a full line of personal ideas and attacks I could line up, but I'm gonna leave that alone. But your denial, rationalization and projection are at full tilt! (Check the FOI for definitions!)