My Tomcat buds are going to disagree

On it's past capabilities when in service, somewhat. Great, good or not, those guys loved flying that plane. My old boss is a 2000+ hr Turkey driver and it's the first and only love of his life. He's a Delta guy now....D-Day!!
Well, of course they are going to disagree. Every fighter pilot is going to believe that their steed is the finest aircraft ever to grace the skies.
And, in a way, they'd be correct.
The Tomcat was awesome at what it was designed to do -- be an interceptor that toted around the Phoenix -- at the time it was designed and originally fielded. It was absolutely world class in it's time. Best radar, best avionics, etc. Unfortunately, it was a mediocre dogfighter (I say that with love, in just the same way that the F-15E is a mediocre dogfighter) because of the P-sub-S of that huge/heavy airframe. But, time marched on, and as the 4th generation fighters hit the scene the F-14A was really outclassed.
The F-14B and D upgrades were needed updates by the time they came around. Even the D model, with great engines and a great radar, was still essentially a gussied-up pig (and this is from someone who had the displeasure of getting his ass kicked by one in a BFM engagement in the vertical!) with an avionics suite that lacked multiple sensor integration. It was a great update, but it was far from being the class leader by the time it came out. It more brought the Tomcat from back in the stone age to being up with it's peers.
The
problem, especially in discussions with people who *don't* have 2,000 hours in the Tomcat, is that through the public's exposure to the F-14 in a movie 20 years ago, they've come to believe that it is the end-all, be-all of 3rd generation (and, gag, 4th generation) fighters.
It's like the Phantom, which was phenomenal in it's time, but by the time it was retired it was simply just not able to keep up with peer fielded aircraft. There were certainly a lot of people pining away at how amazing the Phantom was when it was sent to the boneyard, but it was based on what was in their hearts and not reality. Hell, the P-51 was a great fighter in it's time, too, but you don't see anyone thinking of it as an alternative to replace the Eagle or the Hornet, right?
I am just tired of Tomcat fanboys, who really have zero grasp of fighter aviation whatsoever outside what they've seen on TV, talking about what an awesome fighter the F-14 was and that it shouldn't have been retired, etc.
So, again, I'm sure the Tomcatter drivers you know would disagree, and in a way they'd be right. Sort of.
