Wasteful F-22 program terminated

I like how she mentions that it cannot even handle small arms fire, but then at the end comments on how dumb it would be for us to sell it to other countries. If this thing is so weak and lame and melts in the rain, why wouldn't she want us to sell it to other countries?

Thats what I was thinking... Sell um cheap, over sale the resale value. offer over priced extended warranties and let them fall apart. We can slap a GM sticker on the side and be done with it.
 
Well as long as we have the F-35 I'm happy.

The press, Congress, etc, haven't even begun to rip apart the Lightning.

It is so overweight and underperforming that it is not even as agile or fast as the airplane it replaces (the Viper). Great avionics stuffed in a mediocre package designed to make all of it's customers equally unhappy instead of actually being good at any one thing.

Everyone is hanging their hat on it, and it hasn't even operationally flown yet. Can't wait to see what the argument is when it turns out to be a turd and the Raptor-haters don't have a fallback plan.
 
The press, Congress, etc, haven't even begun to rip apart the Lightning.

It is so overweight and underperforming that it is not even as agile or fast as the airplane it replaces (the Viper). Great avionics stuffed in a mediocre package designed to make all of it's customers equally unhappy instead of actually being good at any one thing.

Everyone is hanging their hat on it, and it hasn't even operationally flown yet. Can't wait to see what the argument is when it turns out to be a turd and the Raptor-haters don't have a fallback plan.

Problem is that it promised too much. The technology just isn't there.
 
Well the B-1 was shut down and then restarted later on (albeit a subsonic version). I think should the technology catch up around the world, and we'd want bragging rights to stay with the US, the Raptor's production could be restarted.
 
30 man hours of MX for every hour of flight time is actually about average for a military combat airplane.

I was thinking the same thing. When I was the maintenance officer for a Prowler squadron we were pushing 80 maint hrs per flight hr.
 
Ahh, nothing like Turtleback corrosion on the "Queer Bird". Sniff, I miss her (Don't miss Whidbey though)

Well, I flew Marine Prowlers, so no one dared to call us "Queers" even when we were on the ship.

Incredible Flyin' Chicken Leg? Maybe.
Thunder Guppy? Probably.
Chariot of Electronic Armageddon? Absolutely!

And I do miss Whidbey. I've been trying to get back there since the day I left, but haven't had much luck.
 
I heard that too. I'm sure she meant that the plane can't yet share the data it gets with other systems automatically.

I too x'd the window after I heard that piece of reporting shenanigans. I can't stand that woman to begin with.

I'd love to see a fight between her and Greta. And I hope they both lose.

God I can't stand Rachel Maddow or MSNBC either!

No, I don't like defense programs structured solely to create/preserve jobs. BUT, if we don't stay prepared for a peer-to-peer conflict by staying in the 20th century, we'll someday be caught with our pants down just like on 9/11/01. Just because our primary enemy are terrorists extremists, I wouldn't count on this always being the case.
 
I was thinking the same thing. When I was the maintenance officer for a Prowler squadron we were pushing 80 maint hrs per flight hr.

I'm guessing this is man hours and not straight hours. Even so, I wonder what the MX hours are on an hour of a 747 flight. I would think it is less than 80 otherwise it would be too cost prohibitive. Just a guess. I know it's not apples to apples, but still looking at the cost of it.

As far as the actual report, she didn't do any worse than any other report now-a-days. They know that 99.9% of the public watching didn't even know the F-22 existed. So they can get away with it, not that they should.
 
By the way...I will have "man troubles" for weeks having seen/heard the woman reporting in that video. Makes me thank my lucky stars I can't afford cable.


She resembled a female version of Fred Savage to me. Scared the crap outta me!
 
So this is what the millions of dollars pay for? Engines on mattresses. I bet if you look at the budget the mattresses cost $50,000 each. lol
3000312743_138d2914dc_o.jpg


3001153596_5a49f5ce91_o.jpg
[/QUOTE]
 
The Tomgrape wasn't that good even when it was in service. Why would we ever want to bring it back? The cost to take a 30+ year old dog and make it a contender in the 2010s and beyond would dwarf the cost of just building new Raptors, and it would still yield a pig with lipstick.

My Tomcat buds are going to disagree :) On it's past capabilities when in service, somewhat. Great, good or not, those guys loved flying that plane. My old boss is a 2000+ hr Turkey driver and it's the first and only love of his life. He's a Delta guy now....D-Day!!
 
My Tomcat buds are going to disagree :) On it's past capabilities when in service, somewhat. Great, good or not, those guys loved flying that plane. My old boss is a 2000+ hr Turkey driver and it's the first and only love of his life. He's a Delta guy now....D-Day!!

Well, of course they are going to disagree. Every fighter pilot is going to believe that their steed is the finest aircraft ever to grace the skies.

And, in a way, they'd be correct.

The Tomcat was awesome at what it was designed to do -- be an interceptor that toted around the Phoenix -- at the time it was designed and originally fielded. It was absolutely world class in it's time. Best radar, best avionics, etc. Unfortunately, it was a mediocre dogfighter (I say that with love, in just the same way that the F-15E is a mediocre dogfighter) because of the P-sub-S of that huge/heavy airframe. But, time marched on, and as the 4th generation fighters hit the scene the F-14A was really outclassed.

The F-14B and D upgrades were needed updates by the time they came around. Even the D model, with great engines and a great radar, was still essentially a gussied-up pig (and this is from someone who had the displeasure of getting his ass kicked by one in a BFM engagement in the vertical!) with an avionics suite that lacked multiple sensor integration. It was a great update, but it was far from being the class leader by the time it came out. It more brought the Tomcat from back in the stone age to being up with it's peers.

The problem, especially in discussions with people who *don't* have 2,000 hours in the Tomcat, is that through the public's exposure to the F-14 in a movie 20 years ago, they've come to believe that it is the end-all, be-all of 3rd generation (and, gag, 4th generation) fighters.

It's like the Phantom, which was phenomenal in it's time, but by the time it was retired it was simply just not able to keep up with peer fielded aircraft. There were certainly a lot of people pining away at how amazing the Phantom was when it was sent to the boneyard, but it was based on what was in their hearts and not reality. Hell, the P-51 was a great fighter in it's time, too, but you don't see anyone thinking of it as an alternative to replace the Eagle or the Hornet, right?

I am just tired of Tomcat fanboys, who really have zero grasp of fighter aviation whatsoever outside what they've seen on TV, talking about what an awesome fighter the F-14 was and that it shouldn't have been retired, etc.

So, again, I'm sure the Tomcatter drivers you know would disagree, and in a way they'd be right. Sort of. :)
 
Unfortunately, it was a mediocre dogfighter (I say that with love, in just the same way that the F-15E is a mediocre dogfighter) because of the P-sub-S of that huge/heavy airframe.

What civilians forget (thanks to the movie) is that the F-14 wasn't designed to be a great dogfighter. The ability to mix it up at close range was a secondary consideration.

It was designed protect the carrier from Soviet bombers and if that didn't work, shoot down their antiship missles. We'll never know how well they would have done in that role, but that's what they were built for.
 
The information came from the DoD report on the aircraft. Remember too that the Pentagon wanted to kill it off and direct the funds to new generation aircraft that better meet force requirements...it was a couple of Congressmen that attached the earmark to extend the program.

So...the generals at the Pentagon said, "thanks, but no thanks"...now it seems that you want the politicians to decide what is best??...:confused:

That happens quite often, look at the C-17 program, military brass want to stop the program, California politicans are trying to extend the program.

There is always a problem between:

Military brass that want to stop programs, to spend money on newer programs
Politicians that want to protect jobs in their district
Politicans that are doing the good thing and want to save the taxpayer money.

All three are in constant conflict with each other......
 
It's like the Phantom, which was phenomenal in it's time, but by the time it was retired it was simply just not able to keep up with peer fielded aircraft. There were certainly a lot of people pining away at how amazing the Phantom was when it was sent to the boneyard, but it was based on what was in their hearts and not reality. Hell, the P-51 was a great fighter in it's time, too, but you don't see anyone thinking of it as an alternative to replace the Eagle or the Hornet, right?

You can say that about just about any aircraft that has been retired. By the time it hits the boneyard it's just not able to keep up with it's peers.

The argument I hear is "Well, it may not be state of the art, but it's adequate for the role it serves and maybe if we delay long enough we can skip a generation and save a bunch of money." I haven't heard anyone seriously think it(F14) can compete with the latest designs.
 
That happens quite often, look at the C-17 program, military brass want to stop the program, California politicans are trying to extend the program.

There is always a problem between:

Military brass that want to stop programs, to spend money on newer programs
Politicians that want to protect jobs in their district
Politicans that are doing the good thing and want to save the taxpayer money.

All three are in constant conflict with each other......

Maybe I'm a bit cynical, but I believe many times the Military Brass or the Administration has said publicly that they were against a certain program when they actually wanted it and knew that it would be put back into the budget by a powerful Congressman.
 
Back
Top