dasleben, you can't possibly believe that this is a healthy environment. Yes, SWA took advantage of deregulation (although SWA is a pre-deregulation carrier, contrary to popular belief), and a tiny number of other start-ups have succeeded, but overall, the industry has been a mess. Bankruptcies have been rampant, screwing over vendor after vendor. Tons of carriers have started, and virtually all of them have failed. The lack of stability and the overcapacity have created a mess. Herb Kelleher may praise deregulation, but this is one area where I'm going to have to disagree with my fellow Democrat.
It's not healthy, but that's pretty much my point. Large bailouts have been given to bloated legacy carriers to keep them afloat. This "Too big to fail" mentality only allows unprofitable airlines to remain in business, which muscles out the airlines that are actually able to do well on a particular route for a competitive fare. The failure of numerous non-competitive airlines is simply business. SWA, JetBlue, Virgin, Spirit, etc. also ran that risk at one point or another.
But let's say, for example, that the government came out with a law that required, in the name of fairness, for all airlines to stop competing with one another in certain markets. Because SWA has been the "aggressor" in markets such as Boston, Chicago, Phoenix, Vegas, etc., SWA is required to stand down and give way to, say, American (which lost about $2 billion last year). It's only fair that American be given every opportunity to succeed (they're too big to fail, after all), and SWA's departure would cut down on excessive supply and bring fares up for everyone. What do you think would happen to SWA? SWA, a worthy, healthy competitor to any of these major carriers, would suddenly be taking massive losses. The same would also hold true with JetBlue in JFK and Boston.
No, propping up bad business only hurts good business. Your company epitomizes that competitive spirit, and it's served them well. Your job security, compensation package, and continued profits all hinge on that ability to continue competing.