US House passes $63 million FAA bill.

It's not like I'm looking to make them pay a proportional amount. Right now, they pay 1.6%. That's absurd. I'm just looking for a reasonable increase. No one has ever argued that GA (including corporate and air taxi) should pay based on a proportional share of the traffic that they comprise. I don't see how anyone in his right mind can argue that the current tax burden is even remotely fair.
 
It's not like I'm looking to make them pay a proportional amount. Right now, they pay 1.6%. That's absurd. I'm just looking for a reasonable increase. No one has ever argued that GA (including corporate and air taxi) should pay based on a proportional share of the traffic that they comprise. I don't see how anyone in his right mind can argue that the current tax burden is even remotely fair.


You must not have read my post. When it comes to asses in seats, the airlines are actually getting a pretty sweet deal. If you want to offset some of that cost, raise fairs. 135 passes the cost along to the customer, why are airline not capable of the same?
 
You must not have read my post. When it comes to asses in seats, the airlines are actually getting a pretty sweet deal.

No, I read your post. Apparently you aren't reading mine. Regardless of the number of "asses in seats," the same resources are consumed. Whether it's a Cessna 172 or a Boeing 777, it still uses the same taxiway, the same runway, the same airspace, and the same ATC services. The number of "asses in seats" has no effect on the cost to maintain the infrastructure. That's why the per passengers fees charged on the airlines are ridiculous.

If you want to offset some of that cost, raise fairs. 135 passes the cost along to the customer, why are airline not capable of the same?

Because the market won't support it. If memory serves, you're a pretty conservative, pro-capitalist kind of guy, so you should be pretty familiar with the concepts of supply and demand and how price point affects demand. The market will only bear a certain price point, and we're pretty much there. The problem is that the price point that is supportable by the market has to include all of the taxes that the government requires us to pay, so that reduces the overall fare that we can charge. If a market will only support a price of $250/ticket, and we're required to pay $60 of that in taxes, then we're only getting $190. We can't simply charge $310 to absorb the taxes, because demand would fall off and overall yield would be lower, reducing our profits. All airlines employ yield management specialists and very pricey yield management software to pinpoint the exact price point that a market will bear.
 
No, I read your post. Apparently you aren't reading mine. Regardless of the number of "asses in seats," the same resources are consumed. Whether it's a Cessna 172 or a Boeing 777, it still uses the same taxiway, the same runway, the same airspace, and the same ATC services. The number of "asses in seats" has no effect on the cost to maintain the infrastructure. That's why the per passengers fees charged on the airlines are ridiculous.

The difference is, the most expensive airports to operate are also dominated by Airlines. So saying flyinga 717 vs a 172 costs the same for the system to handle isnt accurate. An airliner landing at PHL or ATL costs way more in support than a 172 landing at WWD.

Because the market won't support it. If memory serves, you're a pretty conservative, pro-capitalist kind of guy, so you should be pretty familiar with the concepts of supply and demand and how price point affects demand. The market will only bear a certain price point, and we're pretty much there. The problem is that the price point that is supportable by the market has to include all of the taxes that the government requires us to pay, so that reduces the overall fare that we can charge. If a market will only support a price of $250/ticket, and we're required to pay $60 of that in taxes, then we're only getting $190. We can't simply charge $310 to absorb the taxes, because demand would fall off and overall yield would be lower, reducing our profits. All airlines employ yield management specialists and very pricey yield management software to pinpoint the exact price point that a market will bear.

Price is only one data point in supply and demand analysis, capacity or more importantly excess capacity is another, more important factor. Excess capacity drives down prices as it increases options. With all the M&A activity excess capacity has been shrinking and if it continues or holds steady and demand picks up then airlines will be able to charge more.

In the past airlines have been guilty of flooding the market with excess capacity to the point that they can not absorb any downturn. I bet if I take a few minutes to look into it I could show load charts pre and post economic downturn and they would tell the story.
 
Because the market won't support it. If memory serves, you're a pretty conservative, pro-capitalist kind of guy, so you should be pretty familiar with the concepts of supply and demand and how price point affects demand.


I would be careful labeling me with anything. I am all over the map. I'm not a red or blue, conservative or liberal. I am whats right for the country to survive.


Look at it like this. You pay into welfare, but you never use it. Should you not have to pay for it now? Or how about the roads that your tax dollars go to that you don't use in your neighborhood? Do you expect to get some oney back for that at then end of they year?

People that make these arguments for user fee's just strike me as whiners. "It's not fair, it's not fair!!!" I have got news for you. Life isn't fair. You end up paying for things that you never use through taxes your whole life. The system we currently have is not broken. The proof is in the new budget. Everything that the FAA wants to do is paid for, and some new things were also intorduced.

Tell me again why we need user fees? Oh yeah, to prop up airlines that have a failing buisness model. Isn't that similar to what we did with the TARP money? Proped up failing business models? While there are some signifigant differences in TARP money and user fee's, the basic premis is the same. People for user fee's want more money in profits, and people against user fee's don't want to give it to them in the form of taxes.

If user fee's are implemented, I hope it goes by the weight of the airplane, like it does on the road.
 
The difference is, the most expensive airports to operate are also dominated by Airlines.

Which is why I'm not advocating for a proportional share of the tax burden. But you keep ignoring the disparity and just keep returning to the AOPA talking points. When will you address the disparity in the airlines covering 98.4% of the revenue, and everyone else only covering 1.6%?

Price is only one data point in supply and demand analysis, capacity or more importantly excess capacity is another, more important factor.

True, but my airline can't stop other airlines from adding capacity. This is why I would support a return to the pre-'78 system of regulation, which prevented overcapacity. An individual airline can't control overcapacity. It can only control its fares and costs.
 
Look at it like this. You pay into welfare, but you never use it. Should you not have to pay for it now? Or how about the roads that your tax dollars go to that you don't use in your neighborhood? Do you expect to get some oney back for that at then end of they year?

It really comes down to what you believe is in the overall interest of society. Welfare prevents people from starving. It's a safety net. Obviously to the benefit of society. I think it's also clear that roads benefit everyone in society. An airport with a 1,500 ft runway far away from any major city is usually not a benefit to society overall. Now, understand, I'm not advocating that we stop funding those airports. I just want the tax burden to be more fairly distributed among the people who use the resources.

The proof is in the new budget. Everything that the FAA wants to do is paid for, and some new things were also introduced.

Not true at all. We've been struggling for years to get NextGen done, and it's still languishing in development hell, with the government wanting the airlines to pick up a lot of the cost for its implementation as well.
 
Which is why I'm not advocating for a proportional share of the tax burden. But you keep ignoring the disparity and just keep returning to the AOPA talking points. When will you address the disparity in the airlines covering 98.4% of the revenue, and everyone else only covering 1.6%?

Airlines are the primary benefactor of the system as it stands today and upgrades are being made for their benefit. While they may foot a large percentage of the bill they also reap the large percentage of the reward. NexGen is not designed to help the 172 or even the corporate operator, but the airlines. Terminals are not built by government money to attract 172's or G-550's but 717'. FBO's foot the bill and pass it on the the 172 and G-550 who come up and fuel, park, clean, cater and rent from them. Runways are not widened or lengthened and taxi ways are not reinforced to support a 172 or a Citation 10 but to handle the 777's and A380's of the airline world.

True, but my airline can't stop other airlines from adding capacity. This is why I would support a return to the pre-'78 system of regulation, which prevented overcapacity. An individual airline can't control overcapacity. It can only control its fares and costs.

Different discussion entirely, but your new employer was able to turn a profit, fuel hedge aside, but differentiating itself from the pack. Not saying every airline can do it, but it can be done. Another option is to stop allowing chapt 11 bankrupcies which would force business to operate within their means and possibly stop fly by night airlines from coming in and dumping seats on the market then going out of business.
 
Airlines are the primary benefactor of the system as it stands today and upgrades are being made for their benefit.

So, just to be clear, your insistence is that the airlines paying 98.4% of the revenue is fair? And you say that with a straight face?

NexGen is not designed to help the 172 or even the corporate operator, but the airlines.

NextGen would benefit everyone, not just the airlines. The ATC system is decades outdated and needs to be replaced.

Terminals are not built by government money to attract 172's or G-550's but 717'.

Actually, most terminals built recently have been funded by the airlines or by local funds, such as bond issuances. The FAA doesn't build them.

Runways are not widened or lengthened and taxi ways are not reinforced to support a 172 or a Citation 10 but to handle the 777's and A380's of the airline world.

Again, this is usually funded from local sources. Cities like to attract business, so they expand runways to do so. Airport authorities and cities also raise money by working out deals with the airlines to cover some of the funding. So, once again, the airlines are expected to pony up for something that is essentially a public utility.

Another option is to stop allowing chapt 11 bankrupcies which would force business to operate within their means and possibly stop fly by night airlines from coming in and dumping seats on the market then going out of business.

Forcing airlines to liquidate rather than reorganizing in Chapter 11 would only make the situation worse. A carrier like AMR liquidating would flood the market with cheap gates, aircraft, slots, and ground support equipment. A slew of start-ups and low-cost carriers would swoop in and grab all of it at bargain-basement prices, and once they get off the ground, the problem is even worse than it was before. You get a short reprieve as the supply is sucked out of the system rapidly, but it all comes back soon, and at even lower cost, forcing fares lower.
 
Forcing airlines to liquidate rather than reorganizing in Chapter 11 would only make the situation worse. A carrier like AMR liquidating would flood the market with cheap gates, aircraft, slots, and ground support equipment. A slew of start-ups and low-cost carriers would swoop in and grab all of it at bargain-basement prices, and once they get off the ground, the problem is even worse than it was before. You get a short reprieve as the supply is sucked out of the system rapidly, but it all comes back soon, and at even lower cost, forcing fares lower.

Actually, you'd find supply sucked up by carriers who might actually be able to sustain a proper business model. Your company expanded like wildfire post-'78 in this very manner, and did quite well. It beat the legacy carriers at their own game, which is what a competitive market should support. If you've noticed, the airlines that have come to being post-regulation (and sustain profitability long enough to grab up significant market share) are generally the most consistent with yearly profits. Regulating a competitive advantage in order to keep an unhealthy airline profitable reduces the ability for other airlines to compete. Being that SWA has been extremely aggressive, this would more than likely affect your own livelihood. Successful business must adapt.

Remember, you owe your career to a lean, aggressive airline that took full advantage of deregulation. Try not to feel bad; that's a good thing. :)
 
It really comes down to what you believe is in the overall interest of society. Welfare prevents people from starving. It's a safety net. Obviously to the benefit of society. I think it's also clear that roads benefit everyone in society. An airport with a 1,500 ft runway far away from any major city is usually not a benefit to society overall. Now, understand, I'm not advocating that we stop funding those airports. I just want the tax burden to be more fairly distributed among the people who use the resources.



Not true at all. We've been struggling for years to get NextGen done, and it's still languishing in development hell, with the government wanting the airlines to pick up a lot of the cost for its implementation as well.

Airlines still use the bulk of the system though. A 13k foot runway costs a lot more to maintain than a 1500ft one. Flying from BOS to LAX costs a lot more than it does for grandpa to depart CMA and not talk to anyone again till he gets to SMX. You and I both know that the majority of airtraffic that is talking to ATC the entire flight is not GA. GA might use some of the same airports, and there may not be as many airports accessable to you because of what you fly, but the fact still remains that in my opnion the split is fairly even, if not for the simple fact of when was the last time you heard a C172 check on the frequency saying "Cessna 172, flight level 220." You are only looking at it from the side of the airline. Me, being in GA, feel like I see both sides of the coin, because I operate in a system desgined around the airlines. I fly into and out of the "little airports" as well as the big ones, in my "little" airplane. The majority of the traffic I hear on the radio is airlines. Most airports are self supporting. The money they collect in the form of other fee's helps to pay for their existance, and when it doesn't, they usually get shut down. Look at how many airports have been done away with in the last 30 years because the city that they were in couldn't justify the expense of keeping them open anymore and were able to get more money in property tax from home and business than what they were collecting from the airport.


As for struggling to get NextGen done for years, no [sensoed]. The FAA has been operating on temporary budget extensions for years. Now that there is a budget, it's finally in there. Estimated cost to implement by 2025 is between $15b and $22b. This year, if I read the budget right, there is more than $1.236b in there for NextGen. So, if those numbers stay the same, and the FAA manages to keep it within budget, the system should be implemented on time. Tell me how user fee's are going to make a dent in that number? I just fail to see how the collection of $100 per flight of the GA that actually uses the system will #1, make a dent, and #2, is justified. The guy that uses the system to take off and land at an airport then is on his way not talking to anyone is not a burdon on the system. And the percentage of GA that uses the system from point a to point b, I would reason, makes up less than 15% of it's total use. While that number does come from the hip, it's also from personal experince in the system.


*note* Use caution, I didn't bother spell checking!
 
dasleben, you can't possibly believe that this is a healthy environment. Yes, SWA took advantage of deregulation (although SWA is a pre-deregulation carrier, contrary to popular belief), and a tiny number of other start-ups have succeeded, but overall, the industry has been a mess. Bankruptcies have been rampant, screwing over vendor after vendor. Tons of carriers have started, and virtually all of them have failed. The lack of stability and the overcapacity have created a mess. Herb Kelleher may praise deregulation, but this is one area where I'm going to have to disagree with my fellow Democrat. ;)
 
mshunter, even if I were to concede to all of your points (which I don't), you still can't get past the raw numbers that 98.4% of the revenue collected is coming from the airlines. Using your WAG of 15% of the usage being GA (ridiculously low, in my opinion, but for the sake of argument), why do you not feel it fair that GA contribute 15% of the revenue? For the life of me, I can't figure out how any reasonable person can defend 1.6% of the revenue coming from all of the other traffic, while the airlines pick up 98.4%. It is patently absurd.
 
To include every bugsmasher VFR flight around the pattern in your 80% useage of the system is absurd. He doesn't use ATC at all, and the airport was built 60 years ago, and the county pays to keep it painted every 10 years. The FAA doesn't pay a dime.

Overall, the companies that use the system the most (airlines, 135, and corporate) pay the most.
 
To include every bugsmasher VFR flight around the pattern in your 80% useage of the system is absurd. He doesn't use ATC at all, and the airport was built 60 years ago, and the county pays to keep it painted every 10 years. The FAA doesn't pay a dime.

Overall, the companies that use the system the most (airlines, 135, and corporate) pay the most.

Consider the source. There is so much I want to say, but this isn't the place.
 
dasleben, you can't possibly believe that this is a healthy environment. Yes, SWA took advantage of deregulation (although SWA is a pre-deregulation carrier, contrary to popular belief), and a tiny number of other start-ups have succeeded, but overall, the industry has been a mess. Bankruptcies have been rampant, screwing over vendor after vendor. Tons of carriers have started, and virtually all of them have failed. The lack of stability and the overcapacity have created a mess. Herb Kelleher may praise deregulation, but this is one area where I'm going to have to disagree with my fellow Democrat. ;)

It's not healthy, but that's pretty much my point. Large bailouts have been given to bloated legacy carriers to keep them afloat. This "Too big to fail" mentality only allows unprofitable airlines to remain in business, which muscles out the airlines that are actually able to do well on a particular route for a competitive fare. The failure of numerous non-competitive airlines is simply business. SWA, JetBlue, Virgin, Spirit, etc. also ran that risk at one point or another.

But let's say, for example, that the government came out with a law that required, in the name of fairness, for all airlines to stop competing with one another in certain markets. Because SWA has been the "aggressor" in markets such as Boston, Chicago, Phoenix, Vegas, etc., SWA is required to stand down and give way to, say, American (which lost about $2 billion last year). It's only fair that American be given every opportunity to succeed (they're too big to fail, after all), and SWA's departure would cut down on excessive supply and bring fares up for everyone. What do you think would happen to SWA? SWA, a worthy, healthy competitor to any of these major carriers, would suddenly be taking massive losses. The same would also hold true with JetBlue in JFK and Boston.

No, propping up bad business only hurts good business. Your company epitomizes that competitive spirit, and it's served them well. Your job security, compensation package, and continued profits all hinge on that ability to continue competing.
 
Obviously, I have a much different philosophy when it comes to "bailouts" than you do. I view the government assistance of the Detroit automakers to be an unmitigated success. Had the government stepped in and assisted the airlines in the wake of 9/11, a similar success story may have emerged. Unfettered capitalism is a disaster, but you and I will never agree on that particular topic. :)

As far as regulation, you should do a little more research into how the CAB worked and how stable the industry was under a regulated system. What you suggest about airlines being forced into money-losing situations in order to prop up other airlines never happened.
 
Obviously, I have a much different philosophy when it comes to "bailouts" than you do. I view the government assistance of the Detroit automakers to be an unmitigated success. Had the government stepped in and assisted the airlines in the wake of 9/11, a similar success story may have emerged. Unfettered capitalism is a disaster, but you and I will never agree on that particular topic. :)

As far as regulation, you should do a little more research into how the CAB worked and how stable the industry was under a regulated system. What you suggest about airlines being forced into money-losing situations in order to prop up other airlines never happened.

I know that things were decent under the CAB (for a select few airlines), however, I'm talking about the effects of re-regulation today. The overabundance of supply would have to be taken care of in some manner, and that would require removing airlines from a number of markets. SWA would undoubtedly be affected, adversely.

You may not believe much in capitalism, but I virtually guarantee that the majority of your new coworkers do. They realize that they owe their careers to it. Without deregulation, SWA would be just that little airline in Texas, perhaps already passed from memory. You don't answer to me, but you do answer to your coworkers whom you may represent as a union official. I mean that in a completely non-confrontational manner; I simply hope you realize what deregulation has done for your career, and the careers of your fellow pilots.
 
Back
Top