Training In Diamond Aircraft

Interesting viewpoints. I'm still waiting on a perspective about the Pipers. Are Pipers an option for you as well?

C-172 vs PA-28

Same wing

Same engine

Same performance

Wing bolted to different part of fuselage.

PA-28 has slightly better visibility flying around the pattern.

All other differences are so subtle that a student pilot won't notice.
 
All my training was done in Da-20 and the best part about it is, when you go to a different school and you can't land a piper archer, you can blame it on the Katana. ha ha ha aha haha hhhhaaaaah:cwm27: :D:sarcasm:

hope my instructor does'nt read this.:D:D
 
I personally like flying both the 20 and 40, the 20 is a little small if you’re over six feet tall and over 220. Really neither Cessna or Diamond are that much better than each other in my opinion. Its just nice to have the little bit of extra speed that Diamonds provide.

I've only been in a 20 and it was cramped like no other. Please tell me the 42 is a lot roomier because I'm starting my twin training in one pretty soon. I'm 6'4'' and got major neck aches having to duck my head down for a 2 hour xc.
 
All my training was done in Da-20 and the best part about it is, when you go to a different school and you can't land a piper archer, you can blame it on the Katana. ha ha ha aha haha hhhhaaaaah:cwm27: :D:sarcasm:

hope my instructor does'nt read this.:D:D
Its true though.

I've only been in a 20 and it was cramped like no other. Please tell me the 42 is a lot roomier because I'm starting my twin training in one pretty soon. I'm 6'4'' and got major neck aches having to duck my head down for a 2 hour xc.
It is a little better, but not much, I'm 5'11" and I hit my head all the time.
 
Interesting viewpoints. I'm still waiting on a perspective about the Pipers. Are Pipers an option for you as well?


Piper is an option as well. I guess I just over looked them since I was too focused on the Cessna Vs. Diamond thing.

One of the schools actually has very nice Pipers. Late 80's models but in GREAT condition. They also have a two Aztecs which they use for multi-training.
 
C-172 vs PA-28

Same wing

Same engine

Same performance

Wing bolted to different part of fuselage.

PA-28 has slightly better visibility flying around the pattern.

All other differences are so subtle that a student pilot won't notice.


Personally, the differences are more subtle than I was comfortable, so I opted to train more in the Pipers vice the Cessnas. That "more aerodynamically stable" philosophy behind the Cessnas for means "float" which is not comfortable for me at all. The "fly the land till landing" aspect of the Piper felt much better to me. I'm believing that process is similar to the Diamond as well. True?
 
Personally, the differences are more subtle than I was comfortable, so I opted to train more in the Pipers vice the Cessnas. That "more aerodynamically stable" philosophy behind the Cessnas for means "float" which is not comfortable for me at all. The "fly the land till landing" aspect of the Piper felt much better to me. I'm believing that process is similar to the Diamond as well. True?


I was under the impression that the Piper's (or all low wing aircraft) tend to float more due to the wing being closer to the surface during landing?:confused:
 
Personally, the differences are more subtle than I was comfortable, so I opted to train more in the Pipers vice the Cessnas. That "more aerodynamically stable" philosophy behind the Cessnas for means "float" which is not comfortable for me at all. The "fly the land till landing" aspect of the Piper felt much better to me. I'm believing that process is similar to the Diamond as well. True?
The DA-20 floats worse than any other plane I have ever flown.
 
I got equal float in both the PA-28 and 172. A majority of my training has been done in the Piper. When I have a choice I always take the Piper. I prefer the way it handles to the Cessna. Also the flaps are easier to use as opposed to the smaller handled electric flaps in the 172. I constantly over shoot the flap position. They are too touchy. I think there visibility is a lot better in the Piper with its larger windows. The one think I hate about the Piper is that it only has ONE DOOR. WTF is up with that. Anyway the 172 is a great airplane as well. I have yet to fly a Diamond and would if I had the chance.:)
 
I got equal float in both the PA-28 and 172. A majority of my training has been done in the Piper. When I have a choice I always take the Piper. I prefer the way it handles to the Cessna. Also the flaps are easier to use as opposed to the smaller handled electric flaps in the 172. I constantly over shoot the flap position. They are too touchy. I think there visibility is a lot better in the Piper with its larger windows. The one think I hate about the Piper is that it only has ONE DOOR. WTF is up with that. Anyway the 172 is a great airplane as well. I have yet to fly a Diamond and would if I had the chance.:)

. . . in that case, I'll defer to you for a perspective. My CFI always taught me to fly the Piper to the ground usually around 70/75 knots. When I flew the Cessna, it was "right before touchdown" flare to the point you're close/almost at stall, then gently touch. . .something you don't do with larger aircraft. Do you have to change landing characteristics with a Cessna moreso than with a Piper?
 
Interesting. I wasn't aware of the characteristic.
The glide ratio of the DA20 is 11:1

It will float for miles if you come in any faster than 55 KIAS, or if the throttle is not entirely out, or the idle is set a little high, if you have a hot runway..............
 
. . . in that case, I'll defer to you for a perspective. My CFI always taught me to fly the Piper to the ground usually around 70/75 knots. When I flew the Cessna, it was "right before touchdown" flare to the point you're close/almost at stall, then gently touch. . .something you don't do with larger aircraft. Do you have to change landing characteristics with a Cessna moreso than with a Piper?

We just went through slow flight on both models. That way I can see and feel where they differ in a landing configuration before doing the actual landing. I have never really been able to tell the difference between the 2 when landing as far as float.The again I dont have too much 172 time at all. Its all in the flare. ;)
 
It will float for miles if you come in any faster than 55 KIAS, or if the throttle is not entirely out, or the idle is set a little high, if you have a hot runway..............

No flap landings are the challange in the DA-20. Rember that it was orgionaly a motor glider, and there is very little drag.

Without flaps you can not have ANY extra energy (altitude or airspeed) and expect to make it to the runway.
 
I've tried to stay out of this one for a while. . .but i feel that I now must comment. :)

I trained for my PPL in a C172K/M series. It was a beast of an airplane, like any 172 - a blast to fly. BUT. . .

Transitioning to the DA20's for my instrument took about two weeks to finally get a good handle on the airplane, and getting a good handle on energy management. Landings are the first thing to go when your in instrument training, but nevertheless the DA20 can be a bear to land if you are overspeed (clean or dirty).

The DA40 is a slightly different story. It does like to float, but certainly not as much as it's older and smaller sibling - DA20. The 40 offers you a bit more weight comparision to a 172, but it is composite, and as composites go. . .they do handle a bit different than old school metal airplanes.

The DA42 Twinstar, well, since I haven't ever flown any other GA twins I really can't comment. It lands like a big soft pillow though. :)

But yes, as USMCmech has said. . .any excess energy will lead to a float of some sort. . .it's bound to happen with the DA20's, less so with the DA40s. Expect and plan for it.

The DA20's offer a wide range of approach speeds. . .(65-50kts). 65 for a normal approach, and 55-50 for a short field approach / landing. Find an airspeed that works for you during normal conditions (<5kt headwind) and adjust it as needed for conditions. I personally have found a nice 58-60kts to work best.

You'll eventually fall in love with flying the DA20. Some call it the sports car of the sky, I'll hold back on that and just call it the Miata of the sky.
 
Oh hell, you can float a EMB-145 if you come in too fast. Learn how to land your airplane, instead of blaming it.

Mike
P.S. The DA20-C1 rocks! :rawk:
 
I just recently just started my Multi-Commercial add on in the DA-42. I have to agree with most of you here that it is an AWESOME plane to fly, but its far from the best multi trainer. I've flown complex planes before with prop and mixture control so at least I have some experience with that, but in the future students will have no idea what prop or mixture is.

The actual aircraft is a beast. It climbs like no ones business and glides like a 172. However, as previously said the seats are awful.

DA-42= Jet with P-Factor :D
 
No flap landings are the challange in the DA-20. Rember that it was orgionaly a motor glider, and there is very little drag.

Without flaps you can not have ANY extra energy (altitude or airspeed) and expect to make it to the runway.

That is actually my favorite thing to pull while doing stage checks, or rental checkouts in the DA20. I have found that a lot of instructors don't throw a flap motor failure into the training. I pull the breaker, pull the throttle and tell them that going around is not an option.

It still amazes me how many run out of runway before I have to put the throttle back in.

Learn how to land your airplane, instead of blaming it.

Hells:yeahthat:
 
Oh hell, you can float a EMB-145 if you come in too fast. Learn how to land your airplane, instead of blaming it.

Mike
P.S. The DA20-C1 rocks! :rawk:

Exactly!

One can make any plane float. . .know your plane. . .make it work. Don't blame the plane.
 
Hey PGA,

I finally found my way over…

FWIW I have been instructing in the DA-20 for the past several years here at the AF Academy. Although, now that the contract with ERAU has ended, I will be flying something else.

I found the DA-20 to be a fun little airplane with good characteristics. It did have some lateral instability but nothing you couldn’t overcome. It was also very under-powered here at our altitudes. We routinely have DA’s over 9500’ during the summer months so we had to be very careful with our operations. For the record when I flew one back to the Chicago area a few summers ago I was amazed at much better it performed at lower altitudes.

As others have mentioned it is based on a motor glider so it is a very clean aircraft with a very high glide ratio compared to other trainers. As a result you will need to keep an eye on / manage your energy a bit more then a Cessna.

And as far as the stick goes…no worries there…it will be a seamless transition back and forth. I would actually much prefer to fly a stick myself!!

With all that said I would have no problem teaching my wife and kids to fly in a DA-20.

Cheers,


PS I leave to hunt IL tomorrow and I got some good news from a buddy at Air New Zealand…all is right with the world!! Hope your season is going well.

 
Back
Top