Thoughts On AOPA

TravDK

Well-Known Member
Just curious what some think about AOPA. Being a student, soon to be private pilot going on to ATP or such, is it worth the money? (29.90 to be exact) I get a freaking letter every week letting me know about a new 'special offer' which is the same as the last letter. I do enjoy the training magazine as flying is still new to me and I do not mind spending thirty bucks for something I will use, but besides an AOPA card with my name on it... worth it?
 
I have been a long time member of AOPA. I like their magazines, both Training and Pilot. I also use them to download approach plates, but you can do that from many places for free. I also have emailed them several questions during my training and instructor days (that was before I knew about JC!). It is good, but other than that, I don't know what makes it worth the money!
 
Just curious what some think about AOPA. Being a student, soon to be private pilot going on to ATP or such, is it worth the money? (29.90 to be exact) I get a freaking letter every week letting me know about a new 'special offer' which is the same as the last letter. I do enjoy the training magazine as flying is still new to me and I do not mind spending thirty bucks for something I will use, but besides an AOPA card with my name on it... worth it?


AOPA is useless and worthless. Phil Boyer writes each month in his column reminding everyone that AOPA fights for pilots rights like we need a constant reminder of their perceived power on Capitol Hill. Yet the Baltimore/Washington ADIZ still exists and user fees are most likely right around the corner.
 
AOPA is useless and worthless. Phil Boyer writes each month in his column reminding everyone that AOPA fights for pilots rights like we need a constant reminder of their perceived power on Capitol Hill. Yet the Baltimore/Washington ADIZ still exists and user fees are most likely right around the corner.

Right...:whatever: I don't know where GA would be right now without AOPA, but it would most likely not exist or would not be worthwhile.

TravDK, AOPA is a very important organization to belong to, as they help us fight for our rights. Unfortunately they can't do everything for us, and we also have to fight for those rights in the form of communicating our opinions with our representatives.

I've met an unfortunate amount of pilots that are part of the "entitlement" group that is overwhelming our country. They feel everything should be done for them, such as all of the political fighting that is occuring right now. This is a defeatist attitude and is very selfish and quite frankly PATHETIC. We must fight along with AOPA and join in their plans as they develop. This is the only way we're going to keep our flying freedoms.

emb145, you've obviously given up already, and you are useless to us as a pilot group. Why not just stay the heck out of these coversations and stick to whatever it is you do?
 
AOPA is useless and worthless. Phil Boyer writes each month in his column reminding everyone that AOPA fights for pilots rights like we need a constant reminder of their perceived power on Capitol Hill. Yet the Baltimore/Washington ADIZ still exists and user fees are most likely right around the corner.

This has to be the most ill informed post I've seen on this site.

Do you know what kind of influence they have within the FAA? Do you know how effective they are influencing members of Congress when they are unsuccessful in affecting change within the agency?

User fees are DOA and you know who you can thank? AOPA's lobbying was instrumental in forming the Congressional opposition that has in all likelihood killed the User Fee proposal put forth by the Administrator and the airlines.

I work as a contractor in FAA HQ and can tell you when it comes to GA, AOPA's voice is heard and their clout is understood. I have seen if first hand and know for a fact that we (GA) would be completely screwed, were it not for their efforts. I kid you not and am not overstating the case. I have been treated like a leaper when I've asked about how GA fit into some of the work going on at FAA.

If you don't like Boyer blowing his own horn, don't read it but don't for a minute believe that the ADIZ wouldn't be bigger and more restrictive if AOPA didn't fight back. Some fights take time, and some like the ADIZ you may never win, but I've seen first hand how AOPA's influence can affect they way things are done at the FAA.
 
AOPA is well worth it for the GA pilot. Just like ALPA for (some) Professional pilots they provide a wealth of services for their members. There is NO other GA advocate out there.

That said, I was only a member for one year due to the fact that despite the fact that I told them not to they sold my name to King Schools. They lost me for life after that.
 
Other quick benefits of AOPA;

A great legal plan that allows me 10 hours legal consult in the event I need to be defended/informed

A fantastic website that has lots of useful information

However, I remember being a student and being completely broke. I am not sure I would put it at the top of a list of to-do's until you have a little extra cash.

Bill
 
AOPA is useless and worthless. Phil Boyer writes each month in his column reminding everyone that AOPA fights for pilots rights like we need a constant reminder of their perceived power on Capitol Hill. Yet the Baltimore/Washington ADIZ still exists and user fees are most likely right around the corner.

without AOPA the ADIZ would be bigger, there would be one around chicago, one around micky mouse and you would not be able to enter class B airspace anywhere. User fees would have been here a decade ago and ATC would be privatized, being run by the airlines, for the airlines. GA would be dead.

Dont worry though, by the time you get around to undertanding what AOPA does for you as a GA pilot you will probably be far enough along to start complaining about ALPA and having to pay your 1.95% for "nothing".
 
AOPA's about the last line of defense from the US skies becoming as unfriendly as Europe is to General Aviation.

I guess I need to get off my arse and renew my membership.
 
Yeah, AOPA is good stuff. Their legal defense alone is worth the 30 bucks. Think of it as "legal insurance". AOPA and EAA are the only 2 groups with any clout in DC that support general aviation, and I support both of them.
 
Another vote for AOPA here. The benefits you receive are far more valuable than $30.

emb145 is entitled to his opinion, but I think you'll find the pros outweigh the cons.
 
I will wait until I pass my first checkride, but I will join. I was just a little skeptical because I get a letter litterally twice a month and I felt bothered. If $30 helps towards keeping GA the way it is, the magazines and website are a free gift! Thank you all.
 
They will also save you $10.00 on each written. I've already recouped my membership fee's with the written's I've taken the last couple month's.
 
I just signed up a few weeks ago The legal services are nice and their insurance plans aren't bad either.
 
I have been a member of AOPA for since 2000. I think they offer a lot of great services from the pilot's perspective.

However I sometimes wonder about some of their views. I work for a company that does a lot of national airpace modernization research for the FAA. It seems like AOPA is against a lot of stuff and it doesn't really make sense why.

For example there is a real need for phasing out the domestic flight plan and using the ICAO flight plan (for some of the performance based nav stuff planned for the future) but AOPA keeps throwing bricks in the way and complains about how it will be too much of a pain for GA. :banghead:

But their magazines, legal services, cheaper hull insurance premiums for rentals etc are very good.
 
I have been a member of AOPA for since 2000. I think they offer a lot of great services from the pilot's perspective.

However I sometimes wonder about some of their views. I work for a company that does a lot of national airpace modernization research for the FAA. It seems like AOPA is against a lot of stuff and it doesn't really make sense why.

For example there is a real need for phasing out the domestic flight plan and using the ICAO flight plan (for some of the performance based nav stuff planned for the future) but AOPA keeps throwing bricks in the way and complains about how it will be too much of a pain for GA. :banghead:

But their magazines, legal services, cheaper hull insurance premiums for rentals etc are very good.

I can't say why AOPA takes that postion but perhaps it has to do with the way NextGen is currently defined by JPDO and the FAA. If you read the NextGen Concept of Operations it looks like a huge airspace grab favoring the airlines.

Just list the equipment you need for this "performance based" airspace beng bandied about within the FAA.

You're talking about digital datalink communications, advanced FMS's and RNP 0.3 or better certified nav systems at a mininum. High end stuff that is not going to be affordable for most GA aircraft.

Now ask where this airspace will be. Answer: We're not sure, but pretty much everywhere, including major metro areas where there are multiple airports interacting.

Now ask when less equipped aircraft can fly there. Answer: Whenever they are not doing "performance based" operations. (ie: When the airlines are not flying there) You might as well call them airline exclusive zones because that is what they will amount to, and again we are talking around major metro areas not just the big airports.

I have been in meetings with JPDO where these questions were asked, and they never get answered any more clearly. From what I can tell AOPA is not having much more luck, but at least have a seat at the table and they can influence the folks holding the congressional purse strings if they can't manage to affect change within FAA.

Add the fact that FAA is the most inefficent organization I've ever seen in 25 plus years experience across 4 different industries. For any given project, there will be many, many, many competing groups within FAA, all spending huge sums of money on simular but uncoordinated development efforts. You can start to see why NextGen and the user fee debate have become my hot button issues as a GA pilot and aircraft owner.
 
I will wait until I pass my first checkride, but I will join. I was just a little skeptical because I get a letter litterally twice a month and I felt bothered. If $30 helps towards keeping GA the way it is, the magazines and website are a free gift! Thank you all.
Only two a month? I just handled a backlog of about six for the past two weeks. Of course I just bought the additional legal plan, insurance, donated $20 to Flight Saftey, and renewed my membership so they may have me on three or four different lists as somebody that responds to the mailings.

Seriously though, I think all the products and benefits that I have gotten from AOPA in the last two years have vastly outweighed the money I have sent their way. Saving $10 on each written has already paid for the membership. Downloading approach plates, the free flight planner, discounts on hotels and car rentals, the magazines, all the info on the members website, etc....... All worth more than the membership price.
 
I can't say why AOPA takes that postion but perhaps it has to do with the way NextGen is currently defined by JPDO and the FAA. If you read the NextGen Concept of Operations it looks like a huge airspace grab favoring the airlines.

Just list the equipment you need for this "performance based" airspace beng bandied about within the FAA.

You're talking about digital datalink communications, advanced FMS's and RNP 0.3 or better certified nav systems at a mininum. High end stuff that is not going to be affordable for most GA aircraft.

Now ask where this airspace will be. Answer: We're not sure, but pretty much everywhere, including major metro areas where there are multiple airports interacting.

Now ask when less equipped aircraft can fly there. Answer: Whenever they are not doing "performance based" operations. (ie: When the airlines are not flying there) You might as well call them airline exclusive zones because that is what they will amount to, and again we are talking around major metro areas not just the big airports.

I have been in meetings with JPDO where these questions were asked, and they never get answered any more clearly. From what I can tell AOPA is not having much more luck, but at least have a seat at the table and they can influence the folks holding the congressional purse strings if they can't manage to affect change within FAA.

Add the fact that FAA is the most inefficent organization I've ever seen in 25 plus years experience across 4 different industries. For any given project, there will be many, many, many competing groups within FAA, all spending huge sums of money on simular but uncoordinated development efforts. You can start to see why NextGen and the user fee debate have become my hot button issues as a GA pilot and aircraft owner.

I undertsand your point about nextgen. You might already be aware but the latest and greatest concept is Performance ATM (P-ATM) which the FAA has already accepted and is being sold to congress. Basically P-ATM comes online in the 2017 time frame and is meant to be the way to reach NGATS. With that concept, there will always be traditional airspace where less equipped aircraft can continue to fly. I think that it is fair to expect GPS on all aircraft by then. Now data-link is another issue. I agree that FMS on GA aircraft is asking to much.

I was thinking more about the current flight plan. The US domestic flight plan is really limiting in the way some things can be described (such as /E nav indicator meaning Dual DME IRU). We are running out of letters to describe equipage since only one character is allowed. Going to ICAO will open up a lot of options, not to mention harmonizing globally which will be a good thing.
 
I undertsand your point about nextgen. You might already be aware but the latest and greatest concept is Performance ATM (P-ATM) which the FAA has already accepted and is being sold to congress. Basically P-ATM comes online in the 2017 time frame and is meant to be the way to reach NGATS. With that concept, there will always be traditional airspace where less equipped aircraft can continue to fly. I think that it is fair to expect GPS on all aircraft by then. Now data-link is another issue. I agree that FMS on GA aircraft is asking to much.

I was thinking more about the current flight plan. The US domestic flight plan is really limiting in the way some things can be described (such as /E nav indicator meaning Dual DME IRU). We are running out of letters to describe equipage since only one character is allowed. Going to ICAO will open up a lot of options, not to mention harmonizing globally which will be a good thing.

And you may have noticed that NextGen changes EVERY WEEK. Heck it just became NextGen a month or so ago, apparently because someone got tired of calling it NGATS. The reason it changes every month/week/day is because it is nothing but a bucket of ideas that may or may not work, and if they work, may not be affordable.

No one, I repeat, No one in the FAA/JPDO can tell you what exactly NextGen is, where the new airspace will exisit (or conversely where it won't), what it will cost the FAA or what it would cost the folks expected to operate in the system. The analysis just has not been done.

As to the assurances of there always being "traditional airspace" for GA, you'll have to forgive me for being highly skeptical. I've been party to the JPDO discussions and it becomes apparent that "tradtional airspace" is whatever is left over after all the whiz-bang stuff is in place, and the JPDO sees the whiz-bang going everywhere. When they are done "Traditional Airspace" will be the small part of northern North Dakota where the rich dilitantes (ie GA) go to fly their little toys (ie anything smaller than an RJ) in endless circles.

If anything has really been sold to congress it is vaporware, because Nextgen is still really just a bunch of concepts. The next few years will see which concepts survive.
 
Back
Top