I can't say why AOPA takes that postion but perhaps it has to do with the way NextGen is currently defined by JPDO and the FAA. If you read the NextGen Concept of Operations it looks like a huge airspace grab favoring the airlines.
Just list the equipment you need for this "performance based" airspace beng bandied about within the FAA.
You're talking about digital datalink communications, advanced FMS's and RNP 0.3 or better certified nav systems at a mininum. High end stuff that is not going to be affordable for most GA aircraft.
Now ask where this airspace will be. Answer: We're not sure, but pretty much everywhere, including major metro areas where there are multiple airports interacting.
Now ask when less equipped aircraft can fly there. Answer: Whenever they are not doing "performance based" operations. (ie: When the airlines are not flying there) You might as well call them airline exclusive zones because that is what they will amount to, and again we are talking around major metro areas not just the big airports.
I have been in meetings with JPDO where these questions were asked, and they never get answered any more clearly. From what I can tell AOPA is not having much more luck, but at least have a seat at the table and they can influence the folks holding the congressional purse strings if they can't manage to affect change within FAA.
Add the fact that FAA is the most inefficent organization I've ever seen in 25 plus years experience across 4 different industries. For any given project, there will be many, many, many competing groups within FAA, all spending huge sums of money on simular but uncoordinated development efforts. You can start to see why NextGen and the user fee debate have become my hot button issues as a GA pilot and aircraft owner.