Supreme Court: Cirrus not liable for fatal plane crash

Seeing as the pilot who flew the plane had his PPL and made the PIC decision to fly in IMC despite receiving (hopefully) the proper training in which he was required to pass a checkride, I have no way of seeing how this is Cirrus' fault.

I remember back when I was doing my CFI training, my instructor pounded liability into me. He talked a lot about keeping good records saying that if anything ever happens, the survivors/family will sue whoever they can (aircraft manufacturer, flight school, instructor, engine manufacturer, etc) regardless of rationality to try and get some closure out of it. It appears this was the case here.
 
I'm curious as to why UND was involved in this. Did UND back in the day offer training to people outside of the aviation school through part 61? Or did Cirrus send him to UND to observe flights (to my understanding UND use to have either SR20s or SR22s)
 
I'm curious as to why UND was involved in this. Did UND back in the day offer training to people outside of the aviation school through part 61? Or did Cirrus send him to UND to observe flights (to my understanding UND use to have either SR20s or SR22s)

Maybe he bought one of the two they were testing out for their program and then sold.
 
I'm curious as to why UND was involved in this. Did UND back in the day offer training to people outside of the aviation school through part 61? Or did Cirrus send him to UND to observe flights (to my understanding UND use to have either SR20s or SR22s)

Maybe he bought one of the two they were testing out for their program and then sold.


While a part of UND it was a seperate unit from the main fligth school. Basically they were contracted to provide training for new purchases from Cirrus.
 
This whole case reminds me of the Carnahan crash in MO several years back. If our Tort laws changed we would stop seeing BS cases like this.
These cases really chap my back side.....
 
You want our tort laws to change so that Cirrus loses cases like this?
I'm hoping he means that the laws cover more backsides. Or perhaps he is confusing the tort laws with the liability that aircraft manufacturers were exposed to before tort reform.
 
You want our tort laws to change so that Cirrus loses cases like this?
Of course that's EXACTLY what I meant! I think that I should be able to hop in a plane and takeoff without ANY training at all, crash, and then my family gets to sue (and win) because I was a total idiot! You figured me out!

A change in Tort laws would NOT have had an effect on the outcome of this (or the Carnahan) case.
I'm hoping he means that the laws cover more backsides. Or perhaps he is confusing the tort laws with the liability that aircraft manufacturers were exposed to before tort reform.
There is no confusion on my part; I understand the difference between the two. The tort reform that you mention ONLY limited the number of YEARS that a manufacturer would be on the hook but little else.

My hope for a change would result in these cases never seeing the courts in the first place. As the laws are written today, I can sue you for almost anything. All I have to do is to find an attorney willing to "roll the dice" on my behalf. The families here are just hoping that the ruling or settlement will gain them money and the attorneys are making about 1/3 of the settlement. MOST of these stupid cases are settled out of court because it's cheaper to settle than to fight in court. (That's BS in my book).

Let's say it doesn't settle; you have to hire an attorney to defend my ridiculous law suit. Whether I win or not, you're out the money to defend (I'm sure this one cost Cirrus about a million to defend).

A simple change in the Tort laws would make it so that the LOSER of the case must pay the attorney fees of BOTH sides of the table. Make this change and there is NO WAY these cases would be attempted.

In the Carnahan crash, the parties involved settled for just under a million. In a plane that was operating in perfect condition while in thick IMC with a non-instrument current, weak-at-best pilot at the controls. Blame the instrument maker, the pump builder, and (of course) the plane manufacturer. Couldn't possibily have been the TARD at the controls that caused the crash! As far as I'm concerned, Carnahan and this Cirrus pilot just helped to clean the pool!!

SteveCostello
jtrain609
 
3wY0w.png
 
It's sad this even went to court in the first place. The problem is people now see the legal system like a lottery. I sue for everything and see what sticks. The PIC is clearly responsible for making poor decisions.
 
I hate that 2 guys died, but also hate that no one can hold themselves accountable anymore...

Having died in the crash, the pilot wasn't the one who brought the lawsuit. It was his relatives. Who knows whether he would have taken responsibility or not?

The relatives' actions were likely heavily influenced by grief and anger and the search for an easy target. People who suffer tragedy can really go crazy. Too bad our legal system provided them a platform for them when what they really needed was therapy.
 
Having died in the crash, the pilot wasn't the one who brought the lawsuit. It was his relatives. Who knows whether he would have taken responsibility or not?

The relatives' actions were likely heavily influenced by grief and anger and the search for an easy target. People who suffer tragedy can really go crazy. Too bad our legal system provided them a platform for them when what they really needed was therapy.

Obviously I know that the dead can't take responsibility for their own actions. Perhaps I should have worded it differently. "but also hate that relatives of those at fault can't accept their loved ones mistakes"
 
Once again, the only ones that come out ahead are the lawyers who keep the whole ridiculous predatory tort system rolling.
 
This case proves two things:

1. Our court system sucks in that this case went this far

2. The Cirrus is the new Bonanza
 
Once again, the only ones that come out ahead are the lawyers who keep the whole ridiculous predatory tort system rolling.

I'm guessing the plaintiff attorneys took this case on contingency, means they lost or the families paid for the case which means they lost. The true winners are the defendant's attorney. I hope they pay their pilot fairly.
 
Back
Top