Supreme Court: Cirrus not liable for fatal plane crash

Malko

ughhh
Staff member
http://www.startribune.com/local/162899916.html
The Supreme Court agreed that training manuals were adequate in lieu of a flight lesson a pilot never received.

The Minnesota Supreme Court has ruled that a Duluth-based airplane manufacturer had no legal duty to provide training for a pilot who died along with a passenger in a 2003 crash.

The 4-2 decision upholds last year's Appeals Court ruling that reversed a $16 million award that Cirrus Design Corp. and the University of North Dakota Aerospace Foundation were ordered to pay to the families of pilot Gary Prokop and passenger James Kosak.

Jurors in Itasca County found that Cirrus and the UND foundation, which provided pilot training, were negligent. They awarded Kosak's family $7.4 million and Prokop's family $12 million, an award that was reduced to $9 million because Prokop was found to be 25 percent liable.

The Appeals Court reversed the award, reasoning that Cirrus owed no such duty. The Supreme Court agreed, reasoning that Cirrus' duty did not specifically include a flight lesson Prokop did not receive in addition to manuals and a handbook on how to use the plane's autopilot function.
"The duty to warn has never before required a supplier or manufacturer to provide training, only accurate and thorough instructions on the safe use of the product, as Cirrus has done here," Justice G. Barry Anderson wrote.

Prokop, 47, and Kosak, 51, left Hill City, Minn., on Jan. 18, 2003, for St. Cloud to watch their sons play in a hockey tournament. The plane crashed shortly after takeoff and the families blamed Cirrus and the UND foundation, alleging that they provided inadequate pilot training.

Prokop, who had received his pilot's license in 2001, bought the Cirrus SR22 a month before the crash after about two years of piloting a Cessna, a plane with markedly different features. The more sophisticated and powerful Cirrus came with a two-day owner training program and flight manuals.

Prokop received training, but the family claims he did not receive an included lesson on how to cope with inclement weather by using the autopilot function. Prokop became disoriented in low-visibility conditions when the plane crashed.

In his dissent, Justice Paul Anderson wrote that the jury's verdict should stand. He agreed that the training manuals alone provided inadequate warning because it did not include the flight lesson Prokop failed to receive.

Further, he wrote, Cirrus made a promise as part of the plane's purchase to provide the flight lesson. He expressed concerns that the high court's decision could have far-reaching consequences.
"By holding that a supplier of a dangerous product, such as the SR22, is never required to provide anything beyond written instructions -- even if the supplier has promised to provide nonwritten instructions -- the majority has essentially held that no consumer of a dangerous product may ever hold a supplier liable for personal injury arising out of defective nonwritten instructions," he wrote.

Justice Alan Page joined Paul Anderson in his dissent. Justice David Stras took no part in the decision.
 
Wait... the SR-22 is now a dangerous product?

I think the only dangerous part of this little story was the unprepared and inadequately trained pilot. The responsibility for that training rests on the pilot, as did the decision to attempt to fly an aircraft he was clearly not prepared to fly.
 
Wait... the SR-22 is now a dangerous product?

I think the only dangerous part of this little story was the unprepared and inadequately trained pilot. The responsibility for that training rests on the pilot, as did the decision to attempt to fly an aircraft he was clearly not prepared to fly.

Agree 100%.
 
Maybe it's not quite the same, but to play devil's advocate.....

I am a PADI-certified SCUBA diver... When I used to go fill my tanks they would always ask to see my card when I went to fill tanks... No card, no air..... I am guessing that may be the angle the lawyers were going after, who knows....

Either way I would agree the pilot would be the one responsibility.
 
Not sure if he was instrument rated, but it sure didn't sound like it from the article. So they're suing Cirrus for not giving him an instrument rating? Sounds like the court made a good decision for once. It would set a bad precedent if families were allowed to sue an aircraft manufacturer every time someone pulled a JFK Jr. I don't think there would be any more new airplanes...
 
http://www.ntsb.gov/aviationquery/brief2.aspx?ev_id=20030122X00087&ntsbno=CHI03FA057&akey=1

...
The pilot, age 47, held a private pilot certificate with an airplane single-engine land rating. He held a third class medical certificate issued on October 28, 2002, with a limitation of "Must wear corrective lenses."

The pilot's logbook was recovered at the scene. Some pages were damaged and partially unreadable. According to the logbook, he had logged 248.0 hours total time. Of these, 18.9 were in an SR-22. Except for 1.0 hour in a simulator, the remaining flights logged were in a Cessna 172 aircraft.

He had logged a total of 57.0 hours of instrument flight time and 19.0 hours of night flight time. Instrument and night flight time in the SR-22 totaled 0.3 and 2.3 hours, respectively.

According to Cirrus Design/University of North Dakota records, the pilot completed the SR-22 training course on December 12, 2002. The course consisted of 4 flights for a total of 12.5 hours of dual flight instruction and 5.3 hours of ground instruction.

The record indicates a ground lesson, which included "Brief on VFR into IMC procedures", was completed on the last day of the course. The flight lesson entitled "IFR Flight (Non-rated)" was not conducted.

A VFR-only completion certificate and High Performance aircraft endorsement were awarded on December 12th. The endorsement was limited to SR-22 aircraft only, according to the training record.

Spatial disorientation experienced by the pilot, due to a lack of visual references, and a failure to maintain altitude. Contributing factors were the pilot's improper decision to attempt flight into marginal VFR conditions, his inadvertent flight into instrument meteorological conditions, the low lighting condition (night) and the trees.
 
Sounds pretty cut and dry to me. He was a relatively low time pilot flew into IMC in a fairly unfamiliar aircraft without his IFR ticket.

Incredible that the first court actually ruled the wrong way, and pretty surprising that this was not a unanimous decision. Totally ridiculous. Like someone mentioned above, suing Cirrus is akin to suing every single auto manufacturer that has had some kid crash and kill someone one of their products on slick roads at night.
 
Pretty much all the above. I've flown the SR-20 quite a bit, while not an easy airplane avionics wise if you're coming from a Cessna, it's not impossible, and again, I had training that I had to seek out. Sounds like the family doesn't want to accept the fact their family member, tragic as it is, was at fault for this.

That's like saying this winter when there's ice on the road, I can sue Kia when I crash my car because I didn't receive the proper training...
 
"Butbutbut... the computers will guide me through, right? I mean... I've got a wing leveler AND a parachute!"

I apparently don't know how to use them, though...


Edit: It's a tragic accident. But one that was completely preventable by a pilot competent enough to know when s/he is over his/her head.
 
Also at night: T/O at 6:30, sunrise at 7:54.That certainly didn't improve his odds.

The pilot didn't have his instrument rating, so it makes perfect sense to me that he would take the lesson "Brief on VFR into IMC Procedures," but NOT the lesson "IFR Flight." If he had, then I can see the survivors suing for tempting him to fly in IMC (I'm not justifying it - I'm just saying that they were going to sue the manufacturer for something.)

Is a dissenting opinion available? I'd like to know the rationale for the two supreme court justices who voted in favor of the plaintiff.
 
Incredible that the first court actually ruled the wrong way, and pretty surprising that this was not a unanimous decision. Totally ridiculous.

I happen to be somewhat familiar with the region where the original district court is located, and the original ruling, while I completely disagree with it, does not surprise me at all. We'll just leave it at that.

I'm very happy to see the MN Supreme Court's decision on this case. Had it gone the other way, that would have opened up a Pandora's Box of problems for flight training and responsibility.
 
I'm very happy to see the MN Supreme Court's decision on this case. Had it gone the other way, that would have opened up a Pandora's Box of problems for flight training and responsibility.

I have to assume that had the MN Supreme Court not been intelligent enough to overturn this that it would have ended up at SCOTUS. The fact that there were actually a few dissents on this at a Supreme Court level makes me weep for our judicial system.

Most assuredly, had the original ruling stood, it would have been a very large nail in the coffin of general aviation and instructing, likely even worse than the product liability fiasco. (Actually had, the original ruling stood firm, we might have eventually actually had a genuine pilot shortage!)
 
Seeing as the pilot who flew the plane had his PPL and made the PIC decision to fly in IMC despite receiving (hopefully) the proper training in which he was required to pass a checkride, I have no way of seeing how this is Cirrus' fault.
 
Back
Top