Spirit Airlines cancels all flights as pilots go on strike

brent p h

Well-Known Member
http://www.cnn.com/2010/TRAVEL/06/14/airline.strike/index.html?hpt=T2

http://www.aviationinterviews.com/pilot/airlinepayrates.html


Pilot salaries will not change until passengers are willing to pay higher ticket prices. The only way that’s probably going to happen is if the government re-regulates the aviation industry, which would set price controls like before deregulation in 1978. Interesting thing is that several airline execs (current and retired) have publicly endorsed re-regulation.
 
Re: Spirit Airlines cancels all flights as pilots go on stri

You know with the 900 sub forums it is really starting to make the General forum look like a ghost town and is becoming pointless really.
 
Re: Spirit Airlines cancels all flights as pilots go on stri

I like the link to the pay rates for all the carriers...eye opening for those of us that weren't quite in the know.
 
Re: Spirit Airlines cancels all flights as pilots go on stri

I just love when you read public comments on those articles and every John Doe still thinks pilots are overpaid. Apparently all the media hype since the Colgan crash hasn't really done anything to change the public image of an airline pilot anywhere closer to modern reality.
 
Re: Spirit Airlines cancels all flights as pilots go on stri

The public sees $125/hr and freaks. In fact the CA pay at Spirit really isn't *too* bad, it's the F/O pay that is so low.

Salaries of public employees are coming down as salaries of government employees and their contractors (especially federal) go up.
 
Re: Spirit Airlines cancels all flights as pilots go on stri

Well the public sees $125/hr and multiples that by 40 hours a week (or more) and says "wow, that's $5000 a week! See, pilots really do make $250k a year!" completely ignoring the fact that we don't get paid 40 hours per week (or anywhere even close).
 
Re: Spirit Airlines cancels all flights as pilots go on stri

I just love when you read public comments on those articles and every John Doe still thinks pilots are overpaid. Apparently all the media hype since the Colgan crash hasn't really done anything to change the public image of an airline pilot anywhere closer to modern reality.


Because they see that the lowest paid First office is paid OMG 25 dollars an hour? that's crazy high!


But the forget about the part where pilots aren't paid 40 hours a week (although they might work that and more)
 
Re: Spirit Airlines cancels all flights as pilots go on stri

I just love when you read public comments on those articles and every John Doe still thinks pilots are overpaid. Apparently all the media hype since the Colgan crash hasn't really done anything to change the public image of an airline pilot anywhere closer to modern reality.

People don't educate themselves.

Plus, everyone thinks that their opinion, no matter how deeply misguided, serves as their undeniable "right" to engage in intellectual combat. We're live "I have an opinion, ready to fight" culture where it's bad to say, "Shut your pie hole, research what you're talking about and THEN come back into the debate."

I have to re-read that paragraph....

Ehh, well, at least I know what it means! ;)
 
Re: Spirit Airlines cancels all flights as pilots go on stri

I initially got a little riled up reading some of the public's comments related to the Spirit strike. Then I realized that the people who are admonishing the pilots probably don't have any real skills of their own. Their skillset allows them to believe that $50,000/year is a lot of money, and they're just angry that someone makes more than they do.

Harsh, but probably true!
 
Re: Spirit Airlines cancels all flights as pilots go on stri

I initially got a little riled up reading some of the public's comments related to the Spirit strike. Then I realized that the people who are admonishing the pilots probably don't have any real skills of their own. Their skillset allows them to believe that $50,000/year is a lot of money, and they're just angry that someone makes more than they do.

Harsh, but probably true!

There's A LOT of truth to that.

It's the "everyone's overpaid except me" crowd.

The general public is largely ignorant to the fact that there is a 'system' of sorts. We just don't apply for a job as a pilot, arrive at work at 0600, launch at 0700, land and fly back home.

They really have no idea the absolute devastating effect that it has on your personal life in terms of having to explain that, yet again, I'm going to be on the road during your birthday party. The dedication it takes to become a pilot and STAY a pilot. The risks... etc.

That same person, if their son said, "Daddy! I want to be an airline pilot" would scoff at the expense, education requirements, years of earning very little and "OMG, all that money and work and you make less than $20,000 to start!?" is probably typing away in the comment section saying "Pilots are overpaid and underworked!"

Yeah, John Q. Public, I'm going to fly you at 550mph in a $30,000,000 jet from PHX to DFW for less than the cost that you're spending on your families AT&T mobile phone bill. Yeeeeeeeeeeeah.
 
Re: Spirit Airlines cancels all flights as pilots go on stri

There's A LOT of truth to that.

It's the "everyone's overpaid except me" crowd.

The general public is largely ignorant to the fact that there is a 'system' of sorts. We just don't apply for a job as a pilot, arrive at work at 0600, launch at 0700, land and fly back home.

They really have no idea the absolute devastating effect that it has on your personal life in terms of having to explain that, yet again, I'm going to be on the road during your birthday party. The dedication it takes to become a pilot and STAY a pilot. The risks... etc.

That same person, if their son said, "Daddy! I want to be an airline pilot" would scoff at the expense, education requirements, years of earning very little and "OMG, all that money and work and you make less than $20,000 to start!?" is probably typing away in the comment section saying "Pilots are overpaid and underworked!"

Yeah, John Q. Public, I'm going to fly you at 550mph in a $30,000,000 jet from PHX to DFW for less than the cost that you're spending on your families AT&T mobile phone bill. Yeeeeeeeeeeeah.

Doug - I hear ya, man, but I wouldn't make the mistake of marginalizing some of these people. They're not educated about what pilots do....but...why should they be? What incentive is there (beyond personal knowledge gain, and let's face it, that's a rare quality these days) for them to understand WHY they're being inconvenienced?

I've had the conversation with dozens of non-flying people over the years about what pilots go through, the sacrifices and the give-backs that the unions have done over the last 30 years.

And to the man they have ALL said, "Well...if life is so awful for them, why don't they quit?" Or - and this is the close second, "Then why did they go into such a crappy industry to begin with?"

It's the latter which is hard to answer. It's difficult to sell the idea that a handful of guys are trying to make the profession better when SJS is so prevalent. Because to the outsider, all they see are 1) inconvenienced schedules due to strikes and 2) greedy pilots and unions always wanting more, because all they understand about unions is UAW and what they see on The Sopranos.

You can try and educate people if you want, but realize it's a hard sell to anyone who doesn't WANT to be in the industry to begin with; and they don't often understand why anyone else would either, given the conditions.
 
Re: Spirit Airlines cancels all flights as pilots go on stri

The public sees $125/hr and freaks. In fact the CA pay at Spirit really isn't *too* bad, it's the F/O pay that is so low.

Salaries of public employees are coming down as salaries of government employees and their contractors (especially federal) go up.

The Captain pay at Spirit is absolutely horrendous.

Going to have to agree with Todd with a hearty YEAH THAT! here...

Looking at the APC scales, I have come up with the following salary figures for an A321 CA, year 2, vs year 15. I have used 12 bid periods (months), at guarantee - because that's all you can truly budget for as an incoming pay on a monthly basis.

Keep in mind that, while Spirit is a so-called "ULCC" or Ultra-Low-Cost-Carrier, they are a major airline, a la Southwest, Delta, United, etc. Different stage of the development game, sure, but if they're making mad profits, they're headed in the right direction.

Why is defining them as a "major" important. Well, first of all, seems like regionals are D-scale carriers right now, and majors are C-scale (another story, another time). So, you're ready to be a MAJOR airline pilot now, you've invested years of your life scraping by at shady outfits and being on the road for long hours away from your family.... you've finally hit the big-time.... the career carrier:

Your current salary at Pinnacle is $57,600/year, as a 6th year pilot at the company holding a CA bid.

Immediately, you get into new hire class at Spirit, they start paying you guarantee for the seat that is vacant: A319FO

Your new salary is $34,560/year.

So, you've been in aviation for over 10 years, 6 with a regional, and the rest of the 4+ learning to fly and teaching, you've got a family. You receive an immediate yearly pay HIT of $23,040. Honey, don't worry, there will be a CA vacancy soon... there are a lot of senior folks retiring at age 60.... I mean 65 now!

Well, as luck would have it, you came to Spirit at the right time, CA's are retiring at 65 in droves and you've only had to survive for one year on the FO scale... you bid for, and are awarded pending successful upgrade training, a CA slot on the big iron. A321 baby!

At the completion of your CA training, you receive the first of many monthly checks with the CA pay attached... you will earn $91,584 in your second year at the company.

Fifteen stable years later, you hit the apex of your career airline Spirit, and you proudly count your W2 at the end of that last pay increase and find that you earned $131,328 that year.

Looking back at this IDEAL scenario for today's pilot, we do the math:

upon reaching his career airline, the hypothetical pilot lost $23,040 in yearly pay. Over the course of his Spirit career, he ends up achieving $39,744 in pay raises... That, my friends, is a net gain of $16,704 over FIFTEEN years. Yes, $131k is better than $57k, but if you've invested your life, your health, and your family into a once-promising career.

Who in their right mind would get their career job and expect that over the course of said career their net gain in salary is less than $40,000, over 20+ years.

As an aside, my friend, a computer programmer, doubled his salary after 3 years, and is still short of $100k, but he's only 3 years in and with his skills, he'll never have to take a job for less than what he is making at the current point (caveat: economy turns to crapper).

Food for thought, those who think that airline pilot pay is too high.

Lower total salary could potentially be stomachable if you never made less than any years prior. Since that will never happen....
 
Re: Spirit Airlines cancels all flights as pilots go on stri

Also keep in mind it might take you 14 or 15 months or longer to accrue a "year" under the proposed step system.
 
Re: Spirit Airlines cancels all flights as pilots go on stri

Can someone explain is the US Airways CA first year pay a typo (25$/hr)?
 
Re: Spirit Airlines cancels all flights as pilots go on stri

Total longevity. I'm a 13 year 767 FO and if I bid 737 captain, I would be a 13 year 737 Captain in terms of pay.
 
Re: Spirit Airlines cancels all flights as pilots go on stri

I'm not disagreeing with your overall conclusions by any means, but this paragraph has me scratching my head:

Looking back at this IDEAL scenario for today's pilot, we do the math:
upon reaching his career airline, the hypothetical pilot lost $23,040 in yearly pay...

57,600-34,560=23,040 - OK, that looks right.

...Over the course of his Spirit career, he ends up achieving $39,744 in pay raises...

I come up with 131,358-34,560=96,798 :confused:

...That, my friends, is a net gain of $16,704 over FIFTEEN years.

My math says 131,358-57,600=73,758...again...:confused:

Help me out here. What am I missing?
 
Re: Spirit Airlines cancels all flights as pilots go on stri

I am guessing that the average pilot spends 300 TAFB every month. The public doesn't know or get this.
 
Re: Spirit Airlines cancels all flights as pilots go on stri

I'm not disagreeing with your overall conclusions by any means, but this paragraph has me scratching my head:



57,600-34,560=23,040 - OK, that looks right.



I come up with 131,358-34,560=96,798 :confused:



My math says 131,358-57,600=73,758...again...:confused:

Help me out here. What am I missing?

The normal worker bee would be seeing nothing but pay raises as their experience increases. Pilots only take experience with them to get hired at the next "better" job as the low-man on the totem pole.

The pilot reaches Spirit as a Captain. He is automatically demoted to FO in accordance with "seniority" and traditional airline hiring practices.

So, when he becomes a Captain AGAIN... he now has to climb a ladder for 15 years to achieve a top pay that is only $39000 different than his starting CAPTAIN pay at Spirit.

The fact that he had to take a pay cut of $23000 switching from the "experience building airline" to the "career airline" only to achieve $39000 worth of raises as a CAPTAIN at the "career airline" is where my math comes in.

It's not an exact math. And of course, the raw numbers tend to show that the pay gained is much more; however, the exercise was an attempt to show that someone who finally achieves "the apex" of their career - CA at a major airline.... only gets $39,000 more from day one as CA to year 15 as CA.

Clear as mud? I'm not trying to spin it to make it seem worse than it is.

I'm merely attempting to get the best comparison to a normal job that I can.

Normal job = gain experience, get paid more; company no longer wants to pay more, go somewhere else, get equal to or greater
Airline job = work butt off to gain experience and get paid a little more; find better job with a start lower than you're at but a higher end...

I don't really think you can consider the total gain in pay $96000 because you're taking pay cuts to get there. If it were a constant slope up, then I buy it.
 
Re: Spirit Airlines cancels all flights as pilots go on stri

Can someone explain is the US Airways CA first year pay a typo (25$/hr)?

It's not a typo. It's the sad truth.

USAir is where Ben was before he came to Spirit.

In all reality, it doesn't mean anything because USAirways has not hired first year Captains.

Joe
 
Back
Top