Some advice for new commuter and corporate FOs.

flyover

New Member
I usually lurk on the forum just to soak up the enthusiasm of younger (and leaner) new aviators. Relive my youth a little.

But I was writing on another forum on a serious subject and realized I should bring it up on this forum.

People, you are hitting the line as a working pilot. This is, thankfully, not like Ernest Gann's days where you will soon have a long list of friends who "died on the line". Things are much safer now.

But there is one area that will cost you a lot of anxiety, I guarantee it. That is thunderstorm flying. The whole deal of how to use the radar, make enroute avoidance decisions, and most importantly terminal area avoidance decisions.

I bring this up because I still see all types of pilots make terrible decisions on the line. But none worse than regional guys. Time and time again I see CRJs and ATRs, etc, landing and taking off in thunderstorms. I attribute this to lots of "newer" captains but still way too many captains of all types making these bad decisions. (examples American at LIT and USAir at CLT).

I spent a few years, first on the panel, then in the right seat hoping some enlightened captain would teach me the secrets of good radar technique and thunderstorm judgments. Instead they scared the &*^%% out of me. In my early days I spent way too much time inside of thunderstorms. And that was with a perfectly working radar.

So here's my suggestion for how to have an easier time than me.

1) Get Dennis Newton's book Severe Weather Flying . Easy read and written in a non-technical way for dumb pilots (like me).

2) Get your butts in a radar seminar. Or buy one of the courses on CD, I think Dave Gwinn sells one thorough Sporty's. Archie Trammel has good stuff.

3) Find and read anything you can on the subject of thunderstorms, windshear and radar.

4) Take what you learned and apply it on the line. Use your radar, work the tilt, practice, practice, practice, with it. Know, for example, what ground returns a properly working radar on your airplane will paint. This is called a confidence check and every pilot should know how to do it. You should also know how to quickly find the approximate height of any weather area. Critically important info.

5) Make up your mind that for the sake of your family and, most importantly, the paying passengers that trust you that you will not push it in thunderstorm conditions. That you will not takeoff and land in a thunderstorm, no matter how many guys ahead of you did it.

6) Make up your mind that you will not keep your mouth shut, as some other (now dead) first offices have done, while your captain does something stupid. If you follow my recommendations above you will soon know much more about radar and thunderstorms than your captain. Believe me it is a tough position to be in. You will have to be ready to be forceful and direct in dealing with it.

Then someday you will be in a position to show the new guys how it's really done. How real captains refuse to go when conditions aren't right.

This is in the spirit of hoping none of you spend a minute inside a thunderstorm in your careers.

Dave
cool.gif
 
so whats the deal?

You tilt downwards until you start painting the ground, then you go back up until your altitude (in 100s) equals the distance away from the craft to start painting. I.E., if your altitude is FL200, you start painting at 20 miles... OR--- is the 20miles figure your button-punch range that you enter.

I've been trying to figure this out in the BE9T for a couple of weeks, no thunderstorms of course.
 
Exactly my point.

This is no place to start a radar course. As professionals it's each pilots responsibility to know their radar and how to use it. If your airline isn't teaching you then you need to take the time and effort to teach yourself.

Then if some of your captains or FOs want to learn from you you can teach them. Many of them, especially the captains, probably won't (don't ask me why). Yet when you ask them to show you their techniques they won't have any or they'll be wrong ones. At least that's my experience. If you guys are getting better training now it would make me very happy, but I won't believe it until I start seeing more guys refuse approaches through thunderstorms or not driving through thunderstorms that I'm avoiding then screaming about the "moderate to severe' turbulence they are in. Saw this just the other day on a flight between ATL and MYR.

There are only a few things out there that can kill you now. It's a very safe profession. The only reason that TRWs are still high on the threat list is the failure to take a professional approach to training pilots in how to avoid them and use their equipment properly.

Dave
banghead.gif
 
[ QUOTE ]
I bring this up because I still see all types of pilots make terrible decisions on the line. But none worse than regional guys. Time and time again I see CRJs and ATRs, etc, landing and taking off in thunderstorms.

[/ QUOTE ]

Those dumb regional guys.....
confused.gif
 
Now, let's not turn this into some pissy cat fight between major airline pilots and regional pilots.

I'm sure the original post was NOT meant to insult, just point out a potential problem from the authors point of view.

Relax. Nobody is calling anybody "dumb" or "stupid". Take it for what it was - a word to the wise from someone who has been there.
 
I never had a course in using a weather radar, but I wish I did earlier. But the kicker is when I got my hands on my first weather radar and was flying in a region that I actually had to use it, we had all of these aviation univeristy grad captains that wanted to teach "Well if you're X altitude, tune the radar to Y*2 miles out, paint the ground and then put it on the Y range, yadda yadda yadda."

But now, I realized it's a mixture of a little science, a little dumb luck and drawing on experience. And I'll readily confess that my basic experience with the WX radar when I was a regional pilot probably got me into more trouble than it got me out of. I think mostly because I saw the operation of the system as more of a 'science' and less of an 'art.

Largely whenever I need to use the WX radar, I'll pull out the chicken bones, the "Jobu" and my Dali Lama picture.
 
>>Now, let's not turn this into some pissy cat fight between major airline pilots and regional pilots.<<

Exactly, in fact I mentioned two fairly recent fatal accidents by major airlines. And I have witnessed plenty of mistakes by majors. Last summer I tried to warn a DC-8 crew (working for an earthtone company that will remain maneless) to not attempt an approach at ABQ with a 40,000' cell sitting between the marker and the runway. They decided to try it and were soon back on approach frequency after a nasty windshear encounter on short final.

This has been one of my main areas of interest since being at DFW in 1985 shortly after the L-1011 crash. It is very disturbing for me to be at an airport and see professional pilots operate in thunderstorms. Or to watch a professional crew in a radar equipped airplane fly into a thunderstorm enroute. I know their passengers are going through hell.

I picked on the regionals because I see them the most doing this and I think they need some help. You will not properly learn how to make thunderstorm or windshear decisions "on the line". This is an area that requires training, just like every other phase of flight. You don't experiment with shooting a real ILS for the first time with paying passengers onboard. (OK, actually I did do that, but it was 30 years ago for god's sake),

It is accepted in the industry that you "learn how to use the radar on the line". This is the reason that the same bad things happen over and over again. That's my point.

I'm on your side. Really.
bandit.gif


Dave
 
[ QUOTE ]
Largely whenever I need to use the WX radar, I'll pull out the chicken bones, the "Jobu" and my Dali Lama picture.

[/ QUOTE ]
banghead.gif
Laughing too hard!
 
Radar training is definitely something that is largely left up to the individual. We had next to no training on the radar in class except for a video. Most of what I know about radar, I learned from more experience captains.

I have heard that Archie Tremel has a good booklet on radar use as well. I've also heard that his videos are incredibly boring. Someone who saw one told me that they drew an outline of him on the screen and he didn't move out of it thoughout the whole film.
grin.gif
 
Since I\'ve got ya here-

While I've got you here Dave, can a ACA pilot ride the DAL jumpseat? Does it depend on the "side" of the operation he's on?
 
It's clearly not just regional pilots. A NWA captain is in deep with the FAA because he allegedly tried to land in Sioux Falls, SD with a tornado in the vinicity. He ultimately diverted to Omaha. I think they've charged him with reckless operations, or something like that.

MF
 
>>I think mostly because I saw the operation of the system as more of a 'science' and less of an 'art.<<

Hey Doug,

Believe me it is much more science and much less art if you do it right.

I got the chance to talk a lot with a man who did the original flight testing on airborne weather radar. Yes believe it or not he would take airplanes like a P-38 up with the then new RCA radar on board and fly through mature thunderstorms to collect and correlate flight data with what the radar was showing. His research established the frequencies that were effective (x-band and c-band) and other data. It was a wealth of information. Boy did he have some stories. Like coming back once buried to the waist inside his cockpit with pea-siaed hail that had come in through an airvent.

It was the great frustration of his life (he has passed) that none of the data he collected was disseminated properly to pilots. It was very difficult for him to learn of fatal accidents involving radar equipped airplanes that he knew could have been avoided with the most basic training in thunderstorm meteorology and radar use. He had risked his life to collect the information and it was just totally wasted.

So here we are in the twenty-first century and most pilots share your opinion of radar techniques and thunderstorm decision making as "art rather than science". When I hear that I know that there are some basic fundamentals missing. (Not to get personal, it is the common belief).

I get a little hard-assed about the subject because having researched a lot of fatal preventable accidents and spoken to men like Jim who put it all on the line I would truly like to see not one more fatal thunderstorm accident. And sitting on the taxiway at places like ATL and watching operations continue in raging thunderstorms just because TDWR isn't giving any warnings I know we aren't even close to getting this thing handled in the industry.

Hence my post, passing along some advice I wish I had gotten earlier in my career.

Dave
 
flyover, check your PM's (little white flashing flag thing in the upper left hand of the screen - just click on it).
 
Re: Since I\'ve got ya here-

>>While I've got you here Dave, can a ACA pilot ride the DAL jumpseat? Does it depend on the "side" of the operation he's on? <<

Yikes Doug, I'm the worst one to ask that question. I'm not very up on the jumpseat rules. I know the basics like the FAA guy has to go. Current Delta guys OK to go. Any tall blonde females the agent has cleared OK to go (sorry, I'm a really old guy, still not properly PC) and that's mainly cause my brain stops working at that point. Tall brown-eyed brunettes good too. Oh heck, all the chicks make it on my jumpseat.

So far it hasn't been an issue because if it's questionable there has always been a seat in the back anyway so I haven't been tested too much on it.

Dave
cool.gif
 
[ QUOTE ]
I never had a course in using a weather radar, but I wish I did earlier. But the kicker is when I got my hands on my first weather radar and was flying in a region that I actually had to use it, we had all of these aviation univeristy grad captains that wanted to teach "Well if you're X altitude, tune the radar to Y*2 miles out, paint the ground and then put it on the Y range, yadda yadda yadda."

[/ QUOTE ]

Yes, this is the same spiel I was trying to explain above. Then I got a different spiel when on descent, as the nose is pointed downward, you have to multiply the pitch down azimuth with something else (???) to get a final tilt angle...
 
Hammering home a good point that was made here:

Ops in and around TSTMS. Minimize as much as possible. There's VERY, VERY, FEW civilian missions that require taking the risks inherent with TSTMS ( windshear, etc). Whether deviating around them enroute, or avoiding them on approach/departure, having "gotten those 50 pax" to their destination with a TSTM overhead the field was just another lucky day.
 
Re: Since I\'ve got ya here-

Oh, I meant Davetheflyer initially. But you also work for ACA, flyover?
 
Re: Since I\'ve got ya here-

Alot of generic radar books, may teach you something, but little about your individual radar. The best source is info on the exact radar in your airplane. Dish sizes, power, etc change these generic methods mentioned above. If you dont bother to read the info published about your radar then it becomes guess work.
bandit.gif
 
Re: Since I\'ve got ya here-

good old archie trammel only blinks about 3 times in about 3 hours of video. it is pretty boring
 
Back
Top