Some advice for new commuter and corporate FOs.

Re: Since I\'ve got ya here-

>>The best source is info on the exact radar in your airplane. Dish sizes, power, etc change these generic methods mentioned above. <<

Very good point with this caveat. Keeping in mind I haven't looked at a operating handbook for about ten years or so.

In the eighties and early nineties when I was doing a lot of technical wrting on this subject we had to pretty much completely throw out the manufacturers handbooks. They were worse than useless.

Any good radar couse should give you the data for your dish size. Power output of the radar is not important. All radars are calibrated to same specs. If a radar has a low power output it is because it has a more sensitive receiver. Dish size matters, power output doesn't.

I hope the manufacturers are writing better books now. I have sat down with engineers from some major manufacturers who do all the writing and I found they do not relate to pilots and what we need to know to operate.

Dave
ooo.gif
 
Re: Since I\'ve got ya here-

>>good old archie trammel only blinks about 3 times in about 3 hours of video. it is pretty boring <<

I have a lot of admiration for Archie. He has been teaching this course for a long time and only wants one thing: no more thunderstorm accidents.

Many pilots are dismissive of Archie's course. I have talked to a number and find some of them don't really know much about radar and thunderstorms, they just think they do, and besides Archie just flies little airplanes.

I know a very experienced airline captain who is also an aviation writer. He admitted one time that thunderstorms still were his biggest fear. I offered to show him how to solve that and start having fun with TRWs and he waved me off. Just not interersted.

Thunderstorms and radar are that way. Boring to read and learn about. Very exciting once you've screwed up.

I can tell you one simple concept Archie pounds a lot that many, if not most, professional pilots get wrong and that can kill you.

He emphasizes that PIREPs can be very misleading and can lead you to make bad decisions. The best example is a busy terminal area.

Situation: you are in a line of airplanes waiting to take off. It is getting darker, windier and lightning is flashing nearby. Now it starts to rain. During all this airplanes are rolling for takeoff every minute and a half. As you turn to the runway now you can see a dark and ominous wall of water just off the end of the runway. An airplane rolls for takeoff and you are now igoing into position on the runway. Your radar shows a big red blob just a few miles ahead. Now you hear the preceding crew switch to departure with a PIREP "smooth ride, moderate rain". There are no TDWR microburst warnings issued. Lightning flashes again, somewhere, you can't tell where. You are cleared for takeoff, what do you do?

I would tell the tower we were waiting for the thunderstorm off the end of the runway to move and offer to exit the runway to let someone else go if they wanted to. This is an easy decision. If you think it is a hard decision or if you've taken off in similar conditions, you may need to rethink it.

I have watched this scenario unfold time and again at major airports. The funny thing is, most pilots would easily decide not to go in that situation, IF no airplanes had taken off in front of them. In virtually all the fatal windshear accidents in the past thirty years, the accident aircraft was following another aircraft who made it just fine.

You don't get to fly through the same weather as the guy in front of you. Thunderstorms change by the second. So the typical terminal area windshear accident involves numerous takeoffs or approaches and then suddenly, bang, burning wreckage. NOW we close the airport because the firetrucks are rolling.

Yet most pilots I've talked to feel the most important info they can hear is that the guy ahead had a "smooth ride".

I'll concede the point Archie had me nodding. But if you can get just some of his basics in use in your line ops you will be safer for it.

Dave
smile.gif
 
Re: Since I\'ve got ya here-

>>Oh, I meant Davetheflyer initially. But you also work for ACA, flyover? <<

Sorry Doug I thought you were taling to me because I'm supposed to know those things. As I clearly demonstrated, I do not.

BTW do you have an operating manual on what all the buttons mean and what they do on this forum?

Forum illiterate.
spin2.gif


Dave
 
[ QUOTE ]
the "Jobu"

[/ QUOTE ]

But do you say, "Jobu, I good to you. I stick up for you. You no good to me now...[screw] you, Jobu. I do it myself."

Ah, Major League. Great movie.

"What's this ole [stuff], Dorn?"
"Nice [freaking] catch, Hayes. Don't ever do it again."
"The hell with the breaking ball, give him the heater, Ricky!"
 
Re: Since I\'ve got ya here-

Thanks for your posts, Flyover.

I watched the Archie tapes last summer, but I think I'll do a little more research into the subject since thunderstorm season has arrived.
 
Re: Since I\'ve got ya here-

[ QUOTE ]
>>The best source is info on the exact radar in your airplane. Dish sizes, power, etc change these generic methods mentioned above. <<

Very good point with this caveat. Keeping in mind I haven't looked at a operating handbook for about ten years or so.

In the eighties and early nineties when I was doing a lot of technical wrting on this subject we had to pretty much completely throw out the manufacturers handbooks. They were worse than useless.

Any good radar couse should give you the data for your dish size. Power output of the radar is not important. All radars are calibrated to same specs. If a radar has a low power output it is because it has a more sensitive receiver. Dish size matters, power output doesn't.

I hope the manufacturers are writing better books now. I have sat down with engineers from some major manufacturers who do all the writing and I found they do not relate to pilots and what we need to know to operate.

Dave
ooo.gif


[/ QUOTE ]

My point is this... Techniques used for a 30 inch dish dont work the same as with an 12 inch dish. EMB has known some limitations with the radar in the EMB145 and putting a larger dish in has not worked well b/c of its housing. EMBs have been around for some time now and techniques and tutorials on our specific radar have been given. I would say that my company has done a good job making this information available, but still some do not bother reading it and go with techniques they used in other airplanes. These same techniques dont work that well and you can find yourself shooting over alot of the storms your trying to paint. I guess we can use the "Its not the size, its how you use it" phrase here too if you know what you're looking for. Obviously bigger would be better, but thats not something that can be changed apparantly at present (we are still talking radars here!).

I agree with you that many folks are lacking good radar techniques. I will not say that Regional Pilots are the worst at this. Arrogance, Ignorance, and complancancy can get people in trouble at all airline and all levels.
 
Re: Since I\'ve got ya here-

Easy fix:

Get a RIO or WSO to read the radar for you.
 
Back
Top