WS
Well-Known Member
You don't need to be in actual IMC for the entire approach in order to log it. I would bet that most people have very few approaches where they are IMC all the way to the DA, usually you are going to break out well before minimums otherwise we wouldn't log many approaches.
As far how much of the approach needs to be in IMC, it's not really defined, just says the approaches need to be completed in actual weather conditions. If you needed those instrument skills to get you from the FAF to the DA or the MAP, you conducted the approach in actual weather conditions as far as I am concerned. Most people log it if they were IMC at all from the FAF.
As far as breaking off the approach, why would you want to do that? If there was a good reason, like maybe ATC directs you to go missed, I would log it as long as I had started down on the approach. If you are just doing it to cheat the system, well... the only person you are cheating is yourself.
And lets be honest here, six approaches in six months isn't exactly going to keep the rust off of your IFR skills so I would do everything possible to keep it challenging and meaningful.
As far how much of the approach needs to be in IMC, it's not really defined, just says the approaches need to be completed in actual weather conditions. If you needed those instrument skills to get you from the FAF to the DA or the MAP, you conducted the approach in actual weather conditions as far as I am concerned. Most people log it if they were IMC at all from the FAF.
As far as breaking off the approach, why would you want to do that? If there was a good reason, like maybe ATC directs you to go missed, I would log it as long as I had started down on the approach. If you are just doing it to cheat the system, well... the only person you are cheating is yourself.
And lets be honest here, six approaches in six months isn't exactly going to keep the rust off of your IFR skills so I would do everything possible to keep it challenging and meaningful.