I won't get into an argument about someone being able to choose where they work. I fully respect the fact that we are independent thinkers and make decisions based on many things. The thing that must be understood is that as in life, those decisions that are made come with a set of conditions. We have spent considerable amounts of time on this very forum talking about the consequences of working for companies like Skybus, Virgin America and others that share the same philosophy toward their employees. This also isn't an issue about unionism despite some that try to make it so. In fact, this subject really transcends unionism.
Being an airline pilot has always been a noble and special profession. You were really someone if you had the fortune to fly airplanes for a living 20 or 30 years ago. The general public looked up to you in ways that were almost, well Godlike. It might have been misguided adulation but it was seen and perceived as a very special occupation nonetheless. As such, major airline pilots were well compensated and enjoyed the perks of living "the life." Airlines knew they had to pay for the experience their crew members brought to work every day.
The advent of men like Frank Lorenzo, Carl Icahn and others brought about a very destructive cycle that still exists in many places. That is, unscrupulous men who see running an airline as nothing more than a way to put money in their own pockets, largely on the backs of labor. We saw this happen with our very own eyes, how these crooks raped and pillaged companies. Proud airlines like TWA, Eastern and many others were sent to slaughter by a very few evil men. When up and coming executives and managers saw how much money could be made by having your hands literally in the airline till, it was like the California Gold Rush to cash in. We are all familiar with the names of individuals who in the past 20 years have jumped on this bandwagon and still try to this day to destroy fundamentally good companies for their own selfish desires.
Ultimately the only ones we can count on to fight back this movement is each other. Unions have been formed to organize these efforts, but frankly ALPA, APA and SWAPA are basically just a group of "us" willing to fight the fight. Are unions perfect? No! Are all non-union pilot groups bad? Of course not!
It is my opinion that this profession of ours is literally hanging on the edge of a very deep and dangerous precipice. If some of the lost benefits are ever restored, It will be because of us, not a generous management team that wants to see us thrive and prosper. That is why it is so important to clearly understand what it means by going to places like Skybus, Virgin America and others like them, literally handing them the tools, in the form of substandard wages and benefits, to continue to destroy our profession. What possible good to our profession does somebody think they are contributing when they knock on Skybus' door and say please hire me at a fraction of what I am worth? In my opinion, it borders on treasonous behavior. How could a person doing that have any expectation that they would be greeted with anything other than disdain by other pilots in the industry? Jeez guys, is it really that difficult of a concept to digest? Pilot positions at respectable companies go unfilled in today's pilot marketplace. The argument of "it was my only option", or "I need to feed my family" falls way short here.
Any industry has entry level positions and the airline industry is no exception. It is generally expected that as a young buck, you will get hired at a Part 135 or regional carrier and essentially work your way through the system. Is it right that Gulfstream and some of the lower paying companies only pay $1000 to $1500 per month? I don't know the answer to that except that if I were a businessman and hung a help wanted sign out front saying that I needed workers for $6 per hour, and my business was flooded with folks wanting the job, I guess I would have to believe that $6 per hour was enough. On the other hand, If I had no one apply, I would be forced into paying more until I could hire the help I needed.
When a young CFI has the opportunity to move up from a Cessna or Piper into a multi million dollar jet, their eyes light up and they see their dream materializing before their eyes. After all, even though they are not making a killing in the pay department, they are gaining valuable experience that will serve them well in the future so this justifies the low starting salary to most. FOs become captains and the captains they replace move on the legacy carriers or other attractive higher paying jobs. Pardon my analogy, but it is a cycle much like Simba experiences in Disney's The Lion King. Simba learned from his father and all the other animals in his ficticious kingdom, eventually laying claim to his title King. Perhaps not a perfect analogy, but you get the idea. Many on this site will become captains at major airlines. The work and courage by all of us today will largely determine what their life will be as a captain in ten years from now.
9/11 was a horrific day for all of us. Many lost their lives and many more lost jobs, pensions, homes and relationships over the economic fallout it created. We all have paid dearly for making it possible for our employers to survive. Well, now they have survived, even getting the balance sheet cleaned up thanks to generous bankruptcy courts. It is now up to every one of us to step up to the plate and tell management that substandard is no longer good enough. We have no choice but to take a stand or becoming an airline pilot will simply not be an option due to the high costs and sacrifices required to get there.
Those among us who are knocking on the wrong doors in looking for work are unfortunately making the job of reclaiming our proud and noble profession very difficult. Be proud of who and what you have become, and don't give your skill and judgment away to an unworthy individual or corporation - and you know who they are. Or if you do, be prepared to exist in a world of non-respect from your fellow pilots. Come on guys, you are way better than that! Let's not get lost talking about unions, scabs and other issues that deserve threads of their own. This is about self respect and raising the bar for all that follow us. If we don't SAY NO to those who choose to destroy us, the fault of killing a wonderful profession will lay squarely at our own feet.