Should gliders have transponders and mode c?

I was descending out of 15,000' into Minden in a Grob 103 glider when a corporate jet of some type came right by me, descending into Reno or Stead. Almost certainly did not see me.
I vote yes, if you're soaring at higher altitudes, cross country or anywhere powered traffic might be around.
 
The biggest problem I see is battery + transponder + mode c encoder = more weight and MONEY.

Weight is not really the issue - more often than not I am putting ballast in gliders.

If there were an easy way to put transponders in gliders, I would be all for it. The reality is that they consume more electricity than a solar panel can power reliably. And they are expensive.

I don't think it would matter anyway. The biggest risk of midairs for gliders is with other gliders. Otherwise, it is in the traffic pattern, where a transponder isn't going to help you.

Gliders are not actually that hard to spot, no more so than other aircraft. And they almost always have radios. If you make traffic calls, they will tell you where they are (or ask a tow plane if they are in the area - they will know too)

Knowing where to look for them helps as well. If you see cumulus clouds with a dark, well defined concave base near a glider port, there is a good chance there are multiple gliders beneath it.
 
the average jet has the same number of sectionals on board as the average glider has transponders on board.

Your lack of a sectional chart on your jet doesn't relieve you of your legal requirement to familiarize yourself with all available information concerning your flight. That information is available in other publications that you should have in your possession. Passing at VFR altitudes through an area known to have a high concentration of gliders without at least giving it a thought constitutes a failure to properly plan your flight.

Let's steer this back in the direction of the original question...
 
Regarding the battery problem, it would be interesting if it could remain charged with a small solar panel (the dashboard battery trickle-charge type) or ram air turbine. The most cost effective solution would probably be to just remove the battery and charge it between flights.

The biggest problem I see is battery + transponder + mode c encoder = more weight and MONEY.

Edit: I'm voting yes, because I think if a smaller combination transponder/mode c encoder unit were offered specifically for the glider market it wouldn't be as big of a deal.

Becker Avionics makes some pretty small transponders and comms, the use very little energy. There are some FAA, aviation approved batteries (Genesis pure lead) to use with this avionics (as far as I know wind generators and solar panels are not approved). My former boss makes kits for balloons, but many bought them for gliders. It`s not cheap you are looking to spend 10000-15000.

I don`t think gliders are really a problem, I`m sure there are many more piper cubs and older planes flying inside the Mode C with no transponder and they are approved to do so by the FAA.
 
Yes, and so should hang gliders and paragliders operating at altitudes greater than 500' AGL. For that matter, so should skydivers. (A guy can dream, can't he?)
 
From an ATC standpoint, if they're going to operate above 10'000 MSL, I would say yes.

I've seen C-130s flying in formation provide only a "weak" return on our scopes in the center (only the leader has their transponder operating) and sometimes nothing at all if they're far enough away from the radar site. I'm sure many glider pilots operate under the assumption that ATC will see a primary return on them, which many times isn't the case. Something of that size would probably only give an occasional return on primary radar (*if* primary radar is available in the area) and as slow moving as they are, may not be noticed amongst the clutter.
 
I'm sure many glider pilots operate under the assumption that ATC will see a primary return on them...
Most of us don't. The majority of modern gliders are made of fiberglass (non-radar reflective) and carbon fiber. Those of us who operate in busy airspace are generally aware of where most fast ifr traffic is coming from and going to. The only glider / jet mid-air in SoCal that I'm aware of was at 500'agl on a ridge when a Navy A-4 lopped of the last meter of a glider's wing. According to the story the A-4 pilot wasn't even aware of what happened until his crew chief asked about the fiberglass shards in the wing :cwm27:. The glider landed safely back at the airport. This happened in a non-radar coverage area, a transponder wouldn't have helped.
 
Your lack of a sectional chart on your jet doesn't relieve you of your legal requirement to familiarize yourself with all available information concerning your flight. That information is available in other publications that you should have in your possession. Passing at VFR altitudes through an area known to have a high concentration of gliders without at least giving it a thought constitutes a failure to properly plan your flight.

Let's steer this back in the direction of the original question...

I'll make sure and familiarize myself with every glider operation on all 3 continents I regularly operate over to make sure I haven't failed to plan my flight properly.

Clearly it isn't in the best interest of glider pilots to have a transponder on onboard. See and avoid is so simple with the high visibility of gliders why would they want to appear on anyone's tcas?
 
Most of us don't. The majority of modern gliders are made of fiberglass (non-radar reflective) and carbon fiber. Those of us who operate in busy airspace are generally aware of where most fast ifr traffic is coming from and going to. The only glider / jet mid-air in SoCal that I'm aware of was at 500'agl on a ridge when a Navy A-4 lopped of the last meter of a glider's wing. According to the story the A-4 pilot wasn't even aware of what happened until his crew chief asked about the fiberglass shards in the wing :cwm27:. The glider landed safely back at the airport. This happened in a non-radar coverage area, a transponder wouldn't have helped.

TCAS(or the Navy/Mil equivalent IFF interrogator) has no dependency on radar.
 
The only glider / jet mid-air in SoCal that I'm aware of was at 500'agl on a ridge when a Navy A-4 lopped of the last meter of a glider's wing.
Two years ago a Hawker hit a glider at 16,000 feet near Reno. Glider pilot parachuted down. Hawker landed with severe damage. Transponder was OFF to save power. That has 91.13 written all over it.
 
Should DEFINETLY have Mode C. Heck...personally I believe like many that it should be a requirement for all aircraft. We implement all kinds of new FAR's and policy every year to try and make the air a safer place...why wouldn't/shouldn't this be a must?
 
There are always going to be isolated incidents of near-midair collisions with gliders but how many near-midairs have occurred where both aircraft were equipped with Mode C? Take a gander at the historical data.
You may want to rethink that "historical data" idea. Historical data contains NOTHING on the numbers saved because of TCAS. I can't tell you how many times/week we get TAs and RAs. Many of which are within radar control.

... the vast majority of glider operation takes place in uncontrolled airspace over sparsely populated areas.
You may want to take a look at all of the STARS west coast airports. They ALL bring arriving jets over the mountains in the low Teens. Just because you are not near a Class B/C, does not mean that it isn't controlled. I don't care where the thermals are, the jets/IFR traffic are on published arrivals...stay out of them.

Adding things like transponders, batteries, wind generators, etc. greatly increases weight and drag, both mortal enemies of the glider.
Too Bad. That is like a bungee jumper complaining the rope is too heavy or interferes with the fall.

Two years ago a Hawker hit a glider at 16,000 feet near Reno.
CORRECTION: It was 2006.
 
Two years ago a Hawker hit a glider at 16,000 feet near Reno. Glider pilot parachuted down. Hawker landed with severe damage. Transponder was OFF to save power. That has 91.13 written all over it.

Recurrent before my one last week, she was in my recurrent class at fsi. Interesting lady. They did a great job, but I think the pilots of the hawker and the glider had luck on their side. A couple of inches either way on impact and it could have been a lot worse for both aircraft.
 
Most of us don't. The majority of modern gliders are made of fiberglass (non-radar reflective) and carbon fiber.

I don't know that I buy the composite being invisible to radar. I was in a Remos LSA out over Tampa Bay at about 500 and approach asked me what the plane was made from. They then asked me to shut the transponder off, to see if they could pick me up as a primary target, all while no more than probably 8 or so miles from MacDill. They said they could get a primary return, so I think they do bounce something back.
 
You may want to take a look at all of the STARS west coast airports. They ALL bring arriving jets over the mountains in the low Teens. Just because you are not near a Class B/C, does not mean that it isn't controlled. I don't care where the thermals are, the jets/IFR traffic are on published arrivals...stay out of them.

Well, the glider (or any other aircraft for that matter) has just as much right to be there as you do in VMC. TCAS or TIS are not a substitute for a visual scan, and just because you are IFR does not change the fact that you are ultimately responsible for visually avoiding traffic.
 
Well, the glider (or any other aircraft for that matter) has just as much right to be there as you do in VMC. TCAS or TIS are not a substitute for a visual scan, and just because you are IFR does not change the fact that you are ultimately responsible for visually avoiding traffic.


That's easy to say.
 
Well, the glider (or any other aircraft for that matter) has just as much right to be there as you do in VMC. TCAS or TIS are not a substitute for a visual scan, and just because you are IFR does not change the fact that you are ultimately responsible for visually avoiding traffic.
Sorry, that argument holds as much water as a screen door in a submarine. No, TCAS isn't a substitute, but it is the BEST we have. Even if you know where a glider is to look, you probably won't see it in time to avoid it at normal jet speeds. There is no such thing as a "Right" to play on an airway, any more than there is a "right" to jump rope on an Interstate, then get mad because someone hit you. Maybe if you had flown 350 kts in hazy mountains you might know how hard it is to "visually avoid." Easier said than done. So if you want to guarantee you won't get run over, turn on your xponder. Then, we can see you farther out than visual range and make an adjustment.
 
Back
Top