Plane crash in Compton, CA

I think the only thing that will water down this site is people telling others that they should not post this or should not post that. If someone has to constantly worry whether something they post is going to cause them grief, then they are less likely to post, and that cannot be positive for our community. No matter what is said, it is bound to upset SOMEONE, so you cannot let that stop you, otherwise you may as well just be a lurker, and when everyone does that, then where is our beloved JC?? As far as crashes being an appropriate topic, of course they are. It's yet another part of flying, not a pleasant part, but a part non-the-less. When someone posts a message about a plane that crashed, then another user realizes they just flew that same plane last week, it causes us all to keep our awareness up a little, and maybe it will cause someone to catch a safety issue they might otherwise have missed. How can that be bad?



Darren,

You provide some very valid points in your reply and I can see the benefits that will arise from posting random crashes on the site. However, posting every plane crash on JC would take away from the value JC is intended to give.

My intent was not to discourage anyone from posting whatever they feel are aviation related topics. My point is that JC is a tool from which aspiring aviation professionals and enthusiasts can benefit from the information provided here. Having to sift through all the extra plane crash posts would render the site less effective in its purpose.

Since this is not my site to govern, my opinion is just that, an opinion. If Doug or Kristie feel it's suitable, then by all means post away.

Still just my 0.02.

Al
 
Darren,

You provide some very valid points in your reply and I can see the benefits that will arise from posting random crashes on the site. However, posting every plane crash on JC would take away from the value JC is intended to give.

My intent was not to discourage anyone from posting whatever they feel are aviation related topics. My point is that JC is a tool from which aspiring aviation professionals and enthusiasts can benefit from the information provided here. Having to sift through all the extra plane crash posts would render the site less effective in its purpose.

Since this is not my site to govern, my opinion is just that, an opinion. If Doug or Kristie feel it's suitable, then by all means post away.

Still just my 0.02.

Al

Well, I didn't see anyone posting every plane crash, and if we did do that, we should have a category for that. Plane crashes happen often enough to have a web site dedicated just to that, and I do believe it already exists, it's called the NTSB site. However, that site doesn't allow discussion on the accidents.

It seems to me, people usually post a crash when they have some sort of connection to the crash, either through proximity, acquaintance, familiarity with the aircraft, etc. The original question seemed to be whether ANY plane crashes should be posted on the site. And we both agree, some things can be learned from accidents.
 
Well, I didn't see anyone posting every plane crash, and if we did do that, we should have a category for that. Plane crashes happen often enough to have a web site dedicated just to that, and I do believe it already exists, it's called the NTSB site. However, that site doesn't allow discussion on the accidents.

It seems to me, people usually post a crash when they have some sort of connection to the crash, either through proximity, acquaintance, familiarity with the aircraft, etc. The original question seemed to be whether ANY plane crashes should be posted on the site. And we both agree, some things can be learned from accidents.


Well, perhaps a separate category for "incidents/accidents" would be beneficial to those interested in those posts. I agree that discussion of an incident/accident is indeed educational and valuable. Those posts that are of a first hand account offer the best information naturally. It's the posts that quote nothing more than a news account that contain very little valuable information.
 
One of the things I have noticed is that pilots become complacent as time goes on. I saw this a lot with all the pilots flying in and out of my local airport during Sun-n-Fun. I have learned so much from watching these old farts do their own thing. Trust no one, on the ground or in the air.

I think crash postings serve as reminders that we need to stay alert and always learning... even if the lesson comes at another pilots expense.

If a crash posting makes you think about your own flying, then it has done its job.

Sadly, as I am typing this there was another plane crash at the Sun-n-Fun. I was just there yesterday.

http://www.baynews9.com/content/36/...tle=Small+plane+crashes+near+Lakeland+Airport

I think pilots are elite and when one goes down we need to pay attention.

Rob
 
I really like this website a lot. My thought was a sub-forum that would serve as a form of "I learned about flying from that..." or interesting accidents.

This would allow the people on here with lots of experience to comment on these and the rest of us can learn.

The essential trick would be to keep it respectful and free of flames. Nothing wrong with dissecting accidents - may be a great way to learn.
 
This is not what I would consider and everyday crash. If you look at the pictures, the plane is literally sticking vertically out of a house!

http://news.aol.com/story/_a/plane-crashes-into-california-homes/20080413064709990001

Alex.

Ok guys you've gotta admit, when you take away folks dying this is kind of a comical picture. I mean seriously how often do you see a Cessna 310 freaking sticking out of a persons house?

An AME I used to go to had a picture of a 210 that crashed into a shack that was smaller than the airplane. I dunno how they survived, but nobody was killed in the accident. It looked much like that Cessna 310 does.
 
We had a aviation safety forum for a period of time, but I think we had less traffic on that than modern day Route 66.

Wait, that doesn't even make sense.

I think if we had a deeper pool of techies and folks with aircraft crash investigation experience or training, it might be more beneficial.
 
It doesn't say anyone died. What are you "R.I.Ping " for?

Am I the only one annoyed by people posting plane crash articles? I just don't see the point. Are people shocked that planes can actually fall out of the sky? Maybe you have an infatuation with death or something. If you love reading about carnage so much enjoy http://www-fars.nhtsa.dot.gov/Main/index.aspx

Some of you guys really remind me of old women who love to troll the obituaries to see if anyone they knew died.


Is anyone else but me even mildly annoyed at this sexist comment? Where's SeatClutcher when you need her. Sorry to pick on ya, Toonces, but old men do the same thing. ;)
 
We had a aviation safety forum for a period of time, but I think we had less traffic on that than modern day Route 66.

Wait, that doesn't even make sense.

I think if we had a deeper pool of techies and folks with aircraft crash investigation experience or training, it might be more beneficial.

Thanks Doug - appreciate the response. Just seemed with all the experience here from pilots it would be beneficial. I understand about the lack of traffic though.
 
Honestly, I don't see the problem with posting every plane crash that happens here. I don't often hear about them on the news, and generally learn from them. It is also related to my industry, and I want to know what happens out there.

If you don't like what's being discussed, as they say about TV programming, change the channel. That doesn't mean that folks can flame and be disrespectful (for those who may be unclear of my intent), but we should be able to discuss any PG related subjects we wish.

lovingly submitted, Dale:)

bbbbBBBBZZZzzzzzzzzzzz
 
We had a aviation safety forum for a period of time, but I think we had less traffic on that than modern day Route 66.

Wait, that doesn't even make sense.

I think if we had a deeper pool of techies and folks with aircraft crash investigation experience or training, it might be more beneficial.

Time for 'Ask an NTSB Investigator' :p
 
Thanks for posting. Some people (like me) do not watch the news! So I appreciate you sharing this info which relates to our interest!
Our thoughts and prayers to those injured. It will be interesting to see what the cause was. Perhaps someday when we find out what the cause was this knowledge will prevent another accident from happening. I lost two friends myself less then a year ago, I hope the ntsb will find the cause in their crash. The cfi was a master cfi, we all are very confused at this time to what could have gone wrong. I hope we will eventually find out!
 
Is anyone else but me even mildly annoyed at this sexist comment? Where's SeatClutcher when you need her. Sorry to pick on ya, Toonces, but old men do the same thing. ;)

That was from my personal experience. My mom reads the obituaries and queries me on anybody I may have even possibly known however brief it may have been. "Do you remember that kid Billy you played T Ball with? His dad had a hart attack and died." Wow mom that's great. I didn't know the guy.
 
Back
Top