AZBigDog
Well-Known Member
I think the only thing that will water down this site is people telling others that they should not post this or should not post that. If someone has to constantly worry whether something they post is going to cause them grief, then they are less likely to post, and that cannot be positive for our community. No matter what is said, it is bound to upset SOMEONE, so you cannot let that stop you, otherwise you may as well just be a lurker, and when everyone does that, then where is our beloved JC?? As far as crashes being an appropriate topic, of course they are. It's yet another part of flying, not a pleasant part, but a part non-the-less. When someone posts a message about a plane that crashed, then another user realizes they just flew that same plane last week, it causes us all to keep our awareness up a little, and maybe it will cause someone to catch a safety issue they might otherwise have missed. How can that be bad?
Darren,
You provide some very valid points in your reply and I can see the benefits that will arise from posting random crashes on the site. However, posting every plane crash on JC would take away from the value JC is intended to give.
My intent was not to discourage anyone from posting whatever they feel are aviation related topics. My point is that JC is a tool from which aspiring aviation professionals and enthusiasts can benefit from the information provided here. Having to sift through all the extra plane crash posts would render the site less effective in its purpose.
Since this is not my site to govern, my opinion is just that, an opinion. If Doug or Kristie feel it's suitable, then by all means post away.
Still just my 0.02.
Al