PIC logging question

Your FSDO might buy that but I know the FSDO/examiner that I work with wouldn't accept it. If you read hard enough the regs will tell you anything you want. I think we will have to agree to disagree on this subject!

Midlifeflyer's information comes from copious Legal Interpretations by the FAA's General Counsel's Office, so it's their opinion you're disagreeing with. Everything he says is spot on; however, your understanding of it seems to be unclear. For instance, you need a current medical to be a safety pilot, PIC or SIC.

Chances are your FSDO/Examiner aren't particularly knowledgeable on this subject. You'll learn a lot more by asking for clarifications than you will by "agreeing to disagree."
 
By reading these 2 paragraphs I would be led to believe that a private pilot rated individual with an expired medical (and legally blind) and expired flight review could serve as safety pilot (PIC) in a turbine single (thinking PC-12, C-208 etc...).
Well,...you're reading them wrong. The blind private pilot with no medical and no BFR and hasn't flown in 20 years and then only in a J-3 could log PIC, I said LOG pic as a sole manipulator as long as he has a current qualified PIC acting. That's stupid to me, too, but at least he cannot be ACTING.

He can be a SAFETY PILOT and log SIC if he has a current medical, but he does not have to be qualified in the airplane other than cat and class rated.
 
FROM XYX
TO XYZ
Total Duration Of Flight .8
ASEL .8
Landings 0
Approaches 0
PIC .8
SIC .8

Remarks: Serving as safety pilot for Joe Blow

you can only log SIC time while acting as such in an aircraft that requires an SIC.

You can't have both PIC and SIC. You are either in command or you aren't. (Unless you have one hand on each yoke and argue with yourself about every decision you make!)
 
You can't have both PIC and SIC. You are either in command or you aren't. (Unless you have one hand on each yoke and argue with yourself about every decision you make!)

You don't need to be in command to log PIC time if you're the sole manipulator of an aircraft in which you are rated.
 
The question I have is in regards to logging the time in my logbook. Can someone, or multiple people, please tell me how to log the following scenario in my logbook as I was the safety pilot.

The flight departed KXYZ back into KXYZ with total time 1.1 on the hobbs. The left seat pilot donned the hood and was under the hood for a total of .8. He flew a hold and then shot 2 approaches into KXYZ.

In my logbook what should I put for the following colums?

FROM
TO
Total Duration Of Flight
ASEL
Landings
Approaches
PIC
SIC

I have a good idea as to what I should be logging but I would just like confirmation from some of you guys that have been doing it a lot.
SoCal, there's a piece of information missing before I can take a shot at a complete answer - which pilot was the pilot in command of the flight> I mean the Part 1 PIC - which pilot was the final authority and responsible for the safety of the flight?

Other than that, I would be happy to work with the assumption that each pilot was qualified for the assigned role and that your role was solely as the safety pilot - in other words, you did no flying.

Without knowing who was the =acting= PIC, my responses are:

FROM - KXYZ
TO - KXYZ
Total Duration Of Flight - .8. Your flight time was the total time you were acting as a required safety pilot.
ASEL - .8 - Same as the total flight time.
Landings - 0. To count landings, you need to be the sole manipulator for the landings.
Approaches - 0. To count approaches, you need to perform them in actual or simulated IMC; the flying pilot was in simulated IMC. You were not (I hope)
PIC - don't know. It depends on who was =acting= as PIC
SIC - don't know. It depends on who was =acting= as PIC.
 
SoCal, there's a piece of information missing before I can take a shot at a complete answer - which pilot was the pilot in command of the flight> I mean the Part 1 PIC - which pilot was the final authority and responsible for the safety of the flight?

Other than that, I would be happy to work with the assumption that each pilot was qualified for the assigned role and that your role was solely as the safety pilot - in other words, you did no flying.

Without knowing who was the =acting= PIC, my responses are:

FROM - KXYZ
TO - KXYZ
Total Duration Of Flight - .8. Your flight time was the total time you were acting as a required safety pilot.
ASEL - .8 - Same as the total flight time.
Landings - 0. To count landings, you need to be the sole manipulator for the landings.
Approaches - 0. To count approaches, you need to perform them in actual or simulated IMC; the flying pilot was in simulated IMC. You were not (I hope)
PIC - don't know. It depends on who was =acting= as PIC
SIC - don't know. It depends on who was =acting= as PIC.

Mark,

Thanks for the reply. I referenced your website and came up with a good idea of how to log the time. To clarify your answer, the flying pilot (and myself) did not specify before the flight who would be in charge of the safety of the flight (acting as PIC). I would interpret this as (Flying pilot is sole manipulator & responsible for the safety of the flight = PIC) (Safety pilot is a required crewmember = SIC).

Why would anyone flying as safety pilot not take responsibility for the safety of the flight (read PIC) so both pilots could log PIC? In what instances would the safety pilot want to only log SIC?

And also, isn't it implied and assumed that the safety pilot is responsible for the safety of the flight? I mean they are directly responsible for observing traffic and terrain.

One last question. Should there be any remarks besides (Safety Pilot for John Doe) concerning PIC or SIC logging ("I took responsibility for the safety of the flight while John was under the hood")?
 
FROM XYX
TO XYZ
Total Duration Of Flight .8
ASEL .8
Landings 0
Approaches 0
PIC .8
SIC .8

Remarks: Serving as safety pilot for Joe Blow


you can only log SIC time while acting as such in an aircraft that requires an SIC.

oops, didn't even realize I put PIC and SIC in there. Nix the SIC.... now back to reading the posts...
 
On another somewhat related subject is the issue of who will be doing what when there is an emergency (engine failure, fire etc).

This is of particular issue when you get 2 CFI's sitting there looking at an oil streak on the window and they are fighting for controls. I make certain I know who will be flying the aircraft when things get ugly.

Midlife, other than my typo it looks like we agree. Now, how would you log it if it was a freshly minted in drying private pilot serving as a safety pilot in a turbine single? I may have misread but I think you said on your site that he could still serve as a safety pilot?
 
Midlife, other than my typo it looks like we agree. Now, how would you log it if it was a freshly minted in drying private pilot serving as a safety pilot in a turbine single? I may have misread but I think you said on your site that he could still serve as a safety pilot?

What, specifically, is your hangup on SE turboprops? Are they not Airplane Single-Engine Land?
 
Mark,

Thanks for the reply. I referenced your website and came up with a good idea of how to log the time. To clarify your answer, the flying pilot (and myself) did not specify before the flight who would be in charge of the safety of the flight (acting as PIC). I would interpret this as (Flying pilot is sole manipulator & responsible for the safety of the flight = PIC) (Safety pilot is a required crewmember = SIC).

Why would anyone flying as safety pilot not take responsibility for the safety of the flight (read PIC) so both pilots could log PIC? In what instances would the safety pilot want to only log SIC?

And also, isn't it implied and assumed that the safety pilot is responsible for the safety of the flight? I mean they are directly responsible for observing traffic and terrain.
There is no requirement or implication that the safety pilot be the PIC any more than that the captain of an airline flight loses his PIC role when he goes to the toilet. Don't confuse the fact that the safety pilot has specific safety of flight duties as a safety pilot with the ultimate responsibility of the PIC. This is a multi-pilot crew and just because one person in a multi-pilot crew has "ultimate" responsibility doesn't mean that others in the crew have =no= responsibility.

There are a number of reasons why the safety pilot might not be qualified to act as PIC. Regulatory ones include lack of currency and lack of endorsements - remember, a safety pilot only needs to have a medical the appropriate category and class ratings; the PIC needs to have a current FR, current landing experience, proper endorsements (complex, high performance), etc.

There are non-regulatory ones also - the safety pilot might no be qualified to act as PIC under applicable insurance or might not be a member or the flying club or an authorized renter.

Then there are "choice" reasons. If it's my airplane, for example, I may simply choose to take the position that I am =always= PIC in my airplane.

One last question. Should there be any remarks besides (Safety Pilot for John Doe) concerning PIC or SIC logging ("I took responsibility for the safety of the flight while John was under the hood")?
The only requirement in the regs is that the name of the safety pilot appear in the hooded pilot's log entry for the flight. Whether you want to do more is up to you. I don't bother.
 
Midlife, other than my typo it looks like we agree. Now, how would you log it if it was a freshly minted in drying private pilot serving as a safety pilot in a turbine single? I may have misread but I think you said on your site that he could still serve as a safety pilot?
He could still serve as a safety pilot, since all 91.109 requires is category and class.

But there is no way he could act as PIC since a turbine requires a type rating.

So, the safety pilot is only able to log SIC.
 
I'm sure he was thinking 'turbojet'.
Yeah. "Thinking" usually gets me in trouble. Let's try that again:
Midlife, other than my typo it looks like we agree. Now, how would you log it if it was a freshly minted in drying private pilot serving as a safety pilot in a turbine single? I may have misread but I think you said on your site that he could still serve as a safety pilot?
He could still serve as a safety pilot, since all 91.109 requires is category and class.

But, assuming that the newly-minted pilot had the usual private pilot training in a simple <200 HP airplane and assuming that turbine had >200 HP or was complex or required a type rating, he could not act as PIC.

So, the safety pilot would only be able to log SIC.

Better, bLizZuE? :D
 
Yeah. "Thinking" usually gets me in trouble. Let's try that again:
He could still serve as a safety pilot, since all 91.109 requires is category and class.

But, assuming that the newly-minted pilot had the usual private pilot training in a simple <200 HP airplane and assuming that turbine had >200 HP or was complex or required a type rating, he could not act as PIC.

So, the safety pilot would only be able to log SIC.

Better, bLizZuE? :D

Ok, fair enough, I will go with that.
 
Back
Top