PIC logging question

tlewis95

I drive planes
So the oppurtunity has come up for me to fly safety pilot in a C182 for someone working on thier instrument rating.

I know to fly as PIC, I have to be rated in cat/class and type is neccesary (which I am), but, I do not have the high-performance or complex endorsement for flying a C182.

It sounds as if I am still able to act as PIC.

However, SIC or PIC, I am still happy for the time, I want it to be part of the 10 hours of high-performance time I need for the renters insurance on an Arrow I want to get checked out in.

Thanks in advance!
 
If all you have ever flown in a C-150 and you have buddy with a V-tail Bonanza you can act as safety pilot because all you need be is a private pilot ASEL with a current medical and BFR.
 
So the oppurtunity has come up for me to fly safety pilot in a C182 for someone working on thier instrument rating.

I know to fly as PIC, I have to be rated in cat/class and type is neccesary (which I am), but, I do not have the high-performance or complex endorsement for flying a C182.

It sounds as if I am still able to act as PIC.

However, SIC or PIC, I am still happy for the time, I want it to be part of the 10 hours of high-performance time I need for the renters insurance on an Arrow I want to get checked out in.

Thanks in advance!

What type arrow do you plan to fly? Most are 200 or 180 hp which do not require HP endorsment.
Your ASEL allows you to fly as safety pilot and log PIC in the airplane, but your lack of HP endors. does not allow you operate the the airplane, so i dont think it would count as HP time for you!
 
What type arrow do you plan to fly? Most are 200 or 180 hp which do not require HP endorsment.
Your ASEL allows you to fly as safety pilot and log PIC in the airplane, but your lack of HP endors. does not allow you operate the the airplane, so i dont think it would count as HP time for you!

You know of an Arrow that's more than 200hp? the PA28R-201 is the 200HP with the Warrior wing on it.

And he can operate the plane, he just cannot ACT as PIC. He can log all that time which he is sole manipulator of the controls or that he is a required crew member (safety pilot) as long as he has PPSEL or better.
 
if the other pilot fell over dead would you be legal to operate the plane? if the answer is NO then you can't serve as safety pilot (PIC).
 
if the other pilot fell over dead would you be legal to operate the plane? if the answer is NO then you can't serve as safety pilot (PIC).
exactamundo:yup: get the endorsements and you're legal to fly the plane, then you could be safety pilot. If you can not go get in it and solo it, you can not act as safety pilot.
 
if the other pilot fell over dead would you be legal to operate the plane? if the answer is NO then you can't serve as safety pilot (PIC).

Sorry, but that is incorrect! Single engine land is single engine land! You can be a safety pilot in any single engine land if you are ASEL.

FAR Part 1 Defines pilot-in-command as follows: Pilot in command means the person who: (1) Has final authority and responsibility for the operation and safety of the flight; (2) Has been designated as pilot in command before or during the flight; and (3) Holds the appropriate category, class, and type rating, if appropriate, for the conduct of the flight.

Cat (airplane) Class (single el) type (no type req) Says nothing of endorsments
 
You know of an Arrow that's more than 200hp? the PA28R-201 is the 200HP with the Warrior wing on it.

And he can operate the plane, he just cannot ACT as PIC. He can log all that time which he is sole manipulator of the controls or that he is a required crew member (safety pilot) as long as he has PPSEL or better.

No I dont, Not unless there has been an engine mod done it. WHich is why I asked. You never know.
 
if the other pilot fell over dead would you be legal to operate the plane? if the answer is NO then you can't serve as safety pilot (PIC).
Give me a break. If the other pilot fell owner dead, it would be an emergency and you definitely =would= be legal to fly. :rolleyes:

tlewis95, you are reading the reg partially correct. All you need to act as the safety pilot is to have the proper category and class ratings and a medical certificate.

But, that does not translate to acting or logging PIC. Safety pilot does not = PIC.

In order to =act= at PIC you must be fully qualified to do so - certificate, ratings, endorsements, currency.

In order to =log= PIC as a safety pilot, you must be =acting= as PIC.

Put all that together and, while you may act as a safety pilot in a 182 without the endorsement, you may not act as PIC nor log PIC.

You may, however, log the time as SIC.

I explain this, with references to the regs and FAA Legal opinions in the FAQ section of my web site: http://www.midlifeflight.com/faq/faq.php?s=1#6 Even though people argue about this incessantly, it was really all settled years ago.
 
nicely done midlife
:yeahthat:

And using "what if the pilot died" argument when referring to a single pilot airplane doesn't add up. Like midlife said - he doesn't need another PIC - he just needs a qualified pilot whose most important quality is his Mark I eyeballs.
 
Thanks for all of the help guys, it looks like I will be getting SIC time in the 182 then, which is really all that I need for now.

Another side question about complex/hp and the Arrow III in particular.

the PA-28R-201 vs a 28R-200, 201 meaning 201hp to make it both complex and high performance I am guessing?

I am not exactly sure what model arrow (I know it is a III) I would be renting, but the instructors at the FBO say that I could get both endorsements in it. :crazy:

Gotta love these FARs dont you, lol.

DSC06057.jpg


A picture of the Arrow I would be renting if that helps anyone.
 
the PA-28R-201 vs a 28R-200, 201 meaning 201hp to make it both complex and high performance I am guessing?
That's not what the numbers mean. Sorry.
PA-Piper Aircraft
28-Airframe model
R-retractable landing gear
2** (series)-Engine horsepower
**1 - Third digit refers to the wing type/shape. A "0" is the straight (hershey bar) wing. A "1" in the third digit is the tapered wing design.

You may, however, log the time as SIC.
Second-in-command time may be logged if not acting as PIC.
  • Usually the case if the safety pilot cannot act as PIC. An example might be when the safety pilot is not endorsed for the particular airplane (such as in a high-performance aircraft).
  • SIC time may be logged because FAR 61.51(f)(2) allows a pilot to log all flight time during which he acts as second in command of an aircraft under which more than one pilot is required by the regulations (91.109) under which the flight is conducted.
http://www.aopa.org/members/files/topics/sftyplt.html
 
I am not exactly sure what model arrow (I know it is a III) I would be renting, but the instructors at the FBO say that I could get both endorsements in it. :crazy:
There are, unfortunately, a good number of FBOs that think that 201 means horsepower and a good number of pilots with invalid endorsements.

NJA_Capt is exactly right about what the "201" means.

Don't blame the FARs; they had to cut off HP somewhere. In fact, as I recall, there was a proposal some years ago to change to wording to read "200 HP or more." Piper and other 200 HP aircraft manufacturers didn't like it - the whole idea was to max the HP while keeping it out of the high performance group.
 
There are, unfortunately, a good number of FBOs that think that 201 means horsepower and a good number of pilots with invalid endorsements.

NJA_Capt is exactly right about what the "201" means.

Don't blame the FARs; they had to cut off HP somewhere. In fact, as I recall, there was a proposal some years ago to change to wording to read "200 HP or more." Piper and other 200 HP aircraft manufacturers didn't like it - the whole idea was to max the HP while keeping it out of the high performance group.

I seem to remember that pre-1996 the endorsement was different, and an Arrow would qualify, but I can't recall the details. I don't have 96 far/aim handy, do you recall any thing like that?
 
I seem to remember that pre-1996 the endorsement was different, and an Arrow would qualify, but I can't recall the details. I don't have 96 far/aim handy, do you recall any thing like that?
Yes. There was a major revision to Part 61 in 1997. If you look at the endorsements in 61.31, the dates in grandfather clauses are referring to the date of the change in the rules.

Before the revision, there was no "complex" endorsement, just a "high performance" one. "High performance" was defined as having an engine with >200 HP =or= having, flaps, controllable prop, and retractable gear. So there are people who have their "high performance" endorsements based on training in even a 180 HP Arrow or Cutlass (where I got mine), but not after about mid-1997.
 
I have been reading over these posts and the regs a lot to try to determine how to log my safety pilot time. I used to (about 5 years ago) log it all as PIC. Now I am getting the impression that it may be better to log it as SIC. If you are rated including endorsements, if both pilots agree that the safety pilot will be responsible for the safety of the flight (And I sure see them responsible as they are the eyes to make sure you will not be running into traffic or terrain), than he can log PIC as well.

The question I have is in regards to logging the time in my logbook. Can someone, or multiple people, please tell me how to log the following scenario in my logbook as I was the safety pilot.

The flight departed KXYZ back into KXYZ with total time 1.1 on the hobbs. The left seat pilot donned the hood and was under the hood for a total of .8. He flew a hold and then shot 2 approaches into KXYZ.

In my logbook what should I put for the following colums?

FROM
TO
Total Duration Of Flight
ASEL
Landings
Approaches
PIC
SIC

I have a good idea as to what I should be logging but I would just like confirmation from some of you guys that have been doing it a lot.

Thanks.
 
FROM XYX
TO XYZ
Total Duration Of Flight .8
ASEL .8
Landings 0
Approaches 0
PIC .8
SIC .8

Remarks: Serving as safety pilot for Joe Blow


you can only log SIC time while acting as such in an aircraft that requires an SIC.
 
<sigh>

Lots of (mis)information available on this topic. I'd seriously recommend reading this page by one of our users. One of the best summations available anywhere:

http://www.midlifeflight.com/faq/faq.php?s=1

quoted from the linked page above:
Rule 1. If you are a recreational, private or commercial pilot, you may log PIC any time you are the sole manipulator of the controls of an aircraft you are rated for. [61.51(e)(1)(i)] "Rated" means the category and class (and type, if a type rating is necessary for the aircraft) that is listed on the back of your pilot certificate. Nothing else matters. Not instrument ratings. Not endorsements for high performance, complex, or tailwheel aircraft. Not medical currency. Not flight reviews. Not night currency. Nothing. There are no known exceptions. Note that the rule is different for sport pilots who have endorsed "privileges" for aircraft in their logbooks insetad of ratings on their pilot certifciates.


another:


May a Safety Pilot Log PIC Time?


It depends. If the safety pilot is also acting as PIC (in charge of the flight), then the safety pilot may log PIC time while the flying pilot is under the hood. If not, the safety pilot is permitted to log second-in-command time. To understand the answer, make sure that you first understand the "golden key" to logging mentioned in the general logging PIC FAQ - the FAA treats "acting as pilot in command" and "logging pilot in command time" under FAR 61.51 as completely different concepts. Unless 61.51 specifically directs you to it, answering a logging question by including the word "acting" or pointing to any other FAR is always a mistake.
Logging PIC time as a safety pilot is one of those times that 61.51 tells you to look somewhere else. As usual, let's start with 61.51. 61.51(e)(1)(iii) tells us that if you are a private or commercial pilot, you may log as PIC any time you are acting as PIC (in charge) of a flight on which more than one pilot is required by the regulations. More than one pilot may be required because the aircraft is not certified for single-pilot operations. But there are other situations as well. One is set up for us by 91.109(b):




By reading these 2 paragraphs I would be led to believe that a private pilot rated individual with an expired medical (and legally blind) and expired flight review could serve as safety pilot (PIC) in a turbine single (thinking PC-12, C-208 etc...).


Your FSDO might buy that but I know the FSDO/examiner that I work with wouldn't accept it. If you read hard enough the regs will tell you anything you want. I think we will have to agree to disagree on this subject! :)
 
Back
Top