OpenAirplane

You know, I know some of those $90-$100/hr CFis, and most of them are consummate aviation professionals. They spend a great deal of time when they're not teaching their students (read: getting paid) staying abreast of the industry, changes in pedagogy and regulations, teaching techniques and so on, and developing study material, computer-based training, tests, courses of study...
The bay area is not an inexpensive place to live, and the rate reflects that. And, frankly, I'd take them in the cockpit over an A320 FO unless I was in an A320 and needed an FO, so your rate comparison is basically just dick measuring. They're lifetime professional CFIs, and that should be respected and not sneered at.
And do you not think airline pilots also spend a great deal of time staying abreast of the industry, changes in regulations, techniques, and so on? The Bay Area is expensive, but I lived there at $44/hr and $65/hr which then became 70. With just a wife and no kid at the time, that was easily doable. And of course, you will always take the person who has the most recent time and experience in the said aircraft so yes I expect you take the CFI.

They're also often professionals in another industry, and thus, unlike pilots, have a clue what their time and expertise is worth in a given geographic locale.
So do pilots. It's usually dictated by a CBA or work rules established by management.

If you don't like it, you can always look for a new instructor like myself at Palo Alto—my rate is $45/hr, and I'll probably be properly obsequious to one of your magnitude once you demonstrate a level of skill commiserate with your pay grade. (No offense, but just having a job pushing buttons in the right seat of an A320 doesn't mean that you know how to actually fly, so you'll still have to prove it over the course of a 0.3-0.8 hour checkout)

Check your bias, sir.

Your rate is actually perfect, I'd have no problem paying $40-45/hr for a CFI in the Bay Area. What kept me out from getting in a Cessna or a Piper in the Bay Area were the ridiculous club and instructor rates. Trying to find a reasonable place without exorbitant non-club rates was nearly impossible. The closest good ones would have been Hayward or Reidhill San Jose, both of which were too far. Whatever happened to just showing up at a flight school, going up in the air for an hour, and then coming back and paying 1 hr hobbs time for the plane and 1.3 hrs for the instructor (pre/post flight inclusion).

As for your no offense comment, none taken :) Just keep in mind that at least in the United States, an A320 is not an entry level job. I had single engine piston time, multi engine piston time, and a hair over 4,000 hrs in a CRJ before I even touched the controls of a button-pushing A320. The pay is therefore respective. Regional pilots earn less than major pilots for that reason. It's an entry level job versus a more experienced one. One can become a CFI in 90-120 days through an ALLATPs course.


The 90-100/hr comment is nothing personal. Just as I believe no way should a burger flipper at McDonalds earn $15/hr. The education and job experience requirements for that job simply do not justify that kind of payrate. To be a CFI is actually a pivotal "entry level" job in the aviation industry. Usually, that's the first paid flying job. For civilians pursing the airlines the logical steps would be CFI, regional, then major airlines. Payrates should be reflective of this.

I just feel bad for the pilots who are suckered into paying 90-100/hr in the Bay Area when other instructors are available that charge $40-45/hr.
 
Last edited:
I fail to see the value and doubt this will catch fire. What's the value to the renter? S/he saves, what, $60-$80 for a couple turns round the airport? Generally, if you show the renting FBO your logbook, they're cool with a no checkout flight if you have experience and recency. But perhaps more germane, if I'm at a new airport, I generally try to seek out a knowledgeable CFI to give me a little local color, insight, and feedback. Regardless of one's experience, one can always learn more. Plus, it's interesting to meet new people and hang with the CFIs and find out what's new.
The day's of FBO's renting out airplanes sans a checkout are over no matter how experienced the renter is. No insurance company will allow it anymore.
 
You know, I know some of those $90-$100/hr CFis, and most of them are consummate aviation professionals. They spend a great deal of time when they're not teaching their students (read: getting paid) staying abreast of the industry, changes in pedagogy and regulations, teaching techniques and so on, and developing study material, computer-based training, tests, courses of study...
The bay area is not an inexpensive place to live, and the rate reflects that. And, frankly, I'd take them in the cockpit over an A320 FO unless I was in an A320 and needed an FO, so your rate comparison is basically just dick measuring. They're lifetime professional CFIs, and that should be respected and not sneered at.

Eh, my personal experience was not that great. I paid $80/hour (for more than an hour) to basically review my logbook. I'm a CFI myself, why is this even necessary? The instructor doing it had no idea what most of the types were, one reason it took so long. The "lifetime professional CFI" was a furloughed RJ FO, had not been there long. To be clear, I'm a CFI myself, I don't mind getting paid, and whatever I charge is whatever I charge. But spending an hour asking questions about 10+ year old logbook entries? Give me a break.

Complex airspace is also a silly argument as well. Flying IFR? Who cares. All pretty much the same anyway. Even VFR, when you fly to another airport, guess what, you are still going to "different complex airspace."
 
Thank you.
  • We're growing.
  • 62 locations. (adding about one a week now)
  • 7,600+ pilots have signed up t fly with us.
  • 20%+ growth month over month in hours flown.

The numbers are small now, but encouraging. Pilots who have used the service tell us they like it. Operators are seeing incremental revenue and getting new customers.

We'll keep punching.

Just set up an account, on my phone, in about 5 minutes. The app is really well done, pro stuff. I am especially impressed with the pertinent data on aircraft listed, especially W&B numbers.

Will schedule a checkout when I get some time, and post about my experience.

My next door neighbor runs an FBO, will see what I can do about getting them to consider joining up.

Good job though, I remember reading about this a few years ago - glad it actually happened.
 
And do you not think airline pilots also spend a great deal of time staying abreast of the industry, changes in regulations, techniques, and so on? The Bay Area is expensive, but I lived there at $44/hr and $65/hr which then became 70. With just a wife and no kid at the time, that was easily doable. And of course, you will always take the person who has the most recent time and experience in the said aircraft so yes I expect you take the CFI.


So do pilots. It's usually dictated by a CBA or work rules established by management.



Your rate is actually perfect, I'd have no problem paying $40-45/hr for a CFI in the Bay Area. What kept me out from getting in a Cessna or a Piper in the Bay Area were the ridiculous club and instructor rates. Trying to find a reasonable place without exorbitant non-club rates was nearly impossible. The closest good ones would have been Hayward or Reidhill San Jose, both of which were too far. Whatever happened to just showing up at a flight school, going up in the air for an hour, and then coming back and paying 1 hr hobbs time for the plane and 1.3 hrs for the instructor (pre/post flight inclusion).

As for your no offense comment, none taken :) Just keep in mind that at least in the United States, an A320 is not an entry level job. I had single engine piston time, multi engine piston time, and a hair over 4,000 hrs in a CRJ before I even touched the controls of a button-pushing A320. The pay is therefore respective. Regional pilots earn less than major pilots for that reason. It's an entry level job versus a more experienced one. One can become a CFI in 90-120 days through an ALLATPs course.


The 90-100/hr comment is nothing personal. Just as I believe no way should a burger flipper at McDonalds earn $15/hr. The education and job experience requirements for that job simply do not justify that kind of payrate. To be a CFI is actually a pivotal "entry level" job in the aviation industry. Usually, that's the first paid flying job. For civilians pursing the airlines the logical steps would be CFI, regional, then major airlines. Payrates should be reflective of this.

I just feel bad for the pilots who are suckered into paying 90-100/hr in the Bay Area when other instructors are available that charge $40-45/hr.


I taught full time for years, and still do part-time. I charged $0.0 - $100.00 /hr for instruction depending upon student, goals, aircraft, type of instruction and airport. My posted rate at PAO was $100/hr. (cash in the pocket). My peak rate flying jets was about the same. But I think I should have made more teaching than flying jets. This industry has a serious structural problem; We make our least experienced our instructors. Even thought darned near the entire industry is bass akwards and thinks otherwise, teaching -real teaching, good teaching- is the highest order of activity in almost any pursuit. Unfortunately, in this nation, and especially in our industry, the dominant motto is "if you can't do, teach." In most of the rest of the world, and in most of human intellectual history, the motto has been somewhat different. More like, "if you practice really, really well; if you work very, very hard; if you observe and question and study very, very assiduously; someday, you may be good enough to teach."
Demonstrably, most training/teaching in this nation and this industry is pretty poor. It is so precisely because of our attitude toward the value of good education. People pay for what they value. I was lucky to be able to explain the value of good teaching to my students. More important, they experienced it. They finished more efficiently and more effectively. They ALL passed on their first check-ride. And at risk of whistling in the grave-yard, none has bent metal or bones. And... the best part for me: They explained the value of good instruction to their friends and colleagues.
As a nation and as an industry we dismiss the value of good teaching at our peril. Education in this country is generally kind of like the weather: Everyone talks about it, but no one does anything; furthermore, although everyone experiences Wx and instruction, very few people really understand what make them work. We pay for what we value. When people experience good education, they value it. When they value it, they are happy to pay for it. Sadly, most folks have little or no experience with good education, and therefore are unable to discern a value delta. Luckily, I've been able to explain the value proposition to my students and those who were able joyfully remunerated me commensurately. But my primary goal was never been the money. I provide hundreds of hours of gratis dual given to students of limited means who are clever and committed. If I won the lottery, I would start a flight school for instructors, train them to teach, and then provide reduced-cost training to promising candidates for the industry. I understand what it takes to command an aircraft. I value good pilots and am a huge advocate for appropriate compensation. That said, I think instructors are the apex of the industry... theoretically... we ain't there yet.
 
I taught full time for years, and still do part-time. I charged $0.0 - $100.00 /hr for instruction depending upon student, goals, aircraft, type of instruction and airport. My posted rate at PAO was $100/hr. (cash in the pocket). My peak rate flying jets was about the same. But I think I should have made more teaching than flying jets. This industry has a serious structural problem; We make our least experienced our instructors. Even thought darned near the entire industry is bass akwards and thinks otherwise, teaching -real teaching, good teaching- is the highest order of activity in almost any pursuit. Unfortunately, in this nation, and especially in our industry, the dominant motto is "if you can't do, teach." In most of the rest of the world, and in most of human intellectual history, the motto has been somewhat different. More like, "if you practice really, really well; if you work very, very hard; if you observe and question and study very, very assiduously; someday, you may be good enough to teach."
Demonstrably, most training/teaching in this nation and this industry is pretty poor. It is so precisely because of our attitude toward the value of good education. People pay for what they value. I was lucky to be able to explain the value of good teaching to my students. More important, they experienced it. They finished more efficiently and more effectively. They ALL passed on their first check-ride. And at risk of whistling in the grave-yard, none has bent metal or bones. And... the best part for me: They explained the value of good instruction to their friends and colleagues.
As a nation and as an industry we dismiss the value of good teaching at our peril. Education in this country is generally kind of like the weather: Everyone talks about it, but no one does anything; furthermore, although everyone experiences Wx and instruction, very few people really understand what make them work. We pay for what we value. When people experience good education, they value it. When they value it, they are happy to pay for it. Sadly, most folks have little or no experience with good education, and therefore are unable to discern a value delta. Luckily, I've been able to explain the value proposition to my students and those who were able joyfully remunerated me commensurately. But my primary goal was never been the money. I provide hundreds of hours of gratis dual given to students of limited means who are clever and committed. If I won the lottery, I would start a flight school for instructors, train them to teach, and then provide reduced-cost training to promising candidates for the industry. I understand what it takes to command an aircraft. I value good pilots and am a huge advocate for appropriate compensation. That said, I think instructors are the apex of the industry... theoretically... we ain't there yet.

But you don't answer the question about what makes you really worth 100/hr when others, just as good and devoted to education and teaching, are charging only $45/hr? I'm sure you're a good teacher and your students value you for all you have done. But lets draw a line somewhere and say this is just ridiculous. Rates like these keep pilots or would be pilots at home instead of going flying. Now, it also sounds like you have volunteered free of charge your services, and that's great. But if it's me, I'd pay you. I'm using your time and you are checking me out in a Cessna 172.

As for your teaching argument, that's a whole 'nuther topic. Our future lies in our kids, and public school teachers make dirt. It just is what it is.
 
To be fair here, a checkout rarely involves much instruction. It is mostly observation, and instruction is a follow on if serious deficiencies are noted. Most (current) pilots are actually quite proficient to begin with.

The CFI's I have flown with that act like they know everything - have often been the worst.

To be fair, it can be a thankless job at times, and I know of none that are in it for the money.
 
To be fair here, a checkout rarely involves much instruction. It is mostly observation, and instruction is a follow on if serious deficiencies are noted. Most (current) pilots are actually quite proficient to begin with.

The CFI's I have flown with that act like they know everything - have often been the worst.

To be fair, it can be a thankless job at times, and I know of none that are in it for the money.
Most checkouts are easy enough and result in me charging my hourly rate x 1.6ish just as long as they fly safe and don't scare me too much. Though, some have taken longer. There's a lot to go over at the school I work with on the ground not related to the actual flying such as operation of the bifold hangar door and proper procedures for taking out and putting away the airplanes (we've been the victims of renter induced hangar rash a few times in the past, so the owner is pretty adamant on being thorough here).
 
Most checkouts are easy enough and result in me charging my hourly rate x 1.6ish. There's a lot to go over at the school I work with on the ground not related to the actual flying such as operation of the bifold hangar door and proper procedures for taking out and putting away the airplanes (we've been the victims of renter induced hangar rash a few times in the past, so the owner is pretty adamant on being thorough here).
Which is information you shouldn't really be paying to get in the first place...
 
But you don't answer the question about what makes you really worth 100/hr when others, just as good and devoted to education and teaching, are charging only $45/hr? I'm sure you're a good teacher and your students value you for all you have done. But lets draw a line somewhere and say this is just ridiculous. Rates like these keep pilots or would be pilots at home instead of going flying. Now, it also sounds like you have volunteered free of charge your services, and that's great. But if it's me, I'd pay you. I'm using your time and you are checking me out in a Cessna 172.

As for your teaching argument, that's a whole 'nuther topic. Our future lies in our kids, and public school teachers make dirt. It just is what it is.

While it's certainly unusual, I'm not so sure that $100/hr for good flight instruction is ridiculous. About a year ago I was cleaning up an old hanger at my old flight school. The school's been around since the early '60s. As I was digging through the boxes avoiding the Brown Recluses and trying not to inhale too much ancient dope dust, I stumbled upon an old 1973 price list sheet typed on a 5x8 card (how quaint). Several of the same airplanes (same serials) are still on the line today, including a 172. This airplane rented for $12/hr back then. The instructor fee/hr from the same card? $22/hr. If we just use the base CPI, that $22 of instruction should now cost $113.82. By the same analysis, the $12 C172 should now rent for $62.08. So where are we really? The CFI at that same school is now making $24/hr, while the exact same aircraft now rents for $120. And, mind you, this strip in 1973 was just barely being converted from a crop dusting strip. There was a pig farm across the road. This was before any of the massive, tech-driven super-inflations of Bay Area costs. Don't you reckon what's really ridiculous is the idea of a $2 pay increase over 40 years?
Additionally, I can go out and teach skiing or guide hunters and make $100/hr, easy. If I'm a crappy ski instructor, maybe my client won't impress anyone on the steeps. But he'll still go have a nice cold beer at the end of the day. If I'm a crappy flight instructor, there's a real possibility that my student ends up killing himself and others. I'd argue that the responsibility, liability and concomitant insurance premiums assumed by flight instructors should alone justify a fee of $100/hr.
Let's be realistic. Golf pros, ski pros, tennis pros, personal trainers, etc, etc, are charging $100+/hr; the really good one's much more. No one seems to be shying away from those activities because of the ridiculous instruction fees. So, once again, I ask, Why do we continue to act like crabs in a slowly heating pot pulling down the ones who are trying to lead the way out? Why do we keep selling ourselves short? We are important. We are highly trained and highly skilled. (Or at least we should be. I fear there is too much Harrison Bergeron-like game playing going on right now to reinforce a truly high level of excellence.) We've incurred high costs - monetarily and otherwise- to become highly trained and skilled. So tell me again why $100/hr is ridiculous. Flight instruction is expensive, that's just how it is, but dumbing it down, allowing it to remain structurally impaired, and/or turning it into a dilettante passtime is not going to make it cheaper, or safer, or better in any way.
If an airline captain wants to teach part time on his days off at a discounted rate, God bless him. We need more of that kind of experienced, informed instruction, especially when it is directed toward the young, career oriented students who need all the financial breaks and experienced mentoring they can get. If some fella with fresh CFI stripes is living out of a car, hating every moment of building hours… er… teaching, while anxiously awaiting his big break at the regionals and dropping his students in the lurch the second he gets it… not so much. Regardless, for professional flight instructors to survive and thrive enough that they might arrive at lessons refreshed and prepared, asking $100/hr is really not ridiculous at all, at least not in the Bay Area. And, I suppose, if you want to go there, there's always the insidious and rather vacuous argument: it's what the market will bear.
What I find ridiculous, and where I think we agree, is how many people equate quality with price. But this stems from the fact that most students walking through the door don't have the experience or knowledge to discern any difference in flight instruction. How could they? That, and ever present egos seeking invidious distinction through conspicuous consumption. Those are issues addressed by better education, too, but how much to charge for that instruction is anyone’s guess.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
But you don't answer the question about what makes you really worth 100/hr when others, just as good and devoted to education and teaching, are charging only $45/hr? I'm sure you're a good teacher and your students value you for all you have done. But lets draw a line somewhere and say this is just ridiculous. Rates like these keep pilots or would be pilots at home instead of going flying. Now, it also sounds like you have volunteered free of charge your services, and that's great. But if it's me, I'd pay you. I'm using your time and you are checking me out in a Cessna 172.

As for your teaching argument, that's a whole 'nuther topic. Our future lies in our kids, and public school teachers make dirt. It just is what it is.

Ah, I missed that. Good point. This was about checkouts. Yeah, well, heck for a checkout to get someone in the air renting an airplane, I often do that for almost nothing.
 
Which is information you shouldn't really be paying to get in the first place...
Why not? It's time that they booked me for and I already give renters quite a bit of my time that I don't bill for doing stuff like signing their logbook (I could care less about past entries since there are no time requirements for the airplanes other than having a pilot certificate) and making myself available to answer questions they have about the rental agreement they have to sign when all is said and done. I go over the hangar procedures just after we go over the preflight (which is something I have to provide instruction on since these airplanes (Remos GX LSA's) have a few quirks that conventional airplanes don't). Should I really be subtracting the 5 minutes that takes from the time I bill the renter?
 
While it's certainly unusual, I'm not so sure that $100/hr for good flight instruction is ridiculous. About a year ago I was cleaning up an old hanger at my old flight school. The school's been around since the early '60s. As I was digging through the boxes avoiding the Brown Recluses and trying not to inhale too much ancient dope dust, I stumbled upon an old 1973 price list sheet typed on a 5x8 card (how quaint). Several of the same airplanes (same serials) are still on the line today, including a 172. This airplane rented for $12/hr back then. The instructor fee/hr from the same card? $22/hr. If we just use the base CPI, that $22 of instruction should now cost $113.82. By the same analysis, the $12 C172 should now rent for $62.08. So where are we really? The CFI at that same school is now making $24/hr, while the exact same aircraft now rents for $120. And, mind you, this strip in 1973 was just barely being converted from a crop dusting strip. There was a pig farm across the road. This was before any of the massive, tech-driven super-inflations of Bay Area costs. Don't you reckon what's really ridiculous is the idea of a $2 pay increase over 40 years?

My private training was in 2003-2004 and those numbers for a Pennsylvania flight school were $55/hr wet for a PA28 Cherokee and $20/hr for the instructor.

Additionally, I can go out and teach skiing or guide hunters and make $100/hr, easy. If I'm a crappy ski instructor, maybe my client won't impress anyone on the steeps. But he'll still go have a nice cold beer at the end of the day. If I'm a crappy flight instructor, there's a real possibility that my student ends up killing himself and others. I'd argue that the responsibility, liability and concomitant insurance premiums assumed by flight instructors should alone justify a fee of $100/hr.
Let's be realistic. Golf pros, ski pros, tennis pros, personal trainers, etc, etc, are charging $100+/hr; the really good one's much more. No one seems to be shying away from those activities because of the ridiculous instruction fees. So, once again, I ask, Why do we continue to act like crabs in a slowly heating pot pulling down the ones who are trying to lead the way out? Why do we keep selling ourselves short? We are important. We are highly trained and highly skilled. (Or at least we should be. I fear there is too much Harrison Bergeron-like game playing going on right now to reinforce a truly high level of excellence.) We've incurred high costs - monetarily and otherwise- to become highly trained and skilled. So tell me again why $100/hr is ridiculous.

Maybe you can. Maybe not. That will still depend on the hourly rate average that others are offering in that area. Problem with the Bay area is that while quite a few have rates in the 40-50/hr some of them have 90-100/hr for the exact same qualifications at the same airport.

Flight instruction is expensive, that's just how it is, but dumbing it down, allowing it to remain structurally impaired, and/or turning it into a dilettante passtime is not going to make it cheaper, or safer, or better in any way.
If an airline captain wants to teach part time on his days off at a discounted rate, God bless him. We need more of that kind of experienced, informed instruction, especially when it is directed toward the young, career oriented students who need all the financial breaks and experienced mentoring they can get. If some fella with fresh CFI stripes is living out of a car, hating every moment of building hours… er… teaching, while anxiously awaiting his big break at the regionals and dropping his students in the lurch the second he gets it… not so much.

It doesn't have to be expensive. That's the point. It's one thing if EVERY instructor charged 90-100/hr in that airport. Then you could argue the local economic aspect. But the truth is the variance is between 40/hr published to 100/hr published. That's what makes it ridiculous.

Regardless, for professional flight instructors to survive and thrive enough that they might arrive at lessons refreshed and prepared, asking $100/hr is really not ridiculous at all, at least not in the Bay Area. And, I suppose, if you want to go there, there's always the insidious and rather vacuous argument: it's what the market will bear.

It is ridiculous and the Bay Area argument doesn't fly with me. The Bay Area IMO is long overdue for a severe "re-adjust." For that matter, the entire state of California is over due. Give it time, and it will happen.

What I find ridiculous, and where I think we agree, is how many people equate quality with price. But this stems from the fact that most students walking through the door don't have the experience or knowledge to discern any difference in flight instruction. How could they? That, and ever present egos seeking invidious distinction through conspicuous consumption. Those are issues addressed by better education, too, but how much to charge for that instruction is anyone’s guess.

Exactly. So why charge the poor John Doe an above-average market rate when someone else is doing it at the same airport for 60/hr less than you?

Renting an airplane today is expensive with even the smallest ones going for over 100/hr. But this we all understand. Cost of avgas has shot through the roof and is as high as 5-8 dollars per gallon in places. Insurance has gone up as well. You have many external factors that have driven up the price of renting out an airplane. But not so for instruction, except the some-what arguable CPI adjustment YOY.

IMO, an ideal situation should be the cost of CFI instruction be approx 30-40% of the aircraft hourly rate. Paying 55 for the plane and 20 for the instructor meant a 36% rate. Later in the DC area, I was paying 40 for the instructor and 112 for the airplane which is again a 36% rate. Once in the ME airplane, then yes I understand the cost of CFI going higher. It's more complexity, a bigger plane to handle, requires a whole another rating. In the DC area it was 190/hr for the ME plane and 55/hr for the instructor and which is about a 30% rate. In the NJ area where I am now, most instructors are 45-60/hr for planes that are 130-160/hr which again works out to about a 30-35% rate.

Don't ask me why, but that's the math that I've found true in almost every state I've lived in. PA, MI, VA, NJ, and a couple in CA. That percentage formula is actually pretty accurate and a good measure I've found that works.

But put that aside, the main bottom line is something that you have a problem with but it is what it is: an instructor in the aviation world is basically the entry-level job. I'm sorry but that just is. That's right there is the primary reason I think 100/hr is over-inflated. Like how you can walk in McDonalds and get a job right away flipping burgers, with the money (or heck even the right financing approval) you can walk into ALL ATPs and walk out with a CFI in 90-100 days. It's still entry-level with that experience.
 
My private training was in 2003-2004 and those numbers for a Pennsylvania flight school were $55/hr wet for a PA28 Cherokee and $20/hr for the instructor.



Maybe you can. Maybe not. That will still depend on the hourly rate average that others are offering in that area. Problem with the Bay area is that while quite a few have rates in the 40-50/hr some of them have 90-100/hr for the exact same qualifications at the same airport.



It doesn't have to be expensive. That's the point. It's one thing if EVERY instructor charged 90-100/hr in that airport. Then you could argue the local economic aspect. But the truth is the variance is between 40/hr published to 100/hr published. That's what makes it ridiculous.



It is ridiculous and the Bay Area argument doesn't fly with me. The Bay Area IMO is long overdue for a severe "re-adjust." For that matter, the entire state of California is over due. Give it time, and it will happen.



Exactly. So why charge the poor John Doe an above-average market rate when someone else is doing it at the same airport for 60/hr less than you?

Renting an airplane today is expensive with even the smallest ones going for over 100/hr. But this we all understand. Cost of avgas has shot through the roof and is as high as 5-8 dollars per gallon in places. Insurance has gone up as well. You have many external factors that have driven up the price of renting out an airplane. But not so for instruction, except the some-what arguable CPI adjustment YOY.

IMO, an ideal situation should be the cost of CFI instruction be approx 30-40% of the aircraft hourly rate. Paying 55 for the plane and 20 for the instructor meant a 36% rate. Later in the DC area, I was paying 40 for the instructor and 112 for the airplane which is again a 36% rate. Once in the ME airplane, then yes I understand the cost of CFI going higher. It's more complexity, a bigger plane to handle, requires a whole another rating. In the DC area it was 190/hr for the ME plane and 55/hr for the instructor and which is about a 30% rate. In the NJ area where I am now, most instructors are 45-60/hr for planes that are 130-160/hr which again works out to about a 30-35% rate.

Don't ask me why, but that's the math that I've found true in almost every state I've lived in. PA, MI, VA, NJ, and a couple in CA. That percentage formula is actually pretty accurate and a good measure I've found that works.

But put that aside, the main bottom line is something that you have a problem with but it is what it is: an instructor in the aviation world is basically the entry-level job. I'm sorry but that just is. That's right there is the primary reason I think 100/hr is over-inflated. Like how you can walk in McDonalds and get a job right away flipping burgers, with the money (or heck even the right financing approval) you can walk into ALL ATPs and walk out with a CFI in 90-100 days. It's still entry-level with that experience.
You can throw numbers at us all you want, but you're worth what you negotiate and if a guy can charge $100 an hour and still have customers showing up, obviously he's doing something right.

I know a guy that runs a high-end instruction business out of Houston (focuses on IFR checkouts for owners of newly purchased high performance, technologically advanced aircraft). He did very well and basically told me that he kept raising his rates until his workload was manageable.
 
You can throw numbers at us all you want, but you're worth what you negotiate and if a guy can charge $100 an hour and still have customers showing up, obviously he's doing something right.

I know a guy that runs a high-end instruction business out of Houston (focuses on IFR checkouts for owners of newly purchased high performance, technologically advanced aircraft). He did very well and basically told me that he kept raising his rates until his workload was manageable.

I'd just like to meet the prospect pilot who sees a webpage like this:

http://www.flysundance.org/cfi_frame.php

And says, "I'll pay that guy 100 an hour!" when there are several listed for $40 to 45/hr.
 
I'd just like to meet the prospect pilot who sees a webpage like this:

http://www.flysundance.org/cfi_frame.php

And says, "I'll pay that guy 100 an hour!" when there are several listed for $40 to 45/hr.
*shrug* it's obvious you're not going to budge on this, so whatevs. Obviously there are plenty of people with money to burn who think the $100/hr guy is worth it when learning to operate a half million dollar airplane single pilot IFR. I would wager that most of the $100 guys are not beating up the pattern in brokeass 150s, they are doing the high dollar stuff in brand new Cirruses, Columbia/Corvallises, and Bonanzas.
 
*shrug* it's obvious you're not going to budge on this, so whatevs. Obviously there are plenty of people with money to burn who think the $100/hr guy is worth it when learning to operate a half million dollar airplane single pilot IFR. I would wager that most of the $100 guys are not beating up the pattern in brokeass 150s, they are doing the high dollar stuff in brand new Cirruses, Columbia/Corvallises, and Bonanzas.

True, a fool and his money are separated ;)

If I was doing basic PPL flight training, no way would I do it in a TAA. You can transition to that gizmo later.
 
Back
Top