OpenAirplane

@Rod Rakic

What kind of procedures do you have in place to standardize your instructors/checkouts? How are your instructors evaluated?

We offer a comprehensive stan/eval manual to instructors who have been designated by operators in the network. There are no "freelance" IPs. The shortcut here is that everyone knows what the PTS is, and it's performance to that standard which we're documenting. We know that if everyone can demonstrate performance to the PTS, the system works really well.

Each pilot who flies rates and reviews the operator, and the airplane that they flew. This offers us another layer of feedback and quality assurance.

Finally, occasional "secret shopping" gives us a final layer of quality assurance.
 
We offer a comprehensive stan/eval manual to instructors who have been designated by operators in the network. There are no "freelance" IPs. The shortcut here is that everyone knows what the PTS is, and it's performance to that standard which we're documenting. We know that if everyone can demonstrate performance to the PTS, the system works really well.

Each pilot who flies rates and reviews the operator, and the airplane that they flew. This offers us another layer of feedback and quality assurance.

Finally, occasional "secret shopping" gives us a final layer of quality assurance.


How will you secret shop your vendors(?) if the trail of documentation through the FAA is so hard to cover up?

I have to admit, I really like the idea, but the quality of CFI's vary so greatly, it's going to be really hard to weed out bad apples.
 
How will you secret shop your vendors(?) if the trail of documentation through the FAA is so hard to cover up?

I have to admit, I really like the idea, but the quality of CFI's vary so greatly, it's going to be really hard to weed out bad apples.

We're seeing about an 80% pass rate, which feel about right to us.

We know that everyone can have a bad day. So if someone isn't performing to the standard, our process is designed to catch it. Ultimately the IPs are the last line of defense for quality assurance in the system. We've taken much of the subjectiveness out of it for both parties. We're not asking IPs to be good teachers. (which is hard) We're asking them to be fair evaluators (which is relatively easy.) Most pilots are telling us they experience a tough but fair evaluation and say they appreciate the good workout.

So how does "secret shopping" happen... There's no telling if a pilot is having a bad day on purpose right?

Ultimately we working to weed out the subjectiveness of what passes / fails a checkout. So far operators are telling us that they are impressed with the pilots who have shown up to rent using OpenAirplane. No system is perfect, but our stan/eval program seems to be holding up well so far.
 
From a previous post,



Any thoughts? I think it's a great idea and surprised it took this long for the idea to come about in real-life practice. Hopefully they continue expanding and get more flight schools and aircraft owners to participate.

Does anyone have any first-hand experience with open airplane?

I fail to see the value and doubt this will catch fire. What's the value to the renter? S/he saves, what, $60-$80 for a couple turns round the airport? Generally, if you show the renting FBO your logbook, they're cool with a no checkout flight if you have experience and recency. But perhaps more germane, if I'm at a new airport, I generally try to seek out a knowledgeable CFI to give me a little local color, insight, and feedback. Regardless of one's experience, one can always learn more. Plus, it's interesting to meet new people and hang with the CFIs and find out what's new.
 
We're seeing about an 80% pass rate, which feel about right to us.

We know that everyone can have a bad day. So if someone isn't performing to the standard, our process is designed to catch it. Ultimately the IPs are the last line of defense for quality assurance in the system. We've taken much of the subjectiveness out of it for both parties. We're not asking IPs to be good teachers. (which is hard) We're asking them to be fair evaluators (which is relatively easy.) Most pilots are telling us they experience a tough but fair evaluation and say they appreciate the good workout.

So how does "secret shopping" happen... There's no telling if a pilot is having a bad day on purpose right?

Ultimately we working to weed out the subjectiveness of what passes / fails a checkout. So far operators are telling us that they are impressed with the pilots who have shown up to rent using OpenAirplane. No system is perfect, but our stan/eval program seems to be holding up well so far.


I wish you the best of luck. But like a new car, I'd like to see the system prove itself for a while. Do you have a way for pilots and FBO's to leave a review?
 
I fail to see the value and doubt this will catch fire. What's the value to the renter? S/he saves, what, $60-$80 for a couple turns round the airport? Generally, if you show the renting FBO your logbook, they're cool with a no checkout flight if you have experience and recency. But perhaps more germane, if I'm at a new airport, I generally try to seek out a knowledgeable CFI to give me a little local color, insight, and feedback. Regardless of one's experience, one can always learn more. Plus, it's interesting to meet new people and hang with the CFIs and find out what's new.

There is a value to the program. Standardization for all participating flight schools and ease of renting for the pilot.
 
I wish you the best of luck. But like a new car, I'd like to see the system prove itself for a while. Do you have a way for pilots and FBO's to leave a review?

Absolutely. Our reputation system is part of the special sauce that makes OpenAirplane work.

Pilot rate and review the plane, and the operator after they fly. (This becomes public.)

Operators rate and review the pilot after they fly. (This is only seen by the pilot, and the FBO which they request a rental from next.)
 
@Rod Rakic, I really do like the idea and hope that it catches on widely. How has growth been?

Thank you.
  • We're growing.
  • 62 locations. (adding about one a week now)
  • 7,600+ pilots have signed up t fly with us.
  • 20%+ growth month over month in hours flown.

The numbers are small now, but encouraging. Pilots who have used the service tell us they like it. Operators are seeing incremental revenue and getting new customers.

We'll keep punching.
 
I fail to see the value and doubt this will catch fire. What's the value to the renter? S/he saves, what, $60-$80 for a couple turns round the airport? Generally, if you show the renting FBO your logbook, they're cool with a no checkout flight if you have experience and recency. But perhaps more germane, if I'm at a new airport, I generally try to seek out a knowledgeable CFI to give me a little local color, insight, and feedback. Regardless of one's experience, one can always learn more. Plus, it's interesting to meet new people and hang with the CFIs and find out what's new.

Hey I'm the first to admit that OpenAirplane isn't for everyone. It sounds like you've had good experiences with renting airplanes, I with that was typical. Just a couple of thoughts...

  • Most FBOs require you to invest hundreds of dollars and half a day before you can rent their airplanes. This is a hassle and expense that pilots tell us keeps them from flying when away from their home base 51% of the time. (A survey of US pilots we conducted in 2011.)
  • We publish a detailed Local Procedures Briefing for all our Operators. This is an opportunity for them to document their tribal knowledge and show up ready to fly with the confidence of a local. Here's and example: https://www.openairplane.com/operators/chicago-executive-flight-school/#op-localprod

Not trying to change your mind about this, just pointing out what we built to make renting airplane easier, safer, and more fun.
 
Thank you.
  • We're growing.
  • 62 locations. (adding about one a week now)
  • 7,600+ pilots have signed up t fly with us.
  • 20%+ growth month over month in hours flown.

The numbers are small now, but encouraging. Pilots who have used the service tell us they like it. Operators are seeing incremental revenue and getting new customers.

We'll keep punching.
If you can get Channel Islands Aviation in Camarillo, CA to do it, I'll pony up for the first checkout.
 
Nothing against this guy or his company (I love entrepreneurialism) , though as a statement in general I think hobby GA has a fork in it.
I just went to rent an airplane and never got a straight answer on costs (there was talk of up to five hours of flying). So where this program would have helped, the larger issue remains I haven't rented an airplane in seven years due to basic rental costs even without a checkout. I think many are in that spot.
 
I am really looking forward to using this service next time I visit my parents in PHX. I've been flying for over two years now and have never had the chance to take my dad for a joy ride, mainly because of the checkout requirements involved with renting a plane down there. I'm really looking forward to that experience, plus flying GA in a new area is always a blast!
 
If you can get Channel Islands Aviation in Camarillo, CA to do it, I'll pony up for the first checkout.
Sweet.

We've had the best luck when customers who rent from FBOs, Flying Clubs, and Flight Schools make an introductions. (Nobody likes a cold call!) Our pitch to Operators is online here:

http://operators.OpenAirplane.com

Let us know if they are interested in having the conversation, we'd be happy to follow up!
 
Nothing against this guy or his company (I love entrepreneurialism) , though as a statement in general I think hobby GA has a fork in it.
I just went to rent an airplane and never got a straight answer on costs (there was talk of up to five hours of flying). So where this program would have helped, the larger issue remains I haven't rented an airplane in seven years due to basic rental costs even without a checkout. I think many are in that spot.

Ummm... wow. I wish this was an isolated story. It's this kind of thing that is bad for for business. It's what inspired us to build the service.

This is exactly the problem we're working to solve.

We publish a wet rate for every airplane and the specific standardized process for every checkout.

Fly with us if you want to avoid such shenanigans in the future.
 
Hey I'm the first to admit that OpenAirplane isn't for everyone. It sounds like you've had good experiences with renting airplanes, I with that was typical. Just a couple of thoughts...

  • Most FBOs require you to invest hundreds of dollars and half a day before you can rent their airplanes. This is a hassle and expense that pilots tell us keeps them from flying when away from their home base 51% of the time. (A survey of US pilots we conducted in 2011.)
  • We publish a detailed Local Procedures Briefing for all our Operators. This is an opportunity for them to document their tribal knowledge and show up ready to fly with the confidence of a local. Here's and example: https://www.openairplane.com/operators/chicago-executive-flight-school/#op-localprod

Not trying to change your mind about this, just pointing out what we built to make renting airplane easier, safer, and more fun.

While I would love to see something like this work, there seem to be several challenges around this.
One, airspace and terrain variations, has already been pointed out. But this is a huge deal. I would argue that a once a year checkout on theoretical aspects of complex airspace with perhaps even some actual practice in complex airspace is not enough to ensure proficiency navigating around LAX or SFO. I flew VFR several times a week in SFO, and IFR the other days of the week in and out of all kinds of complex airspace all over the country. But when I moved to LAX, I was still rather trepidatious and sought advice about local controller customs, landmarks, and navigating the VFR routes. As regards mountain flying, there are certainly some general commonalities regarding the dos and don'ts. But to be really safe, one must know the specific peculiarities of the specific area in which one wants to fly. Local terrain, local Wx patterns, anomalies, and wind flows are what kills people in the mountains. There is no safer way to ascertain this knowledge than consulting/flying with an experienced local pilot/instructor.
Two, there is a tremendous amount of risk and liability in renting airplanes, which I imagine elicits a high degree of caution on the part of those renting airplanes. This is similar to when an employer is hiring a new pilot. The pilot may look awesome on paper, and the pilot may actually be awesome in reality, but hiring organizations are still going to want a skills check of their own doing.
And, (2.5), checkouts don't have to be long. When I did renter checkouts, I could tell in about 5 minutes of subtly-asked questions and pre-flight whether the person was going to be safe or not. If the person seemed solid, we'd start with a turn in the pattern to a crosswindy runway (if possible). If the first turn was good, on the second turn I'd pull the engine abeam the departure numbers. If the pilot performed the correct checks, maintained correct SA, AOA, & A/S, and landed decently, I could be fairly certain he was safe. I'd have him taxi, shut down, do a hot start, then a last shut down and post-flight. Total time: ~1hr tot, 0.3-0.4 in the plane.
Three (and this is a generalization so it may not be worth a D), in my experience as an instructor I've noticed that the folks who don't seek advice are usually the ones who end up in trouble. Often times, a person's resistance to a checkout is the best indication that s/he needs one.
But I do like this concept and would like to see it work.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Pretty much all of them at PAO. Some of their instructor hourly rates are listed as 90-100/hr. That's more than I make as an A320 F/O. No offense, but I would never pay a CFI $90/hr for their services. The education, cost, plus experience time curve does not justify that pay rate.
You know, I know some of those $90-$100/hr CFis, and most of them are consummate aviation professionals. They spend a great deal of time when they're not teaching their students (read: getting paid) staying abreast of the industry, changes in pedagogy and regulations, teaching techniques and so on, and developing study material, computer-based training, tests, courses of study...
The bay area is not an inexpensive place to live, and the rate reflects that. And, frankly, I'd take them in the cockpit over an A320 FO unless I was in an A320 and needed an FO, so your rate comparison is basically just dick measuring. They're lifetime professional CFIs, and that should be respected and not sneered at.

They're also often professionals in another industry, and thus, unlike pilots, have a clue what their time and expertise is worth in a given geographic locale.

If you don't like it, you can always look for a new instructor like myself at Palo Alto—my rate is $45/hr, and I'll probably be properly obsequious to one of your magnitude once you demonstrate a level of skill commiserate with your pay grade. (No offense, but just having a job pushing buttons in the right seat of an A320 doesn't mean that you know how to actually fly, so you'll still have to prove it over the course of a 0.3-0.8 hour checkout)

Check your bias, sir.

-Fox
PS. Do you like my complementary use of 'No offense'? I'm practicing for the day someone actually pisses me off.
 
Back
Top