Military vs. Regional Airline route

From the original poster: "What are the pros and cons of flying in the Navy and going back to flying in the civilian world afterwords?"

Remember one thing, if you go Active Duty, they own you for, what is it up to now, the next 10 years, after wings? So you cannot get a job as a Major Airline Pilot for at least that long, plus you first have to finish college, so you are looking at 13 years from now.

In 13 years I doubt any of today's Major Airlines will look anything like they do today, there might only be 3 or less "alive" by then, which is why a lot of Military Pilots are staying in today vs. getting out, only to be hired and furloughed shortly afterwards. And...if you go Active Duty, they could assign you to work in a box to fly UAV's. So you've got that going for you...
 
Remember one thing, if you go Active Duty, they own you for, what is it up to now, the next 10 years, after wings?

Close, it is 8 yrs after wings for all 1310's. For the OP's reference, I've been in flight school 25 months now, and I will have 8 years of AD starting this friday when I wing.
 
In my experience, I've seen very little difference in the quality of aviators that are put out by the military as opposed to the civilian route. That may just be who I've ran into, and ymmv, but seriously, there's nothing magical about flying airplanes. The military pilots have better training than do their civilian counterparts that's a fact. But training is just the basis, you can tell the difference between dudes who have spent their time fully engaged in the real world, and those who have spent their entire time maintaining currency through training.

Real world experience, like running freight through thunderstorms, dodging rocks in a mile of vis, flying the 12th leg at regional X, or putting bombs on target down town is what makes the pilot. All the world's most excellent training doesn't mean a damn thing if you don't have any experience to back it up. As a career pilot, you may spend less than 1% of your time doing initial training if you finish out your career with 25,000TT. Its the experiences you get after you're flying daily, and the training that recurrent training you receive later that augments your experience that counts.

I've got around 3000TT, essentially less than 10% of my total time was spent in training. Or to put it another way, one out of ten experiences correspond to a training event, the other 9 experiences correspond to previous experience. Yeah, its all built on that initial foundation, but honestly, my flying style has changed so much since I started flying that I'm a totally different pilot now. The training is a mere footnote in my operational history.
 
Close, it is 8 yrs after wings for all 1310's. For the OP's reference, I've been in flight school 25 months now, and I will have 8 years of AD starting this friday when I wing.

So, essentially, you're doing the same 10 years...
 
In my experience, I've seen very little difference in the quality of aviators that are put out by the military as opposed to the civilian route. That may just be who I've ran into, and ymmv, but seriously, there's nothing magical about flying airplanes. The military pilots have better training than do their civilian counterparts that's a fact. But training is just the basis, you can tell the difference between dudes who have spent their time fully engaged in the real world, and those who have spent their entire time maintaining currency through training.

Real world experience, like running freight through thunderstorms, dodging rocks in a mile of vis, flying the 12th leg at regional X, or putting bombs on target down town is what makes the pilot. All the world's most excellent training doesn't mean a damn thing if you don't have any experience to back it up. As a career pilot, you may spend less than 1% of your time doing initial training if you finish out your career with 25,000TT. Its the experiences you get after you're flying daily, and the training that recurrent training you receive later that augments your experience that counts.

I've got around 3000TT, essentially less than 10% of my total time was spent in training. Or to put it another way, one out of ten experiences correspond to a training event, the other 9 experiences correspond to previous experience. Yeah, its all built on that initial foundation, but honestly, my flying style has changed so much since I started flying that I'm a totally different pilot now. The training is a mere footnote in my operational history.

Define training in the military? I've done real world flying via the Navy and carrier ops, I've been an FRS IP, a primary IP and soon will be an advanced IP in the tailhook pipeline. I somewhat agree that fleet experience is key to improving an avaitor's overall ability. I was just a trash hauler but I flew on all sorts of weather, landing on the carrier in all sorts of weather, both day and night. As an FRS IP, I also flew in all sorts of weather, day/night at the boat. As a primary IP, not so much in the weather but flying with studs during OCF, spins, aero, landing pattern, etc is a tough business and a great way to increase one's experience level in the more dynamic regimes of flight, especially for the big winged (P-3/E-2/C-2/E-6) and helo drivers.

Not every military aviator is going to be top notch, I've seen some who just blew my mind as to how they made it through the program. However, the training is second to none and fleet experience will be unlike anything most guys will every experience. Granted, I assume things like being an Alaskan Bush pilot or competitive aerobatic pilot is a specialty niche that has extreme challenges and is certainly worthy of respect no doubt. I'm assuming the general GA path that leads to the regionals isn't quite as challenging however.
 
On the training issue, my Dad, a long time Civilian flight instructor, now a retired North West Capt., used to say, "Give me enought bananas and I can teach any monkey to fly." You remember the first astronaut was a monkey, right? See? It can be done.

In the civilian world, as long as the student keeps showing up with money, the IP will keep teaching him, and maybe, eventually, he'll figure out how to do it, or give up and go spend his money on new golf clubs.

The military has only -so many- bananas. You get 10 bananas and then go solo, in a jet. Ten more and a check ride, 10 more and another checkride. If it takes you 11 rides to "be ready" you've got a problem, you'll get another ride or two...maybe...but then it's up or out.

They have a tough mission, take a green newbie with no time, from zero to hero, in about 12 months. You either get it the first time around or you are soon eliminated. That same philosophy extends all the way up the pipline even after you've got your wings, every time you go to a new jet.

They train to tighter standards where as the civilian training by comparison is quite laid back, money being the prime motivator, not student performance, and there is that whole rank and chain of command "Yes Sir, No Sir, Three bags full" thingy to deal with in the military vs. "Hey Dude, how's it hangin'? " in the civilian world. You keep bringing the money, they'll keep training you.

Now, the "end product" from the military world is a known product, for the most part. Any airline interviewing knows a military pilot has performed under intense pressure, passed "the test" and if he gets a good letter or two from his commanders, he's good to go, as long as he's got no skeletons in his closet, like DWI's, kiddie porn, etc.

The civilian applicant on the other hand, not so much a "proven product", unless he's come up through the RJ pipeline that some Majors have set up for that purpose; to weed out the idiots and get the rest to pay for their own jet training. Com Air Academy comes to mind. The Major interviewers know who's who and can pick up the phone to get the low-down on you, your sick leave use, and late sign in's, in about 5 minutes.

If your goal is to become a pilot at a Major Airline, either path will get you there. It is much harder, statistically, to become a Navy Fighter Pilot however and there are risks involved if you can't cut the mustard. The Navy still owns you, they are not going to turn you lose to pursue the other path until they get their pound of flesh out of you, they might send you to RIO or WSO school, so be sure when you sign on that line you are prepared to study hard, work hard and commit many years of your life to it. In my 12 mo. of UPT I studied much harder than I did in all 4 years of college...combined, and I had an ATP and 4,500 TT when I showed up at UPT, I still had to bust my ass to learn to fly "The Military Way". But I also met a lot of great guys and some of them are still my closest friends, 25 years later. Most of them got hired at Major Airlines.

It could turn out to be the best thing you ever did, especially if all the Majors go bankrupt...again...and they easily could, putting more former Navy Fighter Pilots out on the street. But you might still be on active duty, still employed. Sure, you might be on a ship in the middle of the ocean for 9mo. with 3 other guys trying to take a shower with you in a 2x2' box, but hey, it worked for Mavrick and Goose, just don't be the first one to drop the soap...
 
I had an ATP and 4,500 TT when I showed up at UPT, I still had to bust my ass to learn to fly "The Military Way". ...

Nearly exactly the same for me.

My class started out with 35, and graduated 16.
 
We even lost one kid who graduated from Embry Riddle with 800 hours and all his tickets but he was still thinking at Cessna speed and just could not catch up to the jet. Sometimes I think all that prop time is more of a hindrence than a help.
 
Hey people,

I was wondering if I could gather a few opinions from this thread. Here's my situation, I'm a CFI in California with about 1,300TT and about 3 more years of college to go. My goal has always been to fly for a major air carrier one day but I am now having a slight hesitation about going the "regional route" like most others. More recently, I have become more interested in military aviation...so for all you military flyers out there, what are the chances of someone in my situation, once I finish college, to become a fighter pilot or any kind of naval aviator? I'm starting to consider the US Navy as an option, but I don't know how to go about this. Any fighter pilots or former fighter pilots out there that can steer me in the right direction? What are the pros and cons of flying in the Navy and going back to flying in the civilian world afterwords? I just have this gut feeling that the better trained pilots come out of the military, am I wrong?Thanks!

KH

Just FYI, I've been working with an AF officer recruiter, and he notified me last week that all rated/non-rated OTS boards have been canceled for 2010. The next scheduled board is March 2011, but it is also likely to be canceled.
 
We even lost one kid who graduated from Embry Riddle with 800 hours and all his tickets but he was still thinking at Cessna speed and just could not catch up to the jet. Sometimes I think all that prop time is more of a hindrence than a help.

I'm not gonna lie, there have been times in jet school where I have felt that my prior civvie time has hindered me for this exact reason. I think it comes down to how hard you want to work to break old habits, and realizing that everything is different (ie you really do need to hit the books and chairfly)
 
Define training in the military? I've done real world flying via the Navy and carrier ops, I've been an FRS IP, a primary IP and soon will be an advanced IP in the tailhook pipeline. I somewhat agree that fleet experience is key to improving an avaitor's overall ability. I was just a trash hauler but I flew on all sorts of weather, landing on the carrier in all sorts of weather, both day and night. As an FRS IP, I also flew in all sorts of weather, day/night at the boat. As a primary IP, not so much in the weather but flying with studs during OCF, spins, aero, landing pattern, etc is a tough business and a great way to increase one's experience level in the more dynamic regimes of flight, especially for the big winged (P-3/E-2/C-2/E-6) and helo drivers.

Not every military aviator is going to be top notch, I've seen some who just blew my mind as to how they made it through the program. However, the training is second to none and fleet experience will be unlike anything most guys will every experience. Granted, I assume things like being an Alaskan Bush pilot or competitive aerobatic pilot is a specialty niche that has extreme challenges and is certainly worthy of respect no doubt. I'm assuming the general GA path that leads to the regionals isn't quite as challenging however.


By training I mean the initial time between starting and getting winged. All I think is that experience is what matters, not the initial training for more than the first 1000TT. I learned more in my first 500TT outside of the training environment, than I learned throughout my entire flight training.

As for the bolded, BADASS! You've got experience! "Just a trashhauler" means that you probably flew through some of the most hellacious stuff that nature could throw at you. That said, you probably weren't ready for the most terrifying stuff as a brand new dude out of school, and now looking back, the stuff that seemed terrifying probably isn't. Experience.
 
I'm not gonna lie, there have been times in jet school where I have felt that my prior civvie time has hindered me for this exact reason. I think it comes down to how hard you want to work to break old habits, and realizing that everything is different (ie you really do need to hit the books and chairfly)

Just speaking for myself personally, but I don't really feel like I had to "unlearn" anything. The acro, form, and low levels were new to me anyway, but flying an ILS is still flying an ILS, so there wasn't much new in the instrument training (except for maybe the fix-to-fixes we did and the high altitude approaches).
 
That low-level comment reminded me of one of my T38 low level briefs. I was to fly with a Lt. Col. who had just come out of A10's and was new to the squadron. He was not my 'regular' IP, who was also the scheduler so I was kind of an orphan as he was usually too busy to sit at our table. Anyway, I sit down to brief this low level with this new guy, the A10 driver, and when I'm done talking about the route, turn points, etc. he says to me, "What is the threat?" I say, "Birds, we will be 500 knots, down at 500' and there are huge turkey buzzards, and if we hit one we're toast..."

He says, "No, what is the THREAT?"

I think for a minute, and I say, "Little planes, Cessna's, we have to look out for them, they won't see us coming, we'll be going so fast..."

He says, "NO, WHAT IS THE THREAT?!!"

Now I'm confused...I think for a minute, he can see I'm out of ideas, so he says, "THE GROUND! THE GROUND IS ALWAYS THE THREAT!! DON'T HIT THE GROUND!!" "You turn your head and relax the back pressure for one second and we will be in the dirt!" DON'T HIT THE GROUND! Hitting the Ground has killed many a fighter pilot.

We then went out and had a great flight, he took it and showed me some really fun stuff as well, and we had beer at the O'club later, he had lots of great stories about the A10!
 
That low-level comment reminded me of one of my T38 low level briefs. I was to fly with a Lt. Col. who had just come out of A10's and was new to the squadron. He was not my 'regular' IP, who was also the scheduler so I was kind of an orphan as he was usually too busy to sit at our table. Anyway, I sit down to brief this low level with this new guy, the A10 driver, and when I'm done talking about the route, turn points, etc. he says to me, "What is the threat?" I say, "Birds, we will be 500 knots, down at 500' and there are huge turkey buzzards, and if we hit one we're toast..."

He says, "No, what is the THREAT?"

I think for a minute, and I say, "Little planes, Cessna's, we have to look out for them, they won't see us coming, we'll be going so fast..."

He says, "NO, WHAT IS THE THREAT?!!"

Now I'm confused...I think for a minute, he can see I'm out of ideas, so he says, "THE GROUND! THE GROUND IS ALWAYS THE THREAT!! DON'T HIT THE GROUND!!" "You turn your head and relax the back pressure for one second and we will be in the dirt!" DON'T HIT THE GROUND! Hitting the Ground has killed many a fighter pilot.

We then went out and had a great flight, he took it and showed me some really fun stuff as well, and we had beer at the O'club later, he had lots of great stories about the A10!

The ground has a 99% Pk.
 
That low-level comment reminded me of one of my T38 low level briefs. I was to fly with a Lt. Col. who had just come out of A10's and was new to the squadron. He was not my 'regular' IP, who was also the scheduler so I was kind of an orphan as he was usually too busy to sit at our table. Anyway, I sit down to brief this low level with this new guy, the A10 driver, and when I'm done talking about the route, turn points, etc. he says to me, "What is the threat?" I say, "Birds, we will be 500 knots, down at 500' and there are huge turkey buzzards, and if we hit one we're toast..."

He says, "No, what is the THREAT?"

I think for a minute, and I say, "Little planes, Cessna's, we have to look out for them, they won't see us coming, we'll be going so fast..."

He says, "NO, WHAT IS THE THREAT?!!"

Now I'm confused...I think for a minute, he can see I'm out of ideas, so he says, "THE GROUND! THE GROUND IS ALWAYS THE THREAT!! DON'T HIT THE GROUND!!" "You turn your head and relax the back pressure for one second and we will be in the dirt!" DON'T HIT THE GROUND! Hitting the Ground has killed many a fighter pilot.

We then went out and had a great flight, he took it and showed me some really fun stuff as well, and we had beer at the O'club later, he had lots of great stories about the A10!

That is a valid discussion -- was that intended to be a story about a "good" IP (seems like it to me), or a "bad" IP?
 
I'm not gonna lie, there have been times in jet school where I have felt that my prior civvie time has hindered me for this exact reason. I think it comes down to how hard you want to work to break old habits, and realizing that everything is different (ie you really do need to hit the books and chairfly)

I've always looked at it as a student aviator either has the "it factor" or doesn't have the "it factor". That means the ability to learn, retain, process and execute in the airplane, what we teach you. If you have it, you will make it through the program and civilian experience will only help (enough flight hours to matter at least). If you don't have it, you won't make it or do well, regardless of civilian flight experience. I remember flying with an ERAU guy how had around 500 hours, a few ratings and couldn't hold or shoot an approach to save his life. I remember thinking he should have got his money back. I flew with a guy who had his ppl and just rocked his flights. One had it and the other didn't.
 
I've always looked at it as a student aviator either has the "it factor" or doesn't have the "it factor". That means the ability to learn, retain, process and execute in the airplane, what we teach you. If you have it, you will make it through the program and civilian experience will only help (enough flight hours to matter at least). If you don't have it, you won't make it or do well, regardless of civilian flight experience. I remember flying with an ERAU guy how had around 500 hours, a few ratings and couldn't hold or shoot an approach to save his life. I remember thinking he should have got his money back. I flew with a guy who had his ppl and just rocked his flights. One had it and the other didn't.

The prior time absolutely helped me in instruments, fams, and in primary. I guess the difficult part initially was just thinking at a minimum of 250 kts most of the time, and getting used to dynamic flying and all the training rules that go along with it. Perhaps "bad habits" isn't the term, but I found that I really needed to speed my brain up and start thinking much farther ahead of the aircraft (if I had a bad habit as a civilian, it was complacency)
 
I guess my point was, the 'stories' you'd have about what you've seen in the pattern would simply be talking about a bunch of SUPT students.

Not exactly typical of an operational USAF pilot. I've never seen such idiocy as occurs on a regular basis with SUPT students -- even with IPs working in high-PRF trying to keep everything in line.

That was basically my point. I've seen a lot of stupid things in both training enviroments. IMHO, the person makes the pilot, not the flight school dejour.

BTW, I've seen both civilian and military guys wash out of airline training. I've known a bunch of both and it just reinforces my belief that the point of origin of the initial experience doesn't matter much. It is all aptitude.
 
Back
Top