Logging time in a Pilatus

PUpilotdave

New Member
I may have the opportunity to fly right seat this summer in a Pilatus PC-12. The pilot I am going to be flying with does not have a CFI certificate however I do. I also do not have my high altitude endorsement. How could I go about logging this flight time?
 
Not at all if you hope to avoid getting raked over the coals for it during any airline interview in your future.

Seriously, this is exactly the sort of questionable time they pour over your logbook in search of.
 
[ QUOTE ]
You can legally log it as instruction given.

[/ QUOTE ] If he does not have a high altitude endorsement, can he even do that (not that he should ever)
 
That is not the kind of time I would even consider logging. If the pilot in the left seat agreed to let you act as PIC for an empty leg and you are actually flying the aircraft it would then be time I would log. However pretending to give dual when you are not just to log time is pretty shady.

Is it really even legal log the time (besides the fact that it is a rule bender at best) as dual given if you are not legal to fly PIC in that aircraft (no high altitude endorsement)? Isn’t that like me giving dual in a tail dragger without that endorsement? Sounds like a bad idea to me.
 
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
You can legally log it as instruction given.

[/ QUOTE ] If he does not have a high altitude endorsement, can he even do that (not that he should ever)

[/ QUOTE ]

No, you would need to read the regs about that. You can that endorsment very easily though - I am not even sure a flight is required, or at the very least you can do it in a 182 with O.
 
[ QUOTE ]
Seriously, this is exactly the sort of questionable time they pour over your logbook in search of.

[/ QUOTE ]

In one of my interviews, the guy barely glaced at my logbooks, and he wouldn't even have done that if I hadn't asked about it.

You can't act as PIC because you don't have the endorsement.

The endorsement is not that easy to get, a 182 with "O" doesn't work, it has to be a pressurized aircraft, which means much money, or a simulator that represents said aircraft.
 
It has to be not only in a pressurized aircraft (or comparable sim), but includes flight above 25k too. 61.31(g)
 
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
You can legally log it as instruction given.

[/ QUOTE ] If he does not have a high altitude endorsement, can he even do that (not that he should ever)

[/ QUOTE ]

I'm too lazy to walk across the apartment to get my FARs, but I'm fair positive that he can log instruction given even though he lacks the high altitude endorsement under certain conditions. Acting as PIC and logging PIC are different beasts. If the pilot acting as PIC is endorsed and appropriately rated category and class and the instruction does not relate to high altitude operations, logging PIC as an instructor would be legal. Similarly, a CFII who isn't rated in a multi-engine aircraft can give instrument instruction in a twin to an AMEL and a CFI with land ratings can give instruction to a rated pilot in a sea plane as long as the instruction doesn't include water landings.

Even so, it wouldn't be smart (or legal) to log dual given when no real instruction takes place. You might squeeze off a few hours of cross-country instruction, instrument refreshers, risk assessment training, etc., but a summer of dual would be walking on thin ice.
 
[ QUOTE ]
You can legally log it as instruction given.

[/ QUOTE ]

I'b wary of logging time in ANY plane I have 0 time in or training on as dual given, much less a turbine.

Would actually kinda suck in an interview if someone decided to start asking you systems questions. A likely event if this winds up being the only turbine aircraft in your logbook.
 
yeahthat.gif


No way... the only possiblity is if you go fly with someone else who is a CFI or ATP rated in the aircraft, get a high altitude endorsment, then log it from that point as acting pic if and only if the PC12 doesent require a type rating. ?

On the safe side enjoy it, get the experience, no one will dispute that with you, cause you know you have the experience of flying it, and dont log it. Pick the brain of the PIC, and hopefully in the future you could have a foot in the door when it comes to hireing a new pilot...

good luck
 
[ QUOTE ]
I've never gotten a high-altitude endorsement in my logbook...........doh.....

[/ QUOTE ]

Me neither.
tongue.gif
 
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I've never gotten a high-altitude endorsement in my logbook...........doh.....

[/ QUOTE ]

Me neither.
tongue.gif


[/ QUOTE ]

I just got mine a few months ago.... easy easy easy sign off.... talk about pressurization, we were on a dead leg from MDW to Ohio we asked for FL250 once we got to about Fort Wayne, IN and then once we hit FL250 I pulled out the emergency descent check list and it was over.

Cheyenne IIXL pilot here baby! (but I just fly dead legs
mad.gif
)
rawk.gif
 
[ QUOTE ]
a CFI with land ratings can give instruction to a rated pilot in a sea plane as long as the instruction doesn't include water landings.


[/ QUOTE ]
Wrong. I don't see how much more plainly worded 61.195(b) can be:
§ 61.195(b) provides, “A flight instructor may not conduct flight training in any aircraft for which the flight instructor does not hold: (1) A pilot certificate and flight instructor certificate with the applicable category and class rating; and (2) if appropriate, a type rating.”
If you don't have a single/multi-engine sea rating on your pilot certificate you can't give any flight training whatsoever, regardless if you don't perform any water landings.
[ QUOTE ]
Similarly, a CFII who isn't rated in a multi-engine aircraft can give instrument instruction in a twin to an AMEL

[/ QUOTE ]
Negative, but a common misconception. I couldn't find the thread on here but MidLifeFlyer posted this about a year ago:
[ QUOTE ]
This is a question that comes up from time to time and the common wisdom has been that a CFI with only an "instrument airplane" rating, but no "airplane" rating is permitted to provide instrument training in an airplane, so long as he doesn't cross the line into teaching how to fly the airplane itself.

From Jeff's post, even John Lynch's Part 61 FAQ has taken this view, saying such things as a CFII with no MEI =can't= give training in one-engine failure during takeoff but =can= give instruction in single-engine operations under instrument conditions.

Finally, as a result of an inquiry by Ron Levy, an instructor at the University of Maryland and a regular contributor to Aviation Safety Magazine, the Eastern Region FAA legal counsel has started the process of putting that one to rest.

The ultimate answer is, no, a CFII with a commercial single and multi (No MEI) can =not= I give instrument instruction to a student in a Multi-engine aircraft who already has his private multi.

The response for the counsel is posted below. It takes a bit of wading to get through it since it goes off on a completely different question. The pertinent part appears in the final few paragraphs.

==============================
JAN 6 2004

Capt Ronald B. Levy
Director, Aviation Sciences Program
University of Maryland Eastern Shore
30806 University Boulevard South
Princess Anne, MD 21853-1299

Dear Capt. Levy:

This responds to your request for an interpretation of 14 CFR § 61.195 pertaining to the providing of instrument instruction. You have raised your disagreement with information contained in the FAA web site maintained by flight Standards (specifically, AFS-840) where answers are provided to frequently asked questions (FAQs). We apologize for the delay in providing this response to you and appreciate your patience.

Your question concerns the response given on the Flight Standards website (http://www1.faa.gov/AVR/AFS/AFS800/DOCS/pt61FAO.doc) in “Q&A-249.” The question posed and the answer from AFS-840 are as follows:

QUESTION: The flight review requirements of § 61.56(a) requires [sic] 1 hour of flight training and 1 hour of ground training which includes a review of the current general operating and flight rules of part 91 and a review of those maneuvers and procedures that, at the discretion of the person giving the review, are necessary for the pilot to demonstrate the safe exercise of the privileges of the pilot certificate. If the person getting the flight review holds an Instrument-Airplane rating on his certificate does the review have to be given by a CFI-IA and include instrument procedures such as radial intercepts, approaches, etc.? Can a CFI-A (but no Instrument-Airplane rating on his CFI) give the flight review to the instrument rated pilot and can that CFI cover any instrument maneuvers such as those that might be given to a Private pilot under 61.107?

ANSWER: Ref. § 61.193 and § 61.195(c); You're incorrectly mixing up the flight review requirements of § 61.56(c) with the Instrument Proficiency Check § 61.57(d). They are two separate requirements. But if you're asking whether a CFI-ASE only can administer the Instrument Proficiency Check of § 61.57(d), the answer is no. The flight instructor must hold a CFII-Airplane rating to administer the Instrument Proficiency Check of § 61.57(d). {Q&A-249}

We view, as the response acknowledges, the above dialogue as involving two distinct matters. The first concerns the requisite qualifications of the person conducting a flight review under 14 CFR § 61.56(c). Section 61.193(g) provides that a flight instructor, within the limitations of that person's flight instructor certificate and ratings, may conduct the flight review. Since maneuvers and procedures necessary for the flight are at the instructor's discretion, see 61.56(a)(2), they need not include instrument maneuvers and procedures. The flight review may be combined with an instrument proficiency check if warranted, see 61.56(h), in which case the instructor must hold the appropriate authorization, see 61.57(d)(2)(iv), 61.195. Accordingly, the person conducting the flight review need only have instructor-airplane privileges (CFI-A). Instrument instructor qualifications (instructor-instrument/airplane, or CFI-IA) are not necessary, even if maneuvers are performed “under the hood” since a flight review is not flight training for the issuance of an instrument rating or type rating, see 61.195(c).

The second matter concerns the requisite qualifications of the person conducting the instrument proficiency examination under 14 CFR § 61.57(d). Since the proficiency check is an operation related to instrument flying, under 61.193(f) an instructor-instrument rating (CFI-IA) is needed, even though the proficiency check does not constitute training toward an instrument or type rating (see 61.195(d)).

Considering the context of the response, we do not read it as indicating that a CFI-A may give instrument training in flight without holding instrument authorization (CFI-IA) as per § 61.193. Flight training is defined as training, other than ground training, received from an authorized instructor in flight in an aircraft (14 CFR § 61.1(b)(6)). Training can only be logged if provided by an instructor authorized to provide the specific training. Any instrument procedures conducted with a CFI-A during a flight review may be appropriate at the discretion of the instructor but do not qualify and may not be logged as training.

Your related question deals with the qualifications to provide instrument training corresponding to the category and class of the aircraft. As you point out, § 61.195(b) provides, “A flight instructor may not conduct flight training in any aircraft for which the flight instructor does not hold: (1) A pilot certificate and flight instructor certificate with the applicable category and class rating; and (2) if appropriate, a type rating.” You have indicated that some persons hold the belief that the possession of a CFI-IA authorizes the holder to provide instrument training without regard to the class rating held, a belief you do not share.

In construing § 61.195(b), we must rely on the plain language since it appears to be unambiguous and we are not aware of any agency-condoned practices that deviate. Section 61.195(b) refers specifically to category and class, as you have pointed out. The category of aircraft is airplane, but the class can consist of, for example, single engine, multiengine, land, and water (sea), as defined in 14 CFR 1.1. As provided in 61.195(b), to provide flight training, the instructor must bold both a pilot certificate and a flight instructor certificate with the category and class rating applicable to the training being provided. For example, an instructor must hold a pilot certificate and an instructor certificate, each with an airplane multiengine instrument rating, to give instrument training in a twin airplane. We do not construe Q&A-249 as indicating any other position.


I trust that this response satisfactorily answers your question. Should you need any further clarification, please contact Stephen Brice in this office at 718 553-3268.

Sincerely,

Loretta E. Alkalay

==============================
Scott Dennstaedt, a CFI and writer out of Maryland, followed up with John Lynch. Part of Lynch's reply to Scott:

==============================
Looking at § 61.195(c), I now believe my answer is wrong and Ms. Alkalay's answer is correct. Because, per § 61.195(c), it states: ". . . must hold an instrument rating on his or her flight instructor certificate and pilot certificate that is appropriate to the category and class of aircraft in which instrument training is being provided."

==============================


[/ QUOTE ]
 
[ QUOTE ]
As you point out, § 61.195(b) provides, “A flight instructor may not conduct flight training in any aircraft for which the flight instructor does not hold: (1) A pilot certificate and flight instructor certificate with the applicable category and class rating; and (2) if appropriate, a type rating.” You have indicated that some persons hold the belief that the possession of a CFI-IA authorizes the holder to provide instrument training without regard to the class rating held, a belief you do not share.

[/ QUOTE ]

Oy!
blush.gif
I lose . . . Should have pulled out the FARs before posting! As for the sea plane part, I have an aquaintance who picked up a single-engine amphib and was told he could fly it under his ASEL until he got the sea rating as long as he didn't make any water landings. According to him, it was his local FSDO that told him he was legal. The regs still clearly state that an instructor can't give instruction unless appropriately rated, but it seems that at least one FSDO has a different interpretation for acting as PIC. (Assuming this guy was telling me the truth, of course.)

However, I'm still curious as to whether the Pilatus would be fair game. The pilatipus is less than 12,500 and a turboprop, so no type is required. Category, class, and type (if required) doesn't include the endorsements, right? Seems that dual given would be loggable. Maybe . . .
grin.gif
 
[ QUOTE ]
Not at all if you hope to avoid getting raked over the coals for it during any airline interview in your future.

Seriously, this is exactly the sort of questionable time they pour over your logbook in search of.

[/ QUOTE ]

As one who pours over the logbooks, I agree. You don't want those skeletons in your closet for the rest of your career.

It's great experience, but if there is no rating or desired outcome don't pretend to log dual given.
 
Back
Top