Leave UAL for FDX?

There are also lots of options on mainline Delta as well as Southwest. Commuting to an earlier time zone, most likely as a lineholder? I'll take that ANY time over commuting across the country to sit in a crashpad in MEM.

Are you talking about SFO or LAX? Southwest doesn't go to SFO from SLC. The LAX commute is worlds easier, but it's also a more senior base.
 
One of the things that is interesting about UAL/FDX is that at UAL we can reserve the JS, but it's based off seniority. If I'm strapped in, ready to go, and 5 min prior a senior guy comes up, he can take it. Everyone else is served come, first served if memory serves. FDX on the other hand let's you reserve the JS (all 4-8 of them) 3 weeks in advance. Essentially removing an stressors that come with commuting. Thank goodness for SWA and Alaska currently.

The extra hour or so flight time to MEM in the back of a FDX plane would be worth it in that case.
 
Are you talking about SFO or LAX? Southwest doesn't go to SFO from SLC. The LAX commute is worlds easier, but it's also a more senior base.

Yes, LAX. He's been on property for almost a year, I would imagine he's able to hold LAX soon and will also get DEN soon. I have a friend at FDX that has been there for a couple years and is still commuting to reserve in MEM from DEN.

There are no doubt a lot of variables at play here, but as far as commuting goes, I don't see how it's going to be easier going to FedEx when the OP is already near a plethora of UAL bases.
 
28 years old, at United...and looking elsewhere...now I've seen it all.
UAL is fantastic, don't get me wrong. I'm completely and utterly grateful to be here. But this opportunity popped up and the decision to stay or go could affect me for decades.
 
Last edited:
UAL is fantastic, don't get me wrong. I'm completely and utterly grateful to be here. But this opportunity popped up and the decision to stay or go could effect me for decades.
Grass is always greener I guess. Whatever tickles your jimmies and keeps them from getting rustled.
 
absolutely...as others have said, the pension, higher pay, and stability make it worth it. The backside of the clock argument is only valid if you want to spend your entire career flying domestic...almost all international flying requires backside flying on one leg.
 
Last edited:
New guy on the forum seeking advice.



Currently 8 months at UAL. RSV commuter. 28 years old, will retire top 30. Single, no kids. Just received and invite to interview with FDX. Live in mountain west, neither FDX nor UAL have a base here.

Pros at FDX are the ease of commuting with reserved JS. Larger % of widebody flying. For the the most part, they don't have a dog in the ME3 fight or other joint venture type flying loss. And finally, mission oriented style flying. No pax, terminal bag drag, FAs, TSA, etc. Pension + 8% D.C. Hard line bidding with conflict.

Cons are easily the night flying, the possibility of autonomous airliners in the future, Amazon style threats, as well as a potentially changing trade climate. Longer commute.

UAL has been great, but the volitility of the pax airline industry can be worrisome at times. Joint ventures, ME3 threats, etc. Also, when you're flying larger widebody equipment, you're essentially flying all nighters as well. RJ's, more 175's, etc.

I'll commute forever for both. This is one of my single biggest concerns.

Thoughts?

Boxes don't b1tch, but they also don't sleep. And neither will you until you have a lot of seniority. To me that's the only CON that matters. The rest is stuff no one can possibly predict so, if it were me, I wouldn't even include it in the calculus.
 
I have a friend at FDX that has been there for a couple years and is still commuting to reserve in MEM from DEN.

I guess it is time for me to "come out" as a FX newhire.

I don't know what airplane your friend is on, but I was hired in spring '16 into the right seat of the A300, and I had two months of custom lines (scheduling screwed up, I benefited) and one month of reserve. I've been holding a secondary line (which is a line made up of the vacation/training/throwaway trips dropped by primary line holders) since my 4th month out of training. So, I have straight trips on commutable lines.

Also, DEN is the toughest FedEx commute in the company because it has the most commuter pilots who live there.
 
At the end of the day, you already know the pros and cons of staying or leaving. Do what is best for YOU. At 28, and single with no kids at United Airlines, you LITERALLY have the world at your fingertips! Seriously man, that is amazing.

"A bird in the hand is worth two in the bush."
 
I have been on the line for about 8 months on the A300 (which flies essentially domestic only), and according to my logbook as of this morning, I have flown 51% night trips and 49% day trips.

That's 50% too much for me :) To each his own though. Cheers
 
How much of that was flying overnight, vs just flying AT night? There's a huge difference between ending at 0000-0200 and ending at 0700.

I'd have to dig deeper to give you a more in-depth analysis, but every one of the night legs either started about 2-4AM and finished at 5-7AM, or began in the late afternoon/evening and landed about midnight.

And, there is obviously variation on that generalization, but that's the best I can give you from my phone without going back through the legs individually.

I did look at the hourly breakdown in my logbook (not the by-trip analysis I presented earlier) and that shows 51.5% night hours...so very close to the trip breakdown.
 
I have been on the line for about 8 months on the A300 (which flies essentially domestic only), and according to my logbook as of this morning, I have flown 51% night trips and 49% day trips.
I'm just glad you didn't have to experience the old crew lounge and dispatch area! New one is quite nice. They finished it right before I left give or take.
 
Back
Top