Is AOPA Legal a good thing to invest it?

Very, very few non-airline pilots will ever need the help of an aviation attorney. Frankly, I think it's a waste of money to buy the AOPA plan. You're better off taking the money that you would pay them and put it into a safe investment instead. The likelihood that you'll ever need it is miniscule, and when you don't end up needing it, at least you'll have the pile of cash instead of AOPA using it to send out more annoying mailers.
 
Very, very few non-airline pilots will ever need the help of an aviation attorney. Frankly, I think it's a waste of money to buy the AOPA plan. You're better off taking the money that you would pay them and put it into a safe investment instead. The likelihood that you'll ever need it is miniscule, and when you don't end up needing it, at least you'll have the pile of cash instead of AOPA using it to send out more annoying mailers.

You airline guys forget that there are other professional pilots not operating under 121. $100/year is cheap insurance.
 
Very, very few non-airline pilots will ever need the help of an aviation attorney. Frankly, I think it's a waste of money to buy the AOPA plan. You're better off taking the money that you would pay them and put it into a safe investment instead. The likelihood that you'll ever need it is miniscule, and when you don't end up needing it, at least you'll have the pile of cash instead of AOPA using it to send out more annoying mailers.
Respectfully,

Bollocks.

-Fox
 
You airline guys forget that there are other professional pilots not operating under 121. $100/year is cheap insurance.

I don't forget it. It's just that a guy flying a Citation typically will not have need for an attorney as often as an airline guy will. How many times do the corporate guys get ramp checked? How many times do they have a fed riding along? How often do they get drug tested? Etc.

Airline guys have a lot more "opportunities" to need the assistance of an aviation attorney. And even then, it's still very rare for them to need the help of an attorney for something non-industrial. The attorneys spend 90% of their time working on disciplinary and contract issues. And that's not stuff that you'll be using an AOPA attorney for.

Sorry, but I think it's a waste of money. Invest that cash. Don't give it to AOPA.
 
I don't forget it. It's just that a guy flying a Citation typically will not have need for an attorney as often as an airline guy will. How many times do the corporate guys get ramp checked? How many times do they have a fed riding along? How often do they get drug tested? Etc.

Airline guys have a lot more "opportunities" to need the assistance of an aviation attorney. And even then, it's still very rare for them to need the help of an attorney for something non-industrial. The attorneys spend 90% of their time working on disciplinary and contract issues. And that's not stuff that you'll be using an AOPA attorney for.

Sorry, but I think it's a waste of money. Invest that cash. Don't give it to AOPA.

135 guys are subject to DOT drug tests just as much as 121. Our company flies boxes and we have random drug screens and ramps. We don't have any jumpsesters, but I did my type and 135 initial with a Fed. Frankly, you have no idea what you're talking about.
 
I was talking corporate, not 135, but you may have a point when it comes to 135 operations. It could be worthwhile in that situation. Still, I would imagine that if an actuary ran the numbers, you'd probably be better off investing the money because of the extreme rarity of actually needing an aviation attorney.
 
I was talking corporate, not 135, but you may have a point when it comes to 135 operations. It could be worthwhile in that situation. Still, I would imagine that if an actuary ran the numbers, you'd probably be better off investing the money because of the extreme rarity of actually needing an aviation attorney.

I think the normal price is less than $50 a year and the professional pilots price is $100/year. I pay more for Spotify than I do for AOPA legal. I bet most insurance products are less than break even for the consumer, so it depends on what you are willing to pay for peace of mind. For what the plan covers, it is extremely cheap.
 
I bet most insurance products are less than break even for the consumer, so it depends on what you are willing to pay for peace of mind.

Actually, all of them are, unless the actuaries and underwriters screwed up. Their entire purpose in life is to make sure that people pay more in premiums and deductibles than they receive in claims. Therefore, insurance is only useful if not having it could financially ruin you. If not, then you're better off investing the money. The same is true of extended warranties on appliances, home warranties, etc. Rip offs.
 
Therefore, insurance is only useful if not having it could financially ruin you. If not, then you're better off investing the money.

Isn't that what we are talking about here? If something threatens the very thing I do for a living, I would say that is a threat to my livelihood. How many ASAPs did you fill out at the airlines? I fill out a NASA ASR report slightly less than every other flight. Not because I suck, but because I acknowledge that I make mistakes that I can hopefully learn from. All it takes is a Fed having a bad day to make your life a nightmare. Even over a career of 40 years, we are talking about 4k. One enforcement action will was It's cost more than this.
 
Big Airline guy. In the last ten years: Zero, Zero, average once every two years. YMMV.

Apparently things are different at Brown. For me (someone who flies as little as possible, even), the answers would be a lot different. The MCO FSDO just loves to ramp check us and ride along.
 
Isn't that what we are talking about here? If something threatens the very thing I do for a living, I would say that is a threat to my livelihood.

You're measuring the risk wrong. The risk that you're paying for insurance to mitigate is having to pay for the legal representation full price instead of having it provided at a discount. Would paying full price for legal representation financially ruin you? If so, then the insurance makes sense. If not, and you could afford the attorney at full price, then the insurance is a bad investment. Every insurance purchase is the same calculation. Not having homeowner's insurance would financially ruin me. I couldn't afford to pay off the note on my house instantly if it burned to the ground, so that insurance is a smart financial move. But if my TV breaks tomorrow, I can easily buy a brand new one, so buying the extended warranty is a waste of money.

Most pilots aren't going to be financially ruined if they have to pay for the services of an attorney at full price to fight an enforcement action. Someone making $35k starting out his career at a part 135 operator probably would, though, so that would probably be a smart investment. But the guy making $100k flying a Citation? Not so much.
 
You're measuring the risk wrong. The risk that you're paying for insurance to mitigate is having to pay for the legal representation full price instead of having it provided at a discount. Would paying full price for legal representation financially ruin you? If so, then the insurance makes sense. If not, and you could afford the attorney at full price, then the insurance is a bad investment. Every insurance purchase is the same calculation. Not having homeowner's insurance would financially ruin me. I couldn't afford to pay off the note on my house instantly if it burned to the ground, so that insurance is a smart financial move. But if my TV breaks tomorrow, I can easily buy a brand new one, so buying the extended warranty is a waste of money.

Most pilots aren't going to be financially ruined if they have to pay for the services of an attorney at full price to fight an enforcement action. Someone making $35k starting out his career at a part 135 operator probably would, though, so that would probably be a smart investment. But the guy making $100k flying a Citation? Not so much.
I'm not measuring it wrong, at all. I can't afford a full aviation attorney defense that would go through all the various processes to the NTSB. I would guess a 100k citation captain couldn't afford it, either. It would be nice if @MidlifeFlyer could tell us a rough estimate of that cost. I personally know an aviation attorney who clears more than 100k who subscribes to the service, as does @MidlifeFlyer. That's really all I need to know. I'm guessing a full enforcement action could easily cost upwards of 50k.
 
... stuff ...

Please review: https://pilot-protection-services.aopa.org/PPS-Plan-Details.aspx

The benefits provided are more comprehensive than this discussion has narrowed its focus to.

You say "invest" the $99/year, but assuming your suggested investment is in something reasonably safe, after the aforementioned 40 years, you've lost, at most, a potential $8k in "investment" income... and that will probably barely offset inflation.

What you don't acknowledge is that we (in the part 91, 119, 135, 141, or GA worlds) have no protection if we should have an event which threatens our medical certificate, pilot certificate, etc. We also have no source of document review, so when we sign a contract—any contract, including an employment contract—we either have to do our own legal review or hire a lawyer for $hundreds. Considering that jobs in these categories aren't considered "career-long" positions, but can certainly come with all sorts of nasty contract gotchas such as training contracts, etc., such review would add up very quickly. Further, buying or selling an airplane, signing a tiedown contract, dealing with issues from a student that comes back to haunt you, dealing with tax issues or even asking questions about the same can all set you back a tremendous amount.

Will all of this apply to every pilot? Certainly not. It's a risk-reward proposition that's best determined on an individual basis. However, I feel much better knowing that I have a legal service "on contract" to provide a certain amount of document review, clarification, and so on., and that I have a first point of contact for a certificate action (medical, airman, or instructor) who is on my side and already affiliated with—and ready to defend—me.

-Fox
 
I'm not measuring it wrong, at all. I can't afford a full aviation attorney defense that would go through all the various processes to the NTSB.

Then it's a smart investment for you.

I would guess a 100k citation captain couldn't afford it, either.

If so, then he must be incredibly poor at managing his finances.

I'm guessing a full enforcement action could easily cost upwards of 50k.

Yep, it could, if you had to take it all the way to an ALJ. Like I said, if that amount of money would ruin you, go for the insurance. If it wouldn't, then it's a bad investment.
 
Then it's a smart investment for you.



If so, then he must be incredibly poor at managing his finances.



Yep, it could, if you had to take it all the way to an ALJ. Like I said, if that amount of money would ruin you, go for the insurance. If it wouldn't, then it's a bad investment.
You just said very very few would benefit from the service. You are talking out of your ass, but you won't admit it.
 
You say "invest" the $99/year, but assuming your suggested investment is in something reasonably safe, after the aforementioned 40 years, you've lost, at most, a potential $8k in "investment" income... and that will probably barely offset inflation.

Actually, it's a whole lot more than that. Putting in $99/yr for 40 years and compounding at 8% would yield a $25k return.
 
Back
Top