Is Airbus A-380 Too Big for Its Own Good? - Report

I think that this particular article wasn't a good example. Most of the complaints have to do with him pontificating on accident causes when the NTSB investigators don't have enough information to come to the conclusions he seems to be reaching. That leads to a lot of loss credibility, in my book.

Here's my guess. You don't know Nance or his books or what he's written about past accidents. You just know that he wrote something that called at least one NTSB investigation into question. And someone may have complained about that, and people who aren't in the NTSB shouldn't pontificate. As I mentioned, Nance first got on my radar screen after he was able to answer the question that no one else could or would, to wit: Why the heck did Boeing modify the whole 737 fleet to allow airfoil anti-ice on the ground? Since those many years ago I've read most of what he's written and often heard him as an aviation analyst on TV. To me he's one of the voices of reason out there.

If you ever read anything he's written let me know. I'd love to discuss it at that point.
 
Here's my guess. You don't know Nance or his books or what he's written about past accidents. You just know that he wrote something that called at least one NTSB investigation into question. And someone may have complained about that, and people who aren't in the NTSB shouldn't pontificate. As I mentioned, Nance first got on my radar screen after he was able to answer the question that no one else could or would, to wit: Why the heck did Boeing modify the whole 737 fleet to allow airfoil anti-ice on the ground? Since those many years ago I've read most of what he's written and often heard him as an aviation analyst on TV. To me he's one of the voices of reason out there.

If you ever read anything he's written let me know. I'd love to discuss it at that point.

Your guess is not quite correct, as I have read his quotes and seen him in the media a number of times and even read a couple of his books. Barry Schiff is another person the media uses a lot that is fairly good, but, like Nance, he thinks he knows more than he does, and has been completely wrong on some things (which we have addressed in the tech section here, actually). Barry has a devoted following also, as does Nance, and both are better than the typical media "head", but neither of them are much better than the typical line pilot when it comes to actually knowing or understanding all the aspects of some of these things -- and that's not all that good. Actually, of the two, I think Barry is more knowledgeable, fwiw.

Oh, and for the record, I do actually own two of Nance's books, Splash of Colors and Blind Trust.
 
Not to play devil's advocate here, but I think the A380 is actually a good design with regards to the way the market is shaping. With the general and flying population skyrocketing with no end in sight, the air traffic system will become saturated in the near future. Unless we can build aircraft that can fly in the higher levels of the atmosphere, the only solution is to build larger a/c that can accomodate more paxs. One A380 carrying 700 paxs is far more efficient than 7 regional jets, each carrying 100 paxs - right?

From an airline perspective, you figure there are certain operating costs that are specific to the number of a/c you fly. If you could accomodate 700 paxs in one daily A380 flight, versus 350 paxs in two 747s, you could reduce your costs.

Stone me if you like, but I think in 10 years the A380 will prove to be the most efficient a/c on the market for long domestic and international flights.
 
From an airline perspective, you figure there are certain operating costs that are specific to the number of a/c you fly. If you could accomodate 700 paxs in one daily A380 flight, versus 350 paxs in two 747s, you could reduce your costs.

Stone me if you like, but I think in 10 years the A380 will prove to be the most efficient a/c on the market for long domestic and international flights.

I for one am not stoning you--you're probably right. As others have mentioned (I think...), it's going to come down to airports being willing to accommodate with ground support equipment, properly stressed rwys and taxiways, and so on.

But you're right--why pay six crews in small aircraft to fly what one crew can in a megajet?
 
Back
Top