flyover
New Member
I think that this particular article wasn't a good example. Most of the complaints have to do with him pontificating on accident causes when the NTSB investigators don't have enough information to come to the conclusions he seems to be reaching. That leads to a lot of loss credibility, in my book.
Here's my guess. You don't know Nance or his books or what he's written about past accidents. You just know that he wrote something that called at least one NTSB investigation into question. And someone may have complained about that, and people who aren't in the NTSB shouldn't pontificate. As I mentioned, Nance first got on my radar screen after he was able to answer the question that no one else could or would, to wit: Why the heck did Boeing modify the whole 737 fleet to allow airfoil anti-ice on the ground? Since those many years ago I've read most of what he's written and often heard him as an aviation analyst on TV. To me he's one of the voices of reason out there.
If you ever read anything he's written let me know. I'd love to discuss it at that point.