Instrument Approach into Uncontrolled Field - TP ??? MikeD

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I always call mileage from the field, even in solid IMC. That way you get into a habit of using the same type of position announcements and feel comfortable making them in VMC or IMC.

[/ QUOTE ]

See I disagree with that because if there are other traffic in the clouds with you they're going to scrambling to figure out what the heck you are. Use known reporting points and fixes and don't make up your own.

[/ QUOTE ]

Maybe, maybe not. Again, it likely depends on who you're dealing with. Calling DME shouldn't be too bad since other's should be able to look at the plate and see the DME associated with the fixes, pending they call a DME that's printed on the plate associated with a fix. But I do see your point.
 
[ QUOTE ]
See I disagree with that because if there are other traffic in the clouds with you they're going to scrambling to figure out what the heck you are. Use known reporting points and fixes

[/ QUOTE ]

See, I like the mileage call outs. Odds are, if the aircraft are in the clouds, they're either established on an approach or talking to ATC. If it's a non-radar environment, they'll probably be able to look at the chart on their lap and see 3 miles = XXX fix. If they're on an approach, they've either called it out already or will be in the near future, so if they have good SA, they'll know where you are.

As for JEP and Dazzler's situation, it boils down to "had to be there to see it." If the guy was a student or newly minted PPL, then 2 miles to him and 2 miles to you are totally different. Agree that his comment was uncalled for, though. If an aircraft is passed the FAF, I consider them on final approach. Otherwise, wouldn't it be called Intermediate Approach Fix?
 
Back
Top