Icing

It's all about what prudent pilot would do...whatever that means.

It's just like everything else with the FAA. If they did publish a definitive interpretation on the issue, they would be obligated to prosecute every violation. They intentionally make their interpretations ambiguous so they can pick and choose which "violations" they want to pursue. Guess which "violations" get pursued?

You guessed it.

The accidents.

As with all accidents, there is always a chain of events that leads up to the final outcome. The earlier you break that chain, the better your chances of safely completing the flight. The longer you let that chain run, the higher your chances of a violation, or worse, an accident. When I say safely completing the flight, I mean making sound decisions from the time you first intend to go fly, up until the time the airplane is back in the hangar or on the tie downs. In my book, your wheels never need to leave the ground in order to safely complete a flight. If at any point in the pre-flight planning, or during the actual conduct of the flight, you determine that the flight cannot be conducted within a reasonable standard of safety, a cancellation would constitute the completion of the flight. The decision to cancel could happen when you roll out of bed in the morning, over a cup of coffee, kissing your wife and/or kids goodbye, driving to the airport, taxiing to the runway...you get the picture. A cancellation could occur half way to your destination; either landing at an alternate or turning around and going back to the departure point. A cancellation is a perfectly acceptable completion of the flight, and any pilot that is not comfortable with making such a decision should not have the privilege of possessing a pilot certificate.
 
I am surprised people are so scared of icing. Not that I go fly through known conditions but If you are IFR chances are you have to go through the layer either on the climb out or descent so you have to pick up ice at one point or another if there is precip. Just make sure you stop the icing asap by either climbing above it or down to warmer temps.

I don't know if a majority of the people here are afraid of icing. I'm just saying why would someone think that going into Icing conditions with an unapproved airplane is good practice.
 
Such a cavalier attitude towards ice from a few people on here.....

In some places (New England in the winter, where I learned to fly) there is an airmet for icing 9 months of the year. You learn to avoid it.

Same as I have learned how to fly around thunderstorms in the south.
 
Its not scary at all until its fricking terrifying. Avoid it until you're in a certified airplane. Then go fly in some and get salty. Try not to do anything stupid.
 
Its not scary at all until its fricking terrifying. Avoid it until you're in a certified airplane. Then go fly in some and get salty. Try not to do anything stupid.

I kissed the ground the first time I was in ice. (not forecast, of course)

But, yeah, stay away from it. That doesn't mean don't fly, but be careful.
 
It isn't known until you have picked up ice there...

Am I understanding you correctly?

For discussion sake, lets create a hypothetical situation. Two airplanes of the same type, one FIKI and one non-FIKI, take off concurrently from the same airport and fly in formation on the same heading, at the same altitude and for the same distance. They arrive over a certain point, wingtip to wingtip. The known ice certified airplane picks up moderate rime ice. The non known ice airplane does not accumulate any ice. Since he is not accumulating ice, it is still legal for him to be in the same atmospheric conditions as the aircraft that is picking up ice, mere feet off of his wingtip.

Is that what you're saying?

Is it reasonable to think that the FAA would consider the pilot of the non-FIKI airplane to be "prudent" under their latest Letter of Interpretation.

Would the pilot of the non-FIKI aircraft be in compliance with the POH prohibition of flight into known icing conditions?
 
I encountered icing once at ATP in the seminole, trying to complete a cross country. Started picking it up rather quickly and it was unexpected, as we had just flown that same route, but at a lower altitude. We were only 2,000' feet higher. So I told ATC we needed lower. Went lower, still in the clouds, still accumulating ice, declared emergency and got vectored lower and to the nearest airport. Scary. We had maybe 1/4" of ice, but it was enough to slow us down 10-15kts...the airplane also felt "heavy". My heart was pounding until we broke out of the clouds and the rain washed the ice away. I learned a lot that day, with 200hrs under my belt.

Even if you are in an airplane certified for icing, you still need to have a great deal of respect for ice and keep vigilant on the deice equipment.
 
Picked it up 3 times in a C172, light rime all 3 times, I was able to get out of it very quickly.

My friend picked up a ton of ice on his 172, I saw pictures, there was a lot of clear on the prop. It was just him and half tanks, he had to use full power to maintain the GS.

Another school picked up about 1.5 inches on their Piper, flew just fine.

I have a powerpoint I just put together to teach a bunch of student pilots, I could email it to ya.

If it's practical information, I'd love to get that email! :)
 
Figure skating Martin. When we met and you were doing mixed doubles figure skating with your "cousin" Keith... that's when I knew that we just HAD to be friends.

Like I said when me and a buddy mistakenly found ourselves in a gay bar: "Dam* John, the only straight folks in this bar are you, me and the two guys we're dancing with!"

:laff:
 
Back
Top