TFaudree_ERAU
Mashin' dem buttons
It's all about what prudent pilot would do...whatever that means.
It's just like everything else with the FAA. If they did publish a definitive interpretation on the issue, they would be obligated to prosecute every violation. They intentionally make their interpretations ambiguous so they can pick and choose which "violations" they want to pursue. Guess which "violations" get pursued?
You guessed it.
The accidents.
As with all accidents, there is always a chain of events that leads up to the final outcome. The earlier you break that chain, the better your chances of safely completing the flight. The longer you let that chain run, the higher your chances of a violation, or worse, an accident. When I say safely completing the flight, I mean making sound decisions from the time you first intend to go fly, up until the time the airplane is back in the hangar or on the tie downs. In my book, your wheels never need to leave the ground in order to safely complete a flight. If at any point in the pre-flight planning, or during the actual conduct of the flight, you determine that the flight cannot be conducted within a reasonable standard of safety, a cancellation would constitute the completion of the flight. The decision to cancel could happen when you roll out of bed in the morning, over a cup of coffee, kissing your wife and/or kids goodbye, driving to the airport, taxiing to the runway...you get the picture. A cancellation could occur half way to your destination; either landing at an alternate or turning around and going back to the departure point. A cancellation is a perfectly acceptable completion of the flight, and any pilot that is not comfortable with making such a decision should not have the privilege of possessing a pilot certificate.