giving holding clearances to your students

...I remeber the term "bearing" since there's no radials but is it a bearing to the point or from it? ...
A bearing is always "to" a fix, a radial is always "from" a fix. So if you are flying on the 090 bearing to an NDB, you are flying a 090 course. If you are flying on the 090 radial to a VOR, you are flying a 270 course. Conversely, if you are flying the 090 bearing from an NDB, you are flying a 270 course, and if you are flying the 090 radial from a VOR, you are flying a 090 course.

Hope that helps.
 
A bearing is always "to" a fix, a radial is always "from" a fix. So if you are flying on the 090 bearing to an NDB, you are flying a 090 course. If you are flying on the 090 radial to a VOR, you are flying a 270 course. Conversely, if you are flying the 090 bearing from an NDB, you are flying a 270 course, and if you are flying the 090 radial from a VOR, you are flying a 090 course.

Hope that helps.

It's courses to, bearings from. So the bearing isn't to the fix. But in your last sentence, you describe it correctly.
 
that's what i thought as well

That's the problem. Even the FAA knowledge test, as I recall, includes the term "from" and "to" when issuing bearings the term bearing. If unsure, clarify.

Of course, there really shouldn't be much confusion in a holding clearance - the holding insructions will start with the quadrant in which the holding course is, which is the clue to what is meant.

So, to use Carlos' example
N1234, Hold Southeast of PWF on bearing 350, 3 mile leg, left turns.

That "southeast" is a pretty good clue that the bearing is "to" the station since the 350 bearing "from" the station is northwest.
 
Holding Phraseology is in the "ATC Bible", FAA Order JO 7110.65T.
You will notice that the information in this "ATC Bible", the specific phraseology example (specified radial, course, bearing, etc.) does not explain whether the bearing is 'to' or 'from'.

My experience has been that most controllers, when issuing NDB bearing holds, will include the term 'to' after the word 'bearing'.
However, that is not always the case, and I think maybe I have received a 'bearing from' - not sure, but the point is, to listen hard to NDB holds for this specific term, either 'to' or 'from', after the specific bearing, or course, as I have also heard.
As Midlife points out, the first part of the instruction tells which side you are on, and the bearing/radial is just a fine tuner of the specific position.
 
All I was saying with the "to" and "from" in my example is that a bearing is a direction from where you are to where you are going. So, you are follow a bearing "to" an NDB. Radials emanate "from" a point (a VOR in our case).

I have to admit I can't remember ever getting an ATC instruction to or from an NDB. I do know that the phraseology of individual controllers can be as varied as that of individual pilots at times.As MidlifeFlyer and others mentioned, if you listen to the entire holding instruction, it should be obvious what you need to do. If not, ask.
 
That's the problem. Even the FAA knowledge test, as I recall, includes the term "from" and "to" when issuing bearings the term bearing. If unsure, clarify.

Of course, there really shouldn't be much confusion in a holding clearance - the holding insructions will start with the quadrant in which the holding course is, which is the clue to what is meant.

So, to use Carlos' example

That "southeast" is a pretty good clue that the bearing is "to" the station since the 350 bearing "from" the station is northwest.
thats makes sence, but it gets very confusing if you are holding say with a dme distance such as "hold 10nm west of the UKW VOR on the east side of the XAMPL intersection". XAMPL intersection would be at 10 DME west. so if you don't have a GPS but do have DME you would have to use distance as the reference...or maybe i am over thinking this but it seems interesting.
 
"hold 10nm west of the UKW VOR on the east side of the XAMPL intersection".
You will never get a holding instruction phrased like that. It would be "Hold east of XAMPl intersection, bla,bla,bla." in the format described in the manual.
 
Back
Top