flyover
New Member
[ QUOTE ]
Not only the official version, but also worked closely with the folks that did the performance analysis on it.
[/ QUOTE ]
Still won't answer that question.
I have to correct myself (it's been a long time since I looked at this accident much). The NTSB did add the "known inherent pitchup characteristics of the B-737 aircraft when the leading edge is contaminated with even small amounts of snow or ice" as a contributing factor.
My argument would be classifying this as contributing or causal. Consider that other 737 pilots had described incidents where the airplane was practically uncontrollable in pitch and where they felt they narrowly avoided crashing, and this was at normal power. This information had not been disseminated to the US domestic 737 community. In Europe some operators had taken their own steps (after harrowing incidents) to ensure their crews treated the 737 differently in snowy conditions than other aircraft. They reported that Boeing had been unresponsive to their urgent warnings about these incidents.
So we get the CVR:
16:00:31 CAM-1 Vee-one. Easy , vee-two.
16:00:39 [SOUND OF STICKSHAKER STARTS AND CONTINUES UNTIL IMPACT]
16:00:41 TWR Palm 90 contact departure control.
16:00:45 CAM-1 Forward, forward, easy. We only want five hundred.
16:00:48 CAM-1 Come on forward....forward, just barely climb.
16:00:59 CAM-1 Stalling, we're falling!
16:01:00 CAM-2 Larry, we're going down, Larry....
16:01:01 CAM-1 I know it.
END
One debate in the investigation was what the captain was referring to with his comments such as "easy" and "forward, forward" etc.
But the aircraft achieved V2 and it was eight seconds later that the stick shaker activated. In that 8 seconds the aircraft had pitched up and climbed sharply away from the runway.
Just about everybody today will tell you that the crew forced the airplane off the runway and staggered in a stalled condition, trying to climb, until it hit the bridge. That makes sense in the context of our collective experience. The idea of the aircraft being uncontrollably pitched up is just not considered. But that would make sense when you consider what the aircraft actually did which was accelerate to V2 (at about 70% of normal power), pitch up abruptly into a steep climb, stall and then descend into the Potomac river.
Now consider the original question. I give you enough thrust to achieve all V speeds and lift off of a 6,000 foot runway. Would this be enough thrust to continue to climb if your airplane was otherwise controllable? Of course it would be.
Not only the official version, but also worked closely with the folks that did the performance analysis on it.
[/ QUOTE ]
Still won't answer that question.
I have to correct myself (it's been a long time since I looked at this accident much). The NTSB did add the "known inherent pitchup characteristics of the B-737 aircraft when the leading edge is contaminated with even small amounts of snow or ice" as a contributing factor.
My argument would be classifying this as contributing or causal. Consider that other 737 pilots had described incidents where the airplane was practically uncontrollable in pitch and where they felt they narrowly avoided crashing, and this was at normal power. This information had not been disseminated to the US domestic 737 community. In Europe some operators had taken their own steps (after harrowing incidents) to ensure their crews treated the 737 differently in snowy conditions than other aircraft. They reported that Boeing had been unresponsive to their urgent warnings about these incidents.
So we get the CVR:
16:00:31 CAM-1 Vee-one. Easy , vee-two.
16:00:39 [SOUND OF STICKSHAKER STARTS AND CONTINUES UNTIL IMPACT]
16:00:41 TWR Palm 90 contact departure control.
16:00:45 CAM-1 Forward, forward, easy. We only want five hundred.
16:00:48 CAM-1 Come on forward....forward, just barely climb.
16:00:59 CAM-1 Stalling, we're falling!
16:01:00 CAM-2 Larry, we're going down, Larry....
16:01:01 CAM-1 I know it.
END
One debate in the investigation was what the captain was referring to with his comments such as "easy" and "forward, forward" etc.
But the aircraft achieved V2 and it was eight seconds later that the stick shaker activated. In that 8 seconds the aircraft had pitched up and climbed sharply away from the runway.
Just about everybody today will tell you that the crew forced the airplane off the runway and staggered in a stalled condition, trying to climb, until it hit the bridge. That makes sense in the context of our collective experience. The idea of the aircraft being uncontrollably pitched up is just not considered. But that would make sense when you consider what the aircraft actually did which was accelerate to V2 (at about 70% of normal power), pitch up abruptly into a steep climb, stall and then descend into the Potomac river.
Now consider the original question. I give you enough thrust to achieve all V speeds and lift off of a 6,000 foot runway. Would this be enough thrust to continue to climb if your airplane was otherwise controllable? Of course it would be.