Fun morning

derg

Apparently a "terse" writer
Staff member
Had to de-ice in Denver this morning because of freezing fog. Turned out that we'd only have a 20 minute holdover time in order to get to the runway and takeoff.

DEN was departing runway 8 because of noise abatement and somehow thought we were going to be able to start the last application of icing fluid and taxi seemingly 20 miles across central Colorado to runway 8 at mach speed in only 1200 RVR of visibility.

Finally convinced DEN to let allow us to depart runway 34R (I think, but it's the right-most runway on the west side of the aerodrome. And we'd be able to go from the de-ice pad to the runway in enough time to depart within our holdover time.

We conducted a low visibility takeoff and from about 8000 feet thru 15000 feet, "enjoyed" wicked moderate turbulence during the climb.

All at midnight. Gotta love the all-nighters!

BTW, another airline, needless to say that I won't say the name because I'd get an inbox full of "You just hate WhateverAir because of blah blah blah" took off out of Denver without de-icing at all. In freezing fog... interesting! Glad they made it!
 
Yeah, I've had the same thing come up at DEN.

Interesting thing about the de-icing. In the old days, before all the guidelines, we didn't de-ice nearly as much. Since then I've had days, with spitting snow, where I departed without de-icing while about half of the fleet was over getting de-iced and anti-iced. Conversely, I went out of ATL one morning last spring when everything was frosted up. Stopped by the pad for a quick shot, just the wings and tail please, and got in line for takeoff. Noticed several airplanes, of a familiar livery to us (well muti-livery), that were departing with frost on the wings.

So everybody still has different opinions on what's safe. Even in the same airline.

God, I hated the red-eyes.
 
[ QUOTE ]
BTW, another airline, needless to say that I won't say the name because I'd get an inbox full of "You just hate WhateverAir because of blah blah blah" took off out of Denver without de-icing at all. In freezing fog... interesting! Glad they made it!

[/ QUOTE ]
Man, there are a lot of guys/gals in my sector of aviation that "get lucky" quite frequently when avoiding a deice. But all it takes is once. I'll pass.
 
[ QUOTE ]

DEN was departing runway 8 because of noise abatement and somehow thought we were going to be able to start the last application of icing fluid and taxi seemingly 20 miles across central Colorado to runway 8 at mach speed in only 1200 RVR of visibility.



[/ QUOTE ]

Noise abatement? The airport is out in BFE. It takes like 30 minutes to drive there from the nearest civilization near Denver.
 
[ QUOTE ]
Man, there are a lot of guys/gals in my sector of aviation that "get lucky" quite frequently when avoiding a deice. But all it takes is once. I'll pass.

[/ QUOTE ]

Just ask the passengers and crew of Air Florida 90. They're the subject of my aircraft accident investigation class paper.
 
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Man, there are a lot of guys/gals in my sector of aviation that "get lucky" quite frequently when avoiding a deice. But all it takes is once. I'll pass.

[/ QUOTE ]

Just ask the passengers and crew of Air Florida 90. They're the subject of my aircraft accident investigation class paper.

[/ QUOTE ]

Yeah, when I mentioned that we used to do less de-icing we also used to crash more.

If you are writing about that crash you should really consider reading Blind Trust by John Nash. He focuses a lot of attention on that accident. I think his conclusion that there was more to the crash than the NTSB finding is correct. He presents good evidence that certain "idiosyncrasies" of the 737 were overlooked for political reasons. Basically a compromised investigation.

I trained on the 737 shortly after that and what I heard and saw confirmed what Nance says in his book about Boeing pulling political strings to avoid any blame and nail the crew.

http://www.johnjnance.com/bookstore/synopsis_blind_trust.asp
 
[ QUOTE ]

Man, there are a lot of guys/gals in my sector of aviation that "get lucky" quite frequently when avoiding a deice. But all it takes is once. I'll pass.

[/ QUOTE ]

Or one written report to the FAA about the aircraft departing with noticeable ice on the upper surface of the wing.

The feds will look at the meteorological conditions at the departure time, any records of any other airliner that conducted a de-ice procedure and whack your pee pee.

I know a guy it happened to! I'm not sure how long they violated him for but it pretty much brought his career to an end. Nothing like having a violation as a scheduled air carrier pilot and getting fired to send that resume to the circular file!
 
[ QUOTE ]
The feds will look at the meteorological conditions at the departure time, any records of any other airliner that conducted a de-ice procedure and whack your pee pee.

I'm not sure how long they violated him for but it pretty much brought his career to an end. Nothing like having a violation as a scheduled air carrier pilot and getting fired to send that resume to the circular file!

[/ QUOTE ]

Do you get a choice between a violation and that other official "action"?
tongue.gif
 
[ QUOTE ]
If you are writing about that crash you should really consider reading Blind Trust by John Nash.

[/ QUOTE ]

You mean the Nobel Prize winner?

...or perhaps John Nance, the aviation author?

smile.gif
 
Actually, the current rules on deicing are waaay overboard when it comes to "soft wing" (those with LEDs) swept wing transport jets. The rules are there to protect hard wings and straight wing turboprops, but end up costing the industy $millions in fluid, labor and time, missed connections, fuel, not to mention the environmental impact, all because a few people overreacted after some hard wing and turboprop accidents.

To date, there has NEVER been an accident of a soft, swept wing jet transport due to failure to deice prior to takeoff or inflight icing. NEVER. Air Florida is oft pointed out, but that aircraft did not fly due to the low powersetting. In fact, it is unlikely it would have cleared that bridge at that power setting even if the wings were totally clean. Sure, ice does affect performance, and we should be clean, but we are well inside of safety thresholds with the current regulation.

Can't argue to change it back now, of course, because you can't say that it would be just as safe if we didn't do it, but the money we waste on that could achieve a LOT more "bang for the buck" in safety enhancement if it were spent elsewhere. All of this stuff is very well known at the upper levels of the aviation safety "power structure", from FAA to the other various alphabet groups, just stuck with it. It's an example where there is no reason to go beyond the regulation for safety's sake, if you are legal, you are definitely safe (can't say the same for the financial health of your airline or the environment, of couse...)!

I would not advocate, for a second, not following the regulation, because you and your airline WILL be violated if you are found out, and the reg requires a lot of documentation for the airlines, so it is easy for a Fed to go back and check. I always dot all the "i"s and cross all the "t"s, but I also know the reality of the situation.
 
[ QUOTE ]
BTW, another airline, needless to say that I won't say the name because I'd get an inbox full of "You just hate WhateverAir because of blah blah blah" took off out of Denver without de-icing at all. In freezing fog... interesting! Glad they made it!

[/ QUOTE ]

Uh oh, If that "other airline" was taking off around midnight, me thinks it has a pretty good chance of being Frontier? Please tell me it wasn't. I can't say I have ever heard of that happening before but at that time of night, I think we are about the only ones leaving around that time... Oh wait, no, B6 has a redeye at that time too. It was them wasn't it
wink.gif
 
I've also noticed some un-named airlines deicing with Type I only, when there is an obvious need for Type IV as well. There was a time in SYR where we deiced with Type I and IV, when four other aircraft were using Type I only... we looked at our holdover times, and with the departure delays, slow taxi for the taxiway conditions, and what not, there really was no way you could make it off the ground within the time. We just shook our heads and said "not our money, but it is our lives" and splattered some green stuff on the wings.
 
[ QUOTE ]
To date, there has NEVER been an accident of a soft, swept wing jet transport due to failure to deice prior to takeoff or inflight icing. NEVER. Air Florida is oft pointed out, but that aircraft did not fly due to the low powersetting. In fact, it is unlikely it would have cleared that bridge at that power setting even if the wings were totally clean.

[/ QUOTE ]

Two points.

1) Some DC-9/MD-80 types were lost due to failure to remove ice on the top of the wing. But this was due to the ice breaking off at liftoff and FODding the engines. I'm not sure about other crashes. At least 2 F-28s were lost, as I remember, attributed to ice on the wing at takeoff.

2) Disagree about Air Florida. If you have enough power to achieve V1 and Vr on that short runway, you have enough to climb out, as Palm 90 did shortly after liftoff, climbing sharply then stalling and descending into the river, just clipping the bridge.

That's probably the biggest misconception about that accident. People "remember" that the crew forced the airplane off the runway, couldn't climb, and hit the bridge. In fact, they achieved their V speeds and actually climbed quite briskly for a short period, a couple of hundred feet as I recall (plenty to clear the bridge). It was during this time that the captain was talking about "forward, forward" which some (me too) believe was referring to an abrupt and uncontrollable pitch up of the airplane. The NTSB never reached a conclusion on that, in part because they wouldn't believe the flight data recorder. Instead, they settled on the failure to turn engine anti-ice on and the frozen EPRs. There had been reports of other 737s (with normal engine power) almost crashing just after takeoff with nearly uncontrollable pitch up. These incidents occured in snowy conditions similar to Palm 90. No finding along those lines was part of the report or even part of the investigation record, but not long after the Palm 90 crash the 737 became the only transport category jet to be modified to allow airfoil anti-ice to be operated on the ground. This was done without comment as to the reason for the mod.



[ QUOTE ]
Sure, ice does affect performance, and we should be clean, but we are well inside of safety thresholds with the current regulation.

[/ QUOTE ]

Agree. They are very conservative rules.

[ QUOTE ]
All of this stuff is very well known at the upper levels of the aviation safety "power structure", from FAA to the other various alphabet groups, just stuck with it. It's an example where there is no reason to go beyond the regulation for safety's sake, if you are legal, you are definitely safe (can't say the same for the financial health of your airline or the environment, of couse...)!

[/ QUOTE ]

Agree. I've seen days when it was hard to see the scattered flakes and airplanes were lined up for the pad. Very expensive and schedule busting.
 
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
If you are writing about that crash you should really consider reading Blind Trust by John Nash.

[/ QUOTE ]

You mean the Nobel Prize winner?

...or perhaps John Nance, the aviation author?

smile.gif


[/ QUOTE ]

Yeah, good catch. I was thinking Nance and typed Nash for some reason? Hmmmm
 
Hmm, my info came from the Manager of Major Investigations of NTSB in D.C. and the fomer Assoc Administrator FAA, Certification and Regulation (Tony Broderick), so I think I'll stand by what I wrote.
 
[ QUOTE ]
BTW, another airline, needless to say that I won't say the name because I'd get an inbox full of "You just hate WhateverAir because of blah blah blah" took off out of Denver without de-icing at all. In freezing fog... interesting! Glad they made it!

[/ QUOTE ]

That's because they are manly pilots, de-icing, who needs that! Hehehehehe
nana2.gif
 
[ QUOTE ]


1) Some DC-9/MD-80 types were lost due to failure to remove ice on the top of the wing.

[/ QUOTE ]

I flew with a guy who had the 'double fod' on takeoff!
 
[ QUOTE ]
Hmm, my info came from the Manager of Major Investigations of NTSB in D.C. and the fomer Assoc Administrator FAA, Certification and Regulation (Tony Broderick), so I think I'll stand by what I wrote.

[/ QUOTE ]

Oh I know what the NTSB concluded. And I don't think this was the last time (not sure if it was the first) that an NTSB investigation was politically compromised.

One question.

If I gave you enough thrust to achieve V1/Vr and V2 on a 6,000 foot runway, do you think you could climb out with that same thrust?
I haven't had a pilot, who believed the official NTSB version, yet who would give me a straight answer on that one. If you take it out of the context of this accident the answer is usually, "Of course, obviously, duh."

The stick shaker on Palm 90 activated 8 seconds after the aircraft reached V2. Not as the airplane lifted off, but after the airplane had steeply climbed away from the runway.

But don't draw your own conclusions. You've got the official version.
 
Not only the official version, but also worked closely with the folks that did the performance analysis on it.
 
Back
Top