Absolute B.S.
Flight Sim helped me a tremendous amount. I was playing that game before I even set foot in a real airplane. I played it while I was training for my PPL, while I was training for my Instrument Rating . . . he11, I've played it during all of my training. To this day, hardly a week goes by that I don't fire it up at least 3 times. And, I fly for a living.
As a flight instructor for a couple of years, I encouraged my students to go home and fool around with the sim. Is it like the real airplane? He11 no. However, the ailerons make it bank, the elevator makes it pitch up, and the airspeed indicator shows the airspeed.
I'd have students go home and play around with different aircraft configurations to see what happens when you add drag, change airspeeds, etc. I'd tell them to go and play with the navaids and the sectional. Cross country coming up? Practice it at home. Just about every land feature that you can see out of the airplane is there on the game. All the rivers, the lakes, and the roads.
Some students didn't listen to the Sergeant. Others went home, and did what they were told. I saw a HUGE difference in the ones that used Flight Sim at home. You know, you're right, it usually added a couple of bad habits. I'd venture to say that it probably took 2-3 hours JUST to remove those habits.
Using flight sim usually saved them 7 or 8, though.
I'd say it's worth it.
If you want some tips on using it effectively to enhance your training experience, let me know.