FS2004.

youngflyer

Well-Known Member
I am 15 and have been playing fs2004 with flight yoke and I was wondering how realistic it is compared to real planes. I am just playing this until I can start my flight training then I will go to college for aviation and eventually become a pilot.
 
not at all.

it will help with basic things but it will ruin you because you will stare the panel a lot. A few people I know noticed this as well.
 
I am 15 and have been playing fs2004 with flight yoke and I was wondering how realistic it is compared to real planes. I am just playing this until I can start my flight training then I will go to college for aviation and eventually become a pilot.

It has actually helped me out a lot with my training. I believe I was able to get my private much sooner than if I had never played the game. And yes, I had to break my self of staring at the stupid real life 172 panel. :o

On a side note, I do think it will help me mucho on my instrument training. That is the only training that you want to be staring at the panel lol.
 
Also, another tip if you do want to play flight sim.... If you load up the Cessna 172, or any plane for that matter, just press the "W" key. It should just leave you with an attitude indicator, airspeed, vert speed, altimeter, and maybe a couple more gauges all at the bottom of the screen. By doing this you get the big picture outside (what you need to be focusing on in real life) and it will keep you from staring inside (a big no no).
 
I am 15 and have been playing fs2004 with flight yoke and I was wondering how realistic it is compared to real planes. I am just playing this until I can start my flight training then I will go to college for aviation and eventually become a pilot.

Its not realistic at all. Dont get me wrong its a good tool for learning the 6 pack of gauges and where they are located in a 172 and in similar areas on a Piper. However there is no feeling to it and that is the greatest part of flying. Also like PGT said too much FS makes for panel gazing pilots instead of looking outside. I wouldnt credit FS as helping me with my flight training at all. Some pilots do, some dont. Wait until you actually take your discovery flight and feel the airplane. I do believe you can do that when your 16. After that you will get bored of FS. Oh yeah, when you start your training dont ever think you have that extra little advantage because you have tons of time on FS. I learned that real quick by getting post it notes slapped on my gauges that read "LOOK OUTSIDE"
 
Absolute B.S.

Flight Sim helped me a tremendous amount. I was playing that game before I even set foot in a real airplane. I played it while I was training for my PPL, while I was training for my Instrument Rating . . . he11, I've played it during all of my training. To this day, hardly a week goes by that I don't fire it up at least 3 times. And, I fly for a living.

As a flight instructor for a couple of years, I encouraged my students to go home and fool around with the sim. Is it like the real airplane? He11 no. However, the ailerons make it bank, the elevator makes it pitch up, and the airspeed indicator shows the airspeed.

I'd have students go home and play around with different aircraft configurations to see what happens when you add drag, change airspeeds, etc. I'd tell them to go and play with the navaids and the sectional. Cross country coming up? Practice it at home. Just about every land feature that you can see out of the airplane is there on the game. All the rivers, the lakes, and the roads.

Some students didn't listen to the Sergeant. Others went home, and did what they were told. I saw a HUGE difference in the ones that used Flight Sim at home. You know, you're right, it usually added a couple of bad habits. I'd venture to say that it probably took 2-3 hours JUST to remove those habits.

Using flight sim usually saved them 7 or 8, though.

I'd say it's worth it.

If you want some tips on using it effectively to enhance your training experience, let me know.
 
It's an easy way to develop some bad habits (starting at instruments), but I don't think it is inherently unhelpful. It won't help you with your private or anything other than basic familiarization with fundamentals. Flight Sim was cool and all back in the day, it just seems terribly boring to me now.
 
Absolute B.S.

Flight Sim helped me a tremendous amount. I was playing that game before I even set foot in a real airplane. I played it while I was training for my PPL, while I was training for my Instrument Rating . . . he11, I've played it during all of my training. To this day, hardly a week goes by that I don't fire it up at least 3 times. And, I fly for a living.

As a flight instructor for a couple of years, I encouraged my students to go home and fool around with the sim. Is it like the real airplane? He11 no. However, the ailerons make it bank, the elevator makes it pitch up, and the airspeed indicator shows the airspeed.

I'd have students go home and play around with different aircraft configurations to see what happens when you add drag, change airspeeds, etc. I'd tell them to go and play with the navaids and the sectional. Cross country coming up? Practice it at home. Just about every land feature that you can see out of the airplane is there on the game. All the rivers, the lakes, and the roads.

Some students didn't listen to the Sergeant. Others went home, and did what they were told. I saw a HUGE difference in the ones that used Flight Sim at home. You know, you're right, it usually added a couple of bad habits. I'd venture to say that it probably took 2-3 hours JUST to remove those habits.

Using flight sim usually saved them 7 or 8, though.

I'd say it's worth it.

If you want some tips on using it effectively to enhance your training experience, let me know.

I've heard it helps a bit with IFR training, but that's it!
 
NO DONT STOP!

if you like it keep playing. Just try to kepe your eyes out during climb out and landing.

The avionics will come close but the feel won't be there.

During my discovery ride my instructor was like "are you sure you have never done this before? You're doing an excellent job" that was after he asked me how many hours I logged....0.
 
NO DONT STOP!

if you like it keep playing. Just try to kepe your eyes out during climb out and landing.

The avionics will come close but the feel won't be there.

During my discovery ride my instructor was like "are you sure you have never done this before? You're doing an excellent job" that was after he asked me how many hours I logged....0.

I scored a 90% on my PPL written test, but feel bad because I could have maybe done better.

Would MSFS04 helped out any?
 
I feel like I could have done better yo :)

No, Gleim helped me. FS helped me fly the 747-400 across the world :D

Don't make me sick "Hawker" on you...

But back to the original question...hope that you're getting the answers you need in this thread.

MSFS is first and foremost a game for entertainment value. That does provide *some* actual skill & knowledge that *may* aid you in your training. But always remember that it is only a game first and foremost.

YMMV
 
MSFS is first and foremost a game for entertainment value. That does provide *some* actual skill & knowledge that *may* aid you in your training. But always remember that it is only a game first and foremost.

YMMV

YMMV - Your mileage might vary

Excellent post that pretty much sums it up.
 
ASA, a leading marketer of aviation training aids, has a book called "Microsft Flight Simulator As A Training Aid". It's an excellent read for you if you're thinking about incorporating MSFS into your studies. I'd suggest you get with a CFI that is comfortable with this technology, and has a bit more than a month or two as a CFI. I've found, surprisingly, that a lot of the very senior CFI's (20+ years on the stick) are quite open to the idea of using MSFS as a learning tool.

Ask the U.S. Navy how much it doesn't help . . . and that was years ago.

It's very easy to say, "It's a game . . . gahhhh . . . there's no value", because that's the cool thing to say (Note above "I've heard it helps a bit with IFR training, but that's it!"). It's not always easy to stray away from the popuylar crowd.
 
Back
Top