Flight Plan "Remarks"?

No sids/stars, or no dp's....As an instructor, for the Long IR XC flight, I request some weird (rarely used) approaches when on an IFR flight plan (Remarks: Request NDB RWY4R @ CHD.) ATC usually see this, understands why, and set us up perfectly. It helps make things run more smoothly.
 
Well for what it's worth, I deal with air carriers all the time who file with RNAV equipment suffixes, and then say "unable" to an RNAV or GPS approach. I'm not sure exactly what's going on there, but it's nice for them to be able to accept direct clearances without interrogation by the controller.

Depends on each and every operator's ops specs. I worked for one operator whereas we could do it all such as Sids/Arrivals, direct anywhere, most approaches except stand alone NDB(NO ADF) I loved those WAAS. Another place I worked at could not do GPS approaches/Sids/Arrivals but was able to go direct to a waypoint or intersection.
 
That's a distinction that seems odd to me as a controller. At least it seems that if you can file in such a way, then another pilot should be able to file /G and just say "unable" to RNAV approaches if their database was out of date. I don't know the legality of it, but practically speaking you're both filing equipment suffixes that imply you can fly stuff that you won't accept. I just hate to see /A aircraft with "VFR GPS" in remarks get the business from ATC in a radar environment when trying to negotiate direct clearances.

You're on radar, we see you on radar, we'll be able to tell if you start heading south instead of north, who cares, y'know?
 
Best one I've seen

"live mammals"

Uh isn't that every airplane with people on it?
 
I thought you had to comply with SIDs, but STARs you could refuse? Or am I thinking of ODPs?

You can absolutely refuse a SID. You'll still get spoon fed a PDR that is basically the same thing, but you can. In fact unless you do something off the wall like request BFE to direct ATL at FL450 in a Lear, I'll probably work it out and save you the heartburn. ODPs? No way, fly those. I can't promise that I know every airport so well that I can keep you from hitting an obstacle. Trees and buildings don't show up so well on RADAR.

You can refuse a STAR as well, easily. Doing so in a turboprop or jet will probably yield less than pleasing results, but you can.
 
You can always fly an ODP but you can only fly a SID if you are cleared for it... is that what you are thinking of?

No I mean I thought if ATC is going to give you a SID, you have to fly the SID, even if you say no SID on the flt plan.

Maybe it's something I made up I my head!
 
You can absolutely refuse a SID. You'll still get spoon fed a PDR that is basically the same thing, but you can. In fact unless you do something off the wall like request BFE to direct ATL at FL450 in a Lear, I'll probably work it out and save you the heartburn. ODPs? No way, fly those. I can't promise that I know every airport so well that I can keep you from hitting an obstacle. Trees and buildings don't show up so well on RADAR.

You can refuse a STAR as well, easily. Doing so in a turboprop or jet will probably yield less than pleasing results, but you can.
Ok that makes sense. I knew ODPs were mandatory, but for some reason I was thinking you could only refuse a STAR (never been given one anyway in a piston single). Thanks

edit: ODP's are recommended, right?
 
Ok that makes sense. I knew ODPs were mandatory, but for some reason I was thinking you could only refuse a STAR (never been given one anyway in a piston single). Thanks

They can't make me do something I don't want to do! :D
 
They can't make me do something I don't want to do! :D
But they can put you through the wringer, I guess ;)

I haven't been issued a ton of SIDs, just at airports like VNY and MRY, but I never found myself wanting to refuse them (If I understood the publication).
 
No I mean I thought if ATC is going to give you a SID, you have to fly the SID, even if you say no SID on the flt plan.

Maybe it's something I made up I my head!
I was prepping for an instrument oral and I read that the only time refusing a SID would work is if you did not have the chart in your airplane. Maybe blame ASA but that is what it said.
 
Note: ATC can only see like the first few characters of your remarks, to see the whole thing they have to type a seperate command which they aren't likely to do. I never have my remarks be more than say one word usually, "MEDEVAC", "INSTRUCTION", "LOCAL", "MULTI APPR" etc
 
This is probably what ATC sees:
Uv7Y8mv.jpg
 
Back
Top