DC-9 Guys

It's somewhat frightening that so many pilots these days view it unsafe to fly without an autopilot, flight director, or FMS. In all the airplanes I've flown, you can turn off all the gee-whiz stuff and it will still fly just fine. You can even navigate just fine.

Funny story: I had an FO ask me on a night visual to a runway without an ILS or VGSI, "Can I ask, what instrument are you using to keep stable on approach?" I replied, "My eyes." He couldn't understand that even in the EMB-145, you can pick a point on the windscreen to put the runway, and maintain an approximate 3 degree glideslope all the way to the runway. I finally had to tell him I also use the VSI once in a while to set about 600-700 FPM on approach. The rest of the trip he was staring at the VSI, in the process getting +/- 200 feet off altitude while being vectored...

While I do like many things about the way pilots train in Europe, historically the one benefit of being a US trained pilot was exceptional stick and rudder skills. It was because of how we learned as private pilots... Our schooling was more about flying than book knowledge. Now, it seems to be reversing... Or just going downhill altogether. :(
 
I don't know man. Having flown a variety of aircraft and having ridden that god-awful jumpseat, I've got to ask is that Purplesaurus Rex or Black Cherry? :) That thing is an ergonomic nightmare.

If you really want to talk about a man's cockpit and don't mention the DC-10, MD-11 and especially the L1011, there's no point in even having a conversation.

Boeing is still working out some kinks in realizing that a long-haul aircraft needn't be like a coat closet up front, the Airbus seems more pilot friendly, (I'm sorry but) Bombardier needs to drop the bizjet feel and design their flight deck for adults and I haven't ridden an Embraer jumpset yet. But considering it's a jet-powered Brasilia, I'm not going to hold my breath.

Trust me, when I first got into the 727 flight deck, I thought it was off the chain, too.

I was just talking about flight deck instrument layout. As far as cockpit comfort I know the big boy planes are definitely much MUCH better:)
 
If you really want to talk about a man's cockpit and don't mention the DC-10, MD-11 and especially the L1011, there's no point in even having a conversation.

L1011: Best. Cockpit. Ever.

I was able to ride in an L1011 on an ATA domestic charter once. We had five of us in the cockpit... Captain, FO, FE, FE doing an observation, and myself. At one point, two flight attendants came up to hang out, and there was still plenty of space to stretch out.
 
It's somewhat frightening that so many pilots these days view it unsafe to fly without an autopilot, flight director, or FMS. In all the airplanes I've flown, you can turn off all the gee-whiz stuff and it will still fly just fine. You can even navigate just fine.

(

OMG!! The green crap is out, I'm declaring an emergency! :banghead:

Saw a Cessna G1000 student...almost done with training. Was telling me how much training on the G1000 was cool. Asked him what he'd do if that all failed, would he dead reckon if need be?

His answer: "what's that?"
 
To be honest, when I first got assigned the -9, I wasn't too happy about having to fly it. Seemed like it would be too much work, etc.

Now 2 years later....I love the airplane. All of the flying without any automation becomes second nature to you. Almost no one ever uses the flight director. Maybe on a "down to mins" ILS. The f/d on the -9 is almost too much work to use. Most guys use it as a reminder that we're on a heading instead of the airway. (as close as we can get anyway :))

Great, great airplane and I'm glad I've had the pleasure of flying it.
 
It's somewhat frightening that so many pilots these days view it unsafe to fly without an autopilot, flight director, or FMS. In all the airplanes I've flown, you can turn off all the gee-whiz stuff and it will still fly just fine. You can even navigate just fine.


You'd be suprised at how many pilots have forgotten to just fly the plane when things don't work out.

Just the other day while landing in ATL on a high, close turn onto final, the FMC could not keep up. Instead of futzing with it, I just turned off the A/P and hand flew. The captain later made the comment, "You are the first FO I've seen do that in a long time. All the others I've flown with would have messed with the FMS instead of flying the plane."

Now, he had been flying with the bottom of the ER list lately, (Post '07 new hires,) so maybe that had something to do with it.:dunno:
 
You'd be suprised at how many pilots have forgotten to just fly the plane when things don't work out.

Just the other day while landing in ATL on a high, close turn onto final, the FMC could not keep up. Instead of futzing with it, I just turned off the A/P and hand flew. The captain later made the comment, "You are the first FO I've seen do that in a long time. All the others I've flown with would have messed with the FMS instead of flying the plane."

Now, he had been flying with the bottom of the ER list lately, (Post '07 new hires,) so maybe that had something to do with it.:dunno:

I did exactly that on OE, just killed everything and the first thing out of the check airman was, "Uhmm....what are you doing man?" I told him we were on a CAVU day, we were high and tight and had more important things to do than futz with the automation right now. We can get this airplane configured and down in a few minutes and we're, you know, visual.

Once we got on the ground he told me that wasn't normally how check airman wanted to see things done, and it would have been better to keep the AP/FD on.

I've heard the same thing on here from captains at a few regionals.

Now that hack FlyChicaga, on the other hand, didn't exactly operate like that. On the trip I flew with him we did the river visual 1 circle 33 into DCA, all without automation. Now given I hadn't done it before so Matt was able to tell me how to set it up so we'd roll out on speed and on altitude, but it involved eyeballing the situation more than anything else.
 
Can't you build a runway extension for a "gomer glideslope" in the FMC?

Yes; however, it's not perfect. I've seen the FMC glideslope do some strange things, so I just go eyes-out.

Now that hack FlyChicaga, on the other hand, didn't exactly operate like that. On the trip I flew with him we did the river visual 1 circle 33 into DCA, all without automation. Now given I hadn't done it before so Matt was able to tell me how to set it up so we'd roll out on speed and on altitude, but it involved eyeballing the situation more than anything else.

Yeah I was surprised you didn't put us in the river. ;)
 
I really liked the DC-9, it was my first jet. Went from a Bandit to the DC-9. Bandits didn't have autopilots so the move to a jet with a nice wing leveler and altitude hold function was a step up :). We used the Flight Director for takeoff only. It went off when the flaps were up. Hand flying to 18,000 and back down from 18,000 was the norm. At level off you simply clocked how many miles you flew in a minute to calculate your ground speed. We didn't need no stinking GS indicator :p.

The -80 series was great fun. The -9 handled better, especially the DC-9-10. The -80 has many more creature comforts than the -9. The original PMS system was pretty much useless, but having autothrottles was okay even if we didn't use them for descent and approach. The later models with FMS made life a bit easier.

The MD-90, and especially the 29 MD-90-Enhanced Flight Deck airplanes built for Saudia were excellent. The EFD has the Honeywell Pegasus FMS along with the normal MD-80 Flight guidance panel. One of the best overall pilot's airplanes ever built. Too bad the wing is so limiting.

For pure pleasure of flying the DC-9-10 was the machine to be in. For ease of life the MD-90EFD's were great.

I've got over 6000 hours total in every model from DC-9-10 through MD-90EFD and I can categorically state that I love the airplane.




The wild flying we did in Asia used those speeds right up to the limits. Not the best care for an aircraft, but that was the culture so we just went with the flow. 320 KIAS to a 13 mile final, yee haw !!!:bandit: Slats and 11 at 280 KIAS; Flap 15 at 240; gear down and flap 28 around 200. Spool up, what's that? Those were the days :pirate:.




Typhoonpilot


What was so limiting about the wing, and what could MD have done to make a better wing, and why didn't they..

Before Boeing bought MD they were planning on making a stretch MD-90 model, probably with the same wing!
 
What was so limiting about the wing, and what could MD have done to make a better wing, and why didn't they..

Before Boeing bought MD they were planning on making a stretch MD-90 model, probably with the same wing!


Long jet.... itty bitty wing! Min clean speed to get the last of the slats retracted can be above 260 knots at heavy weights in the MD-90.






All DC-9's at NWA are CAT II certified.
 
What was so limiting about the wing, and what could MD have done to make a better wing, and why didn't they..

Well, more weight needs a wing designed to produce a sufficient amount of lift.

Oftentimes, flying the MD-90, we'd have to fly pretty fast in order to maintain a safe margin for maneuvering. Trucking along at 260 knots, clean, below 10,000 feet wasn't all that uncommon.

When you're departing behind some jets that climb at 210 to 230 knots, it wreaked havoc on us because we had to convince SLC that it's probably better to get a vector around that traffic rather than expect us to slow to 220 knots, start throwing out flaps and wrecking fuel consumption.

McD-D more or less stretched the tube and put more power on DC-9 variants.
 
I don't know if it's a saying they hear in ground school or not but both 777 jumpseaters I've had both said its the first plane they've flown that "amazed" them
 
Back
Top