DC-9 Guys

Completely disagree. The CRJ 700/900 has to be one of the best designed aircraft in the passenger airline business. Absolutely wonderful to handfly with an awesome cockpit design and logical layout. Jumpseaters are always in awe looking at the cockpit. Had a AA 767 Checkairman on the jump two days ago and he was impressed.

I don't know man. Having flown a variety of aircraft and having ridden that god-awful jumpseat, I've got to ask is that Purplesaurus Rex or Black Cherry? :) That thing is an ergonomic nightmare.

If you really want to talk about a man's cockpit and don't mention the DC-10, MD-11 and especially the L1011, there's no point in even having a conversation.

Boeing is still working out some kinks in realizing that a long-haul aircraft needn't be like a coat closet up front, the Airbus seems more pilot friendly, (I'm sorry but) Bombardier needs to drop the bizjet feel and design their flight deck for adults and I haven't ridden an Embraer jumpset yet. But considering it's a jet-powered Brasilia, I'm not going to hold my breath.

Trust me, when I first got into the 727 flight deck, I thought it was off the chain, too.
 
If it's the same JS as the EMB-145, I don't think it's that bad. I think it's very similar to a 737's center jumpseat, and just as uncomfortable.

You want comfy a jumpseat? You need to get yourself on an Airbus!
 
If it's the same JS as the EMB-145, I don't think it's that bad. I think it's very similar to a 737's center jumpseat, and just as uncomfortable.

You want comfy a jumpseat? You need to get yourself on an Airbus!

Personally the old places lears with the extended net pole were probably the worst jumpseats in the industry especially if there were two people. Straddling a pole with some other guy rubbing next to you and then looking up with me in the left seat and some scarred FO in the right. Yeah I felt for those people.
 
Personally the old places lears with the extended net pole were probably the worst jumpseats in the industry especially if there were two people. Straddling a pole with some other guy rubbing next to you and then looking up with me in the left seat and some scarred FO in the right. Yeah I felt for those people.
Ahh, the memories...I have way too many hours in those "jumpseats". It allowed me to not have to move so it was worth it in the end.
 
I went from the E170, that does just about everything for you, (as in the overhead panel was more looking at stuff, start the APU and turn on one HYD system pump if I remember right) to the 747-200, which had all the capabilites but none of the integration. It had a FD, that we used during cruise, sometimes in the descents.

And now the -400, which is has a first-gen FMC and VNAV. Both of which require a fair amount of baby sitting.


Note of CAUTION: :soapbox:

Both the 170 and -400, you really have to focus on learning logic. What is it doing and why is it doing that. You have to excercise CRM with both jets and keep them in the loop, or you can get in trouble with mode management. It's hard to maintain a high level of proficiency in the -400 with a high level of mode management and hand flying as you get into an either/or situation since you don't have many touches on the controls in any given period of time. Much easier to do both in the domestic environment with the 170.

It was funny. I'd watch the pilots putting on a fine airshow out of a high density airport, and they'd fly the crap out of the jet. However, they were so focused on aviating and navigating, often times not using the automation for what it was intended - easing your actual flying of the airplane to manage a task-saturated environment. I'd see people not using the automation to fly an RNAV or complex departure, and allowing both pilots to monitor the performance of the procedure, again a departure that requires high fidelity to prevent metal on metal contact. Or, I'd see Captain candidates put on an airshow when their attention would have been far better served planning the diversion route through the weather in the departure corridor.

Don't get me wrong, when the conditions are right, hand fly. It's the only way to maintain proficiency and improve your skills.

It's up to us to recognize the most appropriate environment that the highest level of automated integration will allow the safest operation versus an environment where operational safety won't be impacted with a greater focus on aircraft control takes (even the slightest bit) away from SA.
 
Oh. Heh. Right, I'm supposed to RTFM. :p But, I guarantee you, if you were to ask APDs/Check Airmen I'll bet most would want FD on more often than not (heck, apparently with the FAA on board we've got to). With specific reference of the RNAV SID, our recurrent ground school instructor (a checkairmen) specifically said that the AP flies it better so that's why we should feel fine about using it for the SID.... "and if the automation screws up the SID you'll have more leverage to avoid a violation".


RNAV SID is a new can of worms. Just got a CFM revision on the -200, and AP is REQUIRED by 500 AGL on RNAV SIDs. It's also required on RNAV STARs now.
 
Now if you can handfly down from FL180 raw data thru a thick overcast layer and shoot a raw data ILS down to mins I'll high-five you on that one:D


:yeahthat:

I do that almost every day. Most of the 1900s in our fleet dont have flight director's on the FO's side and the autopilot is non-existant.
 
RNAV SID is a new can of worms. Just got a CFM revision on the -200, and AP is REQUIRED by 500 AGL on RNAV SIDs. It's also required on RNAV STARs now.

Saw that as well. Need to bookmark that.

I've got other thoughts on that new requirement, but I am not going to voice them here. :banghead:
 
Can you point me to the guidance that says that the autopilot must be ENGAGED in RVSM? I know it's an equipment requirement, but I haven't been able to find the reg that says it must be engaged.

Both airlines I have flown for it is in the FOM. If pinnacle's requires AP on for RNAV SIDS, then I can't believe they wouldn't require it on for RVSM.
 
You weren't 1000 ft apart, you were 2000

And your point is?

1000ft. 2000ft. FL230 or FL390 the needle remained within 50ft of assigned. And we flew a Lear 23 at FL410 with no autopilot because it would pitch badly if engaged.

I am a firm believer in automation but recognize the limits of automation. It is dumb and dutiful. It will TRY to do what it is programmed to do. And automation philosophy has changed from not using it, to using highest level available to use mode most appropriate now. And some guys DEPEND on automation. Their stick and rudder skills are not the best. As a check airman I saw more than a few guys grabbing for the autopilot on V1 cuts before ever trying to trim up the airplane. Poor technique! Poor skills!

Simply put, RVSM, automation aside, if one can not fly ATP standards one should not be in an ATP job.
 
And your point is?

1000ft. 2000ft. FL230 or FL390 the needle remained within 50ft of assigned. And we flew a Lear 23 at FL410 with no autopilot because it would pitch badly if engaged.

I am a firm believer in automation but recognize the limits of automation. It is dumb and dutiful. It will TRY to do what it is programmed to do. And automation philosophy has changed from not using it, to using highest level available to use mode most appropriate now. And some guys DEPEND on automation. Their stick and rudder skills are not the best. As a check airman I saw more than a few guys grabbing for the autopilot on V1 cuts before ever trying to trim up the airplane. Poor technique! Poor skills!

Simply put, RVSM, automation aside, if one can not fly ATP standards one should not be in an ATP job.

Very well said. During my upgrade training in the 35 I flew takeoff to landing every leg without use of autopilot. If I put it on it would have failed. ;)
 
And your point is?

1000ft. 2000ft. FL230 or FL390 the needle remained within 50ft of assigned. And we flew a Lear 23 at FL410 with no autopilot because it would pitch badly if engaged.

I am a firm believer in automation but recognize the limits of automation. It is dumb and dutiful. It will TRY to do what it is programmed to do. And automation philosophy has changed from not using it, to using highest level available to use mode most appropriate now. And some guys DEPEND on automation. Their stick and rudder skills are not the best. As a check airman I saw more than a few guys grabbing for the autopilot on V1 cuts before ever trying to trim up the airplane. Poor technique! Poor skills!

Simply put, RVSM, automation aside, if one can not fly ATP standards one should not be in an ATP job.

My point is that if something distracts you and you accidentally sink 300 ft (which is the point that ATC would say something) and a plane that is below happens to rise 2-300ft, you are now 200 ft apart. Combine that with the allowable altimeter error of 200 ft between altimeters, and both planes could conceivably be at the same altitude. I realize the possibility is remote, but could happen. Everyone can hand fly straight and level just fine, if you couldn't, you wouldn't be a private pilot. Why not put the autopilot on in RVSM and significantly decrease your workload? I agree that if you cannot fly to ATP standards, you shouldn't be working in an ATP job, but you have a much higher chance of busting altitude hand flying than autopilot flying due to human factors. Back before RVSM, when planes were spaced 2000 ft apart, you had a lot more room to dick around with, now there's not much at all.
 
My point is that if something distracts you and you accidentally sink 300 ft (which is the point that ATC would say something) and a plane that is below happens to rise 2-300ft, you are now 200 ft apart.

two planes with no one monitoring the flight path? Then yes.

Back before RVSM, when planes were spaced 2000 ft apart, you had a lot more room to dick around with, now there's not much at all.

ATC would still call you on 100-200ft. Note that I am not advocating not using automation. It is fine but as the old saying goes, use it as a tool, not a crutch.
 
two planes with no one monitoring the flight path? Then yes.



ATC would still call you on 100-200ft. Note that I am not advocating not using automation. It is fine but as the old saying goes, use it as a tool, not a crutch.

I know, chances are very remote, however I bet you never thought a regional would crash one because the capt and f/o weren't paying attention to airspeed, and to make matters worse couldn't recover from a stall.........
 
I know, chances are very remote, however I bet you never thought a regional would crash one because the capt and f/o weren't paying attention to airspeed, and to make matters worse couldn't recover from a stall.........

I think you just made his point.
 
My point is that if something distracts you and you accidentally sink 300 ft (which is the point that ATC would say something) and a plane that is below happens to rise 2-300ft, you are now 200 ft apart. Combine that with the allowable altimeter error of 200 ft between altimeters, and both planes could conceivably be at the same altitude. I realize the possibility is remote, but could happen. Everyone can hand fly straight and level just fine, if you couldn't, you wouldn't be a private pilot. Why not put the autopilot on in RVSM and significantly decrease your workload? I agree that if you cannot fly to ATP standards, you shouldn't be working in an ATP job, but you have a much higher chance of busting altitude hand flying than autopilot flying due to human factors. Back before RVSM, when planes were spaced 2000 ft apart, you had a lot more room to dick around with, now there's not much at all.

So two pilots and an altitude alerter and no one catches being more than 200 ft off of assigned altitude? If I'm more than 50ft off of my altitude while hand flying, I'm having a bad day!
 
I really liked the DC-9, it was my first jet. Went from a Bandit to the DC-9. Bandits didn't have autopilots so the move to a jet with a nice wing leveler and altitude hold function was a step up :). We used the Flight Director for takeoff only. It went off when the flaps were up. Hand flying to 18,000 and back down from 18,000 was the norm. At level off you simply clocked how many miles you flew in a minute to calculate your ground speed. We didn't need no stinking GS indicator :p.

The -80 series was great fun. The -9 handled better, especially the DC-9-10. The -80 has many more creature comforts than the -9. The original PMS system was pretty much useless, but having autothrottles was okay even if we didn't use them for descent and approach. The later models with FMS made life a bit easier.

The MD-90, and especially the 29 MD-90-Enhanced Flight Deck airplanes built for Saudia were excellent. The EFD has the Honeywell Pegasus FMS along with the normal MD-80 Flight guidance panel. One of the best overall pilot's airplanes ever built. Too bad the wing is so limiting.

For pure pleasure of flying the DC-9-10 was the machine to be in. For ease of life the MD-90EFD's were great.

I've got over 6000 hours total in every model from DC-9-10 through MD-90EFD and I can categorically state that I love the airplane.

The amazing thing about the -9/-80 is the high speeds for extensions. As I remember 320 for the gear and 280 for the slats. And the slats come out NOW.


The wild flying we did in Asia used those speeds right up to the limits. Not the best care for an aircraft, but that was the culture so we just went with the flow. 320 KIAS to a 13 mile final, yee haw !!!:bandit: Slats and 11 at 280 KIAS; Flap 15 at 240; gear down and flap 28 around 200. Spool up, what's that? Those were the days :pirate:.




Typhoonpilot
 
Back
Top