Commuting

Frenchie

Well-Known Member
Don't mean to rehash an old topic but I've read all the previous posts and would like some fresh perspective on thoughts on commuting?

I'm still looking for a residence; but, I've found a crash pad of sorts and am leaning towards the idea but would like the perspective of the forum since you guys are most definitely more versed in it than I would be...

Thanks in advance...
 
Don't mean to rehash an old topic but I've read all the previous posts and would like some fresh perspective on thoughts on commuting?

I'm still looking for a residence; but, I've found a crash pad of sorts and am leaning towards the idea but would like the perspective of the forum since you guys are most definitely more versed in it than I would be...

Thanks in advance...
Where do you work and where are you looking to commute from?
 
If you are going to commute, you might as well live in a state that doesn't have state income tax, if that is not possible then try and find a state that has a reciprocal tax agreement. Living in a state that has no income tax means you only have to file one state tax form, a reciprocal agreement allows the state you live in to give you credit for the state that taxed you. The downside is you will have to file 2 different state tax forms.

This coming from a permanent commuter.
 
Last edited:
Minnesota and New York
NY is a tough one, make sure WX is good on your commute days, especially the day you have to get back to work, you can easily get stuck in NY on a bad WX, and it doesn’t even have to be “really” bad WX... NY airport can quickly going into a ground stop and GDPs even with high winds and once the flights start getting delayed even those with lots of empty seats get quickly filled up because revenue passengers will still show up and move themselves to the next flight that’s leaving... also, none of the pilots that are based in NY live there so on IROP days jumpseats are all taken by pilots.
But on good days (mostly outside of summer in NY, and winter storms in MSP) you shouldn’t have to much trouble commuting, on fridays and mondays you might have to connect through other cities between NY and MSP.
 
Wonderlic is spot-on here. You'll spend more of your time in your crashpad at the city you work in than you will at home. Not really worth it unless you have a family that can't/won't move. Plus, you have to factor in the cost of housing and transportation at your work city, which is hard to do on a regional wage.

It's a little better if you work midnights so you can commute before/after your shift. Also at airlines that have a 4 on/4 off or better schedule (Spirit, Kalitta, some shifts at Delta) or if you get promoted to a coordinator position that can work doubles (my current airline allows this).
 
If he's commuting between MSP and NYC, at least there are hub airports on both ends, so direct flights would be available. I just did a quick search on Google Flights, and there are 4 nonstops JFK-MSP, 4 LGA-MSP, and there are 3 EWR-MSP. Depending on what part of the city you're in, one of those airports would work. If I were working in the industry and commuting, I'd only commute if at least one of the airports was a hub airport, thus making direct, nonstop flights available.

I flew home a few times when I was in DX, so I got a taste of commuting. I didn't like it. I wouldn't do it unless either or both cities were hub airports, thus making direct flights an option. If you catch the first flight out (which someone will inevitably miss), you should be good to go; I never got bumped from the 5:45 AM out of ABE. If you take a later flight out, you could be bumped; this doesn't usually happen on the very first flight out (6 AM or earlier). There's no connecting flight from which you can be bumped, either.

Where I am (near ABE), I always had to get a connecting flight. On my way back to STL the last time, I was bumped from the connecting flight I'd planned to take. I schmoozed with the gate agent to make sure if there were later flights. Thankfully, there were; there were plenty of seats on a late afternoon flight, so she put me on that. That said, I got to spend some 'quality' time at DTW and finish a John Grisham novel. If there's a connecting flight involved, I wouldn't commute because there's simply too much chance of getting bumped.
 
Back
Top