If he's commuting between MSP and NYC, at least there are hub airports on both ends, so direct flights would be available. I just did a quick search on Google Flights, and there are 4 nonstops JFK-MSP, 4 LGA-MSP, and there are 3 EWR-MSP. Depending on what part of the city you're in, one of those airports would work. If I were working in the industry and commuting, I'd only commute if at least one of the airports was a hub airport, thus making direct, nonstop flights available.
I flew home a few times when I was in DX, so I got a taste of commuting. I didn't like it. I wouldn't do it unless either or both cities were hub airports, thus making direct flights an option. If you catch the first flight out (which someone will inevitably miss), you should be good to go; I never got bumped from the 5:45 AM out of ABE. If you take a later flight out, you could be bumped; this doesn't usually happen on the very first flight out (6 AM or earlier). There's no connecting flight from which you can be bumped, either.
Where I am (near ABE), I always had to get a connecting flight. On my way back to STL the last time, I was bumped from the connecting flight I'd planned to take. I schmoozed with the gate agent to make sure if there were later flights. Thankfully, there were; there were plenty of seats on a late afternoon flight, so she put me on that. That said, I got to spend some 'quality' time at DTW and finish a John Grisham novel. If there's a connecting flight involved, I wouldn't commute because there's simply too much chance of getting bumped.