It depends on the situation, for me.
I'm on the young end of the spectrum in the airlines (like you, Trip7) and right now since I can't hold captain in any base I want the most productive schedule I can get so I can have as much time off as possible to travel.
That requires the type of time off that's scheduled in advance. I live in my base, and reserves in my seat here often fly just 20-30 hours a month, which is less than eight or nine workdays much of the time (until the summer months anyway). They've got lots of time to lounge around, take a college course or two online, learn another language, hit the gym 7 days a week, go out and party every day, go biking, fishing, whatever.
I on the other hand, prefer to sacrifice that for having the schedule I want which usually includes a large stretch of days off (and that can carry into the following month to make it weeks off). So, if I were only able to hold reserve in this base where I live in, or be senior in another base, I'd probably commute to the line as long as the commute was one leg and at least ~6 flights a day.
I think my gauge would be, I'd have to be getting 16 days off in the line base to make the commute worthwhile. If I couldn't get that, I'd just do the reserve in base thing.