Commute to a line or Reserve in base

It would depend on the circumstances. What kind of commute are we talking here? I'd rather sit reserve at home instead of trying to do a difficult commute to a not so great line. On the other hand if it's a easy commute to a commutable line, I'd probably opt for that.
 
It all depends. How commutable are your prospective lines? How badly are they beating you up on reserve? In my personal opinion only, I would sit reserve in base. No commute is equal, but if you don't mind living in domicile, I'd do that.
 
Commuting sucks, regardless of whether you hold a line or not.

From worst to best, at least in my mind:

- Commuting to reserve
- Commuting to a line
- Living in base on reserve
- Living in base with a line (1,000,000 times better than even commuting to a line!)
 
It depends on the situation, for me.

I'm on the young end of the spectrum in the airlines (like you, Trip7) and right now since I can't hold captain in any base I want the most productive schedule I can get so I can have as much time off as possible to travel.

That requires the type of time off that's scheduled in advance. I live in my base, and reserves in my seat here often fly just 20-30 hours a month, which is less than eight or nine workdays much of the time (until the summer months anyway). They've got lots of time to lounge around, take a college course or two online, learn another language, hit the gym 7 days a week, go out and party every day, go biking, fishing, whatever.

I on the other hand, prefer to sacrifice that for having the schedule I want which usually includes a large stretch of days off (and that can carry into the following month to make it weeks off). So, if I were only able to hold reserve in this base where I live in, or be senior in another base, I'd probably commute to the line as long as the commute was one leg and at least ~6 flights a day.

I think my gauge would be, I'd have to be getting 16 days off in the line base to make the commute worthwhile. If I couldn't get that, I'd just do the reserve in base thing.
 
Commuting sucks, regardless of whether you hold a line or not.

From worst to best, at least in my mind:

- Commuting to reserve
- Commuting to a line
- Living in base on reserve
- Living in base with a line (1,000,000 times better than even commuting to a line!)

I've done all four, and I can say that your list is absolutely 100% correct! With that being said, it depends on how commutable your lines are that you would be bidding on and if you would expect to hold more days off. For me personally I would choose reserve in base, but that's only one man's opinion. :)
 
I hate reserve so much, and I'm short on time for upgrade (whenever that happens), that I commute to DTW from ATL for reserve.

Of course, if the commute sucks, I will move.
 
After 2 years of reserve (even in base), if I could hold a line in DTW, I'd SERIOUSLY consider moving to MCO and commuting. Doesn't help that Memphis could fall into the Mississippi River and I wouldn't shed a tear, though.
 
I not yet a lineholder but those a couple numbers above me in my class are now lineholders in IAD. Many of them have ads on our company website wanting to base swap with someone in ATL so they can go back to sitting reserve.

IMO its not worth it to give up the freedom of having a line, more days off, and much more money(around $1000 extra a month) to go sit reserve in ATL and get abused for less days off and less money.

For those that asked the commute is ATL-IAD and the lines are commutable for the most part.
 
For those that asked the commute is ATL-IAD and the lines are commutable for the most part.

People are complaining about an ATL-IAD commute with "mostly" commutable lines? Between United, Delta and DaTranny there are about 15 non stops a day in each direction. That's (almost) a cake walk.

Unless you are in a situation where as a reserve you never get used (and you don't want to fly) I don't see any reason to walk away from a line in a situation like that.
 
People are complaining about an ATL-IAD commute with "mostly" commutable lines? Between United, Delta and DaTranny there are about 15 non stops a day in each direction. That's (almost) a cake walk.

Unless you are in a situation where as a reserve you never get used (and you don't want to fly) I don't see any reason to walk away from a line in a situation like that.

That's what I was thinking. The only explanation is the lineholders Im talking about have never held a line before and must not know the difference. Maybe the tune will change after the month:D
 
I'm very much enjoying my only opportunity to hold a line at my base. My commute is an easy one legger and my trips are half commutable. IMO, it's worth it for me, because it helps me provide income for childcare. If and when I get awarded my home base, I'm virtually guaranteed reserve and if I don't get used, that's a lot of money gone. However, it gets me home and the overall stress level is lower. We just have to watch our spending more.
 
I know a girl who was sitting reserve for 2+ years at home and decided to switch to another base to hold a line. She's regrets it and she's now back on reserve and stuck in another base she has to commute to. If you're based at home stay there... Commuting sucks big donkey d. I commuted to reserve for 2 months from the west coast to CVG and I was on the verge of quitting. Got a line shortly after and it became more bearable but still brutal. Moved to one of our bases and it completely changed my outlook on my job.
 
Back
Top