CFI advice with challenging student

If he's always planting it on the nose, maybe have him come in with the nose higher on the other side of the power curve, make sure he's good at slow flight though.

That would put him at around 50 knots in a C172. Sounds like a real bad idea.

Coming in with a higher nose attitude just requires a smaller flap setting, perhaps none.

(Not that I think either is a great idea.)
 
Demonstrate Adverse yaw (Roll OUT of a turn with rudder, and OUT of a turn without rudder. A light bulb will turn on when they see adverse yaw. It works a little better rolling out of a turn it seems)
I think adverse yaw can easily be demonstrated in both ways, into and out of a turn. The reason most people don't see adverse yaw when demonstrating it is because they roll niiiice and smoooth into the turn. There's very little difference in aileron when you bank gradually.

You almost have to snap into the turn, maintaining aileron differential for the second to be able to see it in the horizon. Remember, once in a bank (depending on the degree, but for the most part) your ailerons are more or less the same, which of course won't show any sort of adverse yaw. That's why when you snap into the turn, keeping the ailerons up and down (respectively) momentarily, the nose will go to the outside, and once you have established your bank it will drop back to the inside.

If you (in general) have never tried it before, go ahead and do it next time. None of my instructors ever demonstrated adverse yaw properly to me. They all overused opposite rudder to emphasize it which is completely unnecessary in my opinion.
 
Wow you guys act as if I'm saying they can't fly just because they are Indian. I have a lot of experience with Indians, an they all fly well, it's just that Stage 1 private seems to give a large portion of them problems.

So quit acting like I'm a hate monger. I like all of the Indians that I've met and most all of them turn out to be good pilots.

We teach primarily Indian students, and it can be a challenge.When you factor in that they are in another country with no parental supervision, they have little experience driving a car, and that a great majority of them decided to take up flying on a whim and really have no interest in doing it, it makes it very difficult and frustrating.

My advice: Don't take it personally, and just keep flying with them. Eventually, it will click.
 
I suppose I had a different experience.

They were usually my best students because they had a lot less to "unlearn" and were generally very motivated to do a good job. A lot of my students did, in fact, come to party in America, but I tried to give them the admonition that the harder they studied and the better they flew, well, that's just more time to get out there and see California and it kind of worked.
 
That would put him at around 50 knots in a C172. Sounds like a real bad idea.
Agreed... Additionally, the last thing I think you want to do is introduce a PPL Student to a situation on final where you are dangerously approaching Critical AoA with a purposefully nose high attitude. Not to mention that the skill you would be teaching them is not the correct way, and will eventually need to be seriously unlearned.
 
Why would you be hosed? Just lower the nose to maintain best glide?

You'll be able to maintain best glide, but the problem with coming in slow with power is that you may not make the field unless you have a 10000' field and you have him land at the 2000 foot mark. At that airspeed you're using power to control your touchdown point, more power, the touchdown point moves farther up the field, less power, wellllllll you get the picture.
 
Agreed... Additionally, the last thing I think you want to do is introduce a PPL Student to a situation on final where you are dangerously approaching Critical AoA with a purposefully nose high attitude. Not to mention that the skill you would be teaching them is not the correct way, and will eventually need to be seriously unlearned.


That's not necessarily the wrong way, "dragging it in with power" can drastically decrease your ground roll if the strip is reallllllyyy short ( e.g. 900ft of wet gravel), he does however need to get a feel for what the outside should look like when the mains hit, if he can see that then he should be golden after he's taught to flare. You could also tell him to look at the wind sock, and when he's about the same altitude as the wind sock he should be well into his flare.

As for 50kts being a dangerous approach speed, when I was landing on gravel bars in the 172 I was using 40Kts indicated as the approach speed and pulling up the electric flaps in the flare, that's just the only way I could get in over the trees, everything has a purpose, don't use 50kts just because someone told you to use 50kts, think for yourself. Not to harp on you, just for people reading, use whatever approach speed you need to perform the desired task.

Finally, there is no real correct way to do anything in aviation provided you don't crash, and don't kill everyone, don't be so set in your ways that you can't adjust.
 
"dragging it in with power" can drastically decrease your ground roll if the strip is reallllllyyy short

This is an advanced technique for bush pilots and not appropriate for a student pilot. There's been more than one pilot who's crashed using this technique because he lacked enough reserve lift to flare the airplane.

The student pilot should be taught the published procedures from the aircraft's AFM. They find this challenging enough.;)
 
Finally, there is no real correct way to do anything in aviation provided you don't crash, and don't kill everyone, don't be so set in your ways that you can't adjust.

Point well made. I think since we're speaking of PPL Students, it would be much better to do it "by the book" at first. Teaching a student to land only using an advanced method (as you described) is certainly doable - but not advisable - and I'm not gonna sign that logbook:D.
 
Finally, there is no real correct way to do anything in aviation provided you don't crash, and don't kill everyone, don't be so set in your ways that you can't adjust.

There might not be any absolutes, but there certainly are procedures that involve more risks than others.

Also, procedures in aviation are not built around what *does* happen, but what *might* happen. Just because something works 100 times in a row does not mean it's a good procedure...after all, attempt #101 might kill you.
 
I had a similar experience with a student of Scandinavian descent.

I started having him do low approaches and had him fly us down to within feet of the runway and just hold that all the way down the length of the runway then go around. It forced him to keep control at all times and not be scared of the gray/black mass underneath him. I think some students either get runway shy or just give up flying the plane when you are close to the ground.

Anyway doing this put the idea in his head that the plane was not only completely controllable until it stopped moving, but that you as the pilot actually should be controlling it until it stops moving. Not giving up and letting the plane decide where it goes.

It didn't take long for that silly Norwegian to get it figured out after doing that.

:yeahthat: I had instructor do this with me--well after I had gotten my commercial certificate--and it improved my landing technique immensely. It's really easy to "quit" flying as soon as the mains touch (or even the flare), and this technique is a good remedy for the reasons you mentioned.
 
if they don't drive cars just tell them to hold the plane at the same height as the view from an elephants back. :)

the whole holding the plane off the runway all the way down does work well. I also make them land and then make them keep their nose off the runway until the yoke is fully back. sorta like a soft field.

By doing this they will sometimes pop back off the runway and realize they still can fly the plane deeper into the flair. ok, 7.7 hours in planes today, I'm not making much sense.
 
Wow you guys act as if I'm saying they can't fly just because they are Indian. I have a lot of experience with Indians, an they all fly well, it's just that Stage 1 private seems to give a large portion of them problems.

So quit acting like I'm a hate monger. I like all of the Indians that I've met and most all of them turn out to be good pilots.

Yeah, got several sikh friends and it just rubbed me wrong at first….perhaps an overreaction on my part. Alright, no more misdirecting the original purpose of your thread.
 
There might not be any absolutes, but there certainly are procedures that involve more risks than others.

Also, procedures in aviation are not built around what *does* happen, but what *might* happen. Just because something works 100 times in a row does not mean it's a good procedure...after all, attempt #101 might kill you.


It all depends on what you're doing. Not what might happen. Aviation is risk management, not risk mitigation, the risks are the same every time.
 
It all depends on what you're doing. Not what might happen. Aviation is risk management, not risk mitigation, the risks are the same every time.

I'm not sure what you're getting at.

My point was that although you're correct in saying there are very few absolutes in aviation, there are definitely ways to do things that are more right than other ways.

I was writing in response to the idea you suggested that as long as nobody gets hurt, it must be ok. It might not be ok. A lack of accidents is not a good measure of determining if a procedure is safe or not.
 
I have around 600 dual given exclusively with Indians, and I've figured it out with all my other students, it's just getting this one student to find his best way of doing it. He just isn't connecting his brain to his hands to the airplane in the last ten feet of flight. Everywhere else he does great.

And we have a sikh. Nice fellow he is.

And Ben, yeah I teach them that they don't have to come in with 30flaps all the time. KNow what good that did me? Now they think that EVERY landing dictates that they land with less than thirty degrees of flaps. "Um Joseph, I had a sandwich today. I think this landing should be made using 10flaps." More like you forgot until short final.
 
I find most of my instrument students have trouble with landings....everything is great until they are just about to touch down, then all hell breaks loose.

I notice that most cross the threshold too slow, flare too high and (if I don't intervene) would do a carrier landing.

One thing that seems to work is for them to not flare, but rather level off, and maybe carry a little extra power before they touch down.
 
I started having him do low approaches and had him fly us down to within feet of the runway and just hold that all the way down the length of the runway then go around. It forced him to keep control at all times and not be scared of the gray/black mass underneath him. I think some students either get runway shy or just give up flying the plane when you are close to the ground.

Anyway doing this put the idea in his head that the plane was not only completely controllable until it stopped moving, but that you as the pilot actually should be controlling it until it stops moving. Not giving up and letting the plane decide where it goes.

i like this reply and have used it frequently over the years to teach landings, especially in the beginning when you see the student's tension rise the closer they get to the runway surface. when they know ahead of time that there's no expectation to actually land, they may concentrate more on rate of descent, airspeed, an aiming point, etc. flap settings should be recommended in the afm. as a general rule, with greater surface winds and gusts, i use fewer degrees of flaps for more rudder authority where required. this also teaches a relationship between surface wind conditions, airspeed and appropriate configuration. :bandit:
 
Back
Top