Call the Tower... Stories?

Where do we get this program that you do? Is it a seminar or a newspaper like thing?

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk
It's a seminar I do live for pilot groups, usually for Wings credit. The PowerPoint for the last time I did it (in January) is available on SlideShare. When I did it a year ago (out of date because, among other things, it doesn't cover the new "compliance philosophy) I recorded it and put the slideshow with audio on my YouTube Channel. It's long...

I'm thinking of trying to record the audio again and, rather than the whole thing, upload a few shorter snippets.
 
It's a seminar I do live for pilot groups, usually for Wings credit. The PowerPoint for the last time I did it (in January) is available on SlideShare. When I did it a year ago (out of date because, among other things, it doesn't cover the new "compliance philosophy) I recorded it and put the slideshow with audio on my YouTube Channel. It's long...

I'm thinking of trying to record the audio again and, rather than the whole thing, upload a few shorter snippets.
I'm really interested in what you have to say about the information you've gathered.

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk
 
I'm really interested in what you have to say about the information you've gathered.

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk
Well, the data is skewed because all I asked for was "good news."

A point I try to make in the program is the one I made in response to Old Pete's comment - that being asked to call the tower may be for a simple discussion or it may be the prelude to something more serious. So it's not as simple as "always call" or "never call."

The one I have been using is one that happened to me. But it didn't end with the tower discussion, so I wanted one that did. In mine, I did a NORDO landing at a busy Class D. No light signals, no nothing. It was in the middle of a runway change so (good news) there was temporarily no takeoffs or landings, but (bad news) there was a jet that in position and holding, pointed at me, on the opposite end of the runway. It was at the height of the FAA getting tough with the runway incursion problem and the Tower was pretty much required to report all runway incursions to the FSDO. It ended at the FSDO level - a discussion with an ASI and a letter he requested I send in, describing what I said over the phone.
 
I have one, but it wasn't in the US, so probably it won't help ya out... But regardles...

I filed a flightplan through the then recently launched "Internet flight plan portal" in Mexico (MMAN). I had filed a dozen flight plans that way, getting a confirmation email every time and never had an issue. On this particular occasion, I had started engines, with my boss on board and somewhat of a schedule to keep, and requested my clearance, and ground replied there's no flight plan on file. So, I refiled right there on the plane via my phone's internet, and call again for the clearance, nothing. Ground says "dispatch (the equivalent of FSS) wants you to phisically turn in the flight plan format with them". I apologize to my boss for the inconvenience and shut everything off and walk understandably upset to the dispatch office. I'm a very patient guy as long as there's no intentional actions involved. So in dispatch I don't say a word, justI tear a flight plan form, walk to the comandante's office (his minions back then had to stamp the fligt plan given I fly N number) and fill it out right there. The comandante even says "those dispatch fellows are stubborn sometimes, huh" (Adding insult to the injury).

I walk back down to the dispatch office and just leave the flight plan on the desk and walk out, not saying a word, because If I did someone would have had it. I restart engines and ask again for clearance, and get a "please call dispatch on 123.45?". Now what? So I tune in and the lady clerk tells me arrogantly that it wasn't their fault the system doesn't work, that I was rude and that this was the last time she'd accept a flight plan from my behalf unless I ask for an apology. I was this close to replying "yes mom", but I just switched frequencies and flipped my mental flying switch back on and back to work now.

A couple of days go by and after this unpleasant experience, I dropped by to the dispatch office just to make sure the flight plan was in the system. There this other clerk says to me "you'll need a weather report" and hands me a printed METAR with - you guessed it, a phone number.

I called and it was their supervisor, telling me that that clerk wanted to submit a report, but that he dissmissed it because he understood that we're under the gun and they're not, and he apologized for the inconvenience, and suggested I keep checking in dispatch if the flight plans went through.

And that was that.
 
I have one, but it wasn't in the US, so probably it won't help ya out... But regardles...

I filed a flightplan through the then recently launched "Internet flight plan portal" in Mexico (MMAN). I had filed a dozen flight plans that way, getting a confirmation email every time and never had an issue. On this particular occasion, I had started engines, with my boss on board and somewhat of a schedule to keep, and requested my clearance, and ground replied there's no flight plan on file. So, I refiled right there on the plane via my phone's internet, and call again for the clearance, nothing. Ground says "dispatch (the equivalent of FSS) wants you to phisically turn in the flight plan format with them". I apologize to my boss for the inconvenience and shut everything off and walk understandably upset to the dispatch office. I'm a very patient guy as long as there's no intentional actions involved. So in dispatch I don't say a word, justI tear a flight plan form, walk to the comandante's office (his minions back then had to stamp the fligt plan given I fly N number) and fill it out right there. The comandante even says "those dispatch fellows are stubborn sometimes, huh" (Adding insult to the injury).

I walk back down to the dispatch office and just leave the flight plan on the desk and walk out, not saying a word, because If I did someone would have had it. I restart engines and ask again for clearance, and get a "please call dispatch on 123.45?". Now what? So I tune in and the lady clerk tells me arrogantly that it wasn't their fault the system doesn't work, that I was rude and that this was the last time she'd accept a flight plan from my behalf unless I ask for an apology. I was this close to replying "yes mom", but I just switched frequencies and flipped my mental flying switch back on and back to work now.

A couple of days go by and after this unpleasant experience, I dropped by to the dispatch office just to make sure the flight plan was in the system. There this other clerk says to me "you'll need a weather report" and hands me a printed METAR with - you guessed it, a phone number.

I called and it was their supervisor, telling me that that clerk wanted to submit a report, but that he dissmissed it because he understood that we're under the gun and they're not, and he apologized for the inconvenience, and suggested I keep checking in dispatch if the flight plans went through.

And that was that.

We've had so many issues at Valley Approach with getting flight plans between the US and Mexico. Whatever system Mexico uses isn't compatible with our system in the US. When you fly into MFE or BRO, we get a phone call from Reynosa and Matamoros giving your arrival details and ETA. That's not really a problem usually, except it's time consuming. Airplanes departing Reynosa or Matamoros going far into the US has been the main issue. They file a flight plan (I assume) but we get no information about it. Instead of just inputting a flight plan in our system, we're now supposed to tell Mexico ATC they need to work it out. At that point, the aircraft departs, switches to Valley, we see them on radar, but for whatever reason we can't do an automatic handoff to Houston Center because they don't have any information on it.
 
Here's one:

I was doing some mountain instruction, which typically started in the SF Bay Area and was a trip up to South Lake Tahoe or Truckee. As part of the training, I'd have the student file a VFR plan. We'd always pad the flight time a bit to allow for some high-DA maneuvers once we got up in the Sierras. Anyhow, it was one of those days where we had a handful of delays and took off about 1030, rather than our planned 0930. Annoying, but no worries: the weather was great. So we call up the FSS and open our flight plan, updating departure time when we do so. We go on our merry way and have a great flight. The only real downer was that the weather was actually too good (calm wind at altitude) and we didn't get a chance to work with orographic winds. Having done what we could, we land at South Lake for lunch and to discuss what we've learned. As soon as we walk in the FBO door, the woman behind the counter tells us Oakland's been calling for us and that we need to give them a call. I tell the student to call up WX-BRIEF and close us out while I see what Oakland wants.

I was confused and a wee bit terrified. I'd done this flight many times and had a pretty standardized process. Had I missed a TFR or something? But I call. Oakland answers and I say who I am.

"Are you on the ground safely in South Lake?" they ask.

"Yes. We landed about five minutes ago," I reply.

"Ah good. We were about scramble search and rescue for you."

This being one of my better days, I have a pretty good notion of what happened, "Hey, uh, what time of departure was listed on our flight plan?"

"0930 local."

Yup, the FSS forgot to input the actual departure time when they opened our plan. The supervisor and I discuss briefly. They're not mad; they're just happy they didn't have to send CAP out looking for us. In the end it was a total non-event. Honestly it didn't even change my process--reporting time-off is a standard part of opening a VFR plan. But it was a nice demonstration of how on-the-ball they are about S&R when plans are filed.
 
We've had so many issues at Valley Approach with getting flight plans between the US and Mexico. Whatever system Mexico uses isn't compatible with our system in the US. When you fly into MFE or BRO, we get a phone call from Reynosa and Matamoros giving your arrival details and ETA. That's not really a problem usually, except it's time consuming. Airplanes departing Reynosa or Matamoros going far into the US has been the main issue. They file a flight plan (I assume) but we get no information about it. Instead of just inputting a flight plan in our system, we're now supposed to tell Mexico ATC they need to work it out. At that point, the aircraft departs, switches to Valley, we see them on radar, but for whatever reason we can't do an automatic handoff to Houston Center because they don't have any information on it.
I'm not surprised. And I totally buy that. On my first job I flied MMAN to KSAT back and forth, and whenever I filed VFR Houston never had my flight plan, had to go to FSS to file one. Whenever I was IFR it would work, but I'm guessing it was also phone related. I guess that also explains I file, say Houston Hobby from MMAN and I get an as filed in Mexico but the moment I'm talking to Houston ctr I get the proper STAR.
Oh and btw I'm an extreme regular at BRO, look for the Lima Limas.

Edit: hey @Stinger on the filing, yeah you MUST in order to get an inch off the ground here, but from what you're telling me VFRs are just a protocol. IFRs I know a few controllers here in Mexico and I know those do work.

Take care
 
Last edited:
I was once asked to call the tower because I was told the pattern was full and I decided to do a fly by anyway.
image.jpeg
 
Back
Top