Call the Tower... Stories?

MidlifeFlyer

Well-Known Member
I periodically do a program on FAA enforcement. I try to improve it a little bit each time i give it. The last time, one of the most positive comments was that I include stories about real events. Some of them are real enforcement cases, some are from personal experience.

What I am missing is a good story about receiving a message to "call the tower" or another ATC facility in which the pilot is worried about some potential violation. The pilot calls, discusses it with ATC, and it doesn't goes any further than that. I'm not interested in stories where discussion it with an ASI goes no further - I have plenty of those.

If you want to tell me the story but not post it on the public part of the forum, send me a PM. Your name will not be mentioned.

Thanks.
 
Departing the world's busiest airport in day VFR conditions with no aircraft ahead of us on takeoff - essentially we were the first one to launch in quite a while.

Rotate, climb, clean up, a lot of radio chatter going on as he is lining up, launching, and lining up a series of aircraft behind us. No switch to departure instruction as we continue the climb through 5k for 10k. At 7k I switch to departure on my own.

Contact Departure. Departure gives us a climb instruction. Passing through 11k for 14k Departure gives us the whole "ASQ...I have a number for you to call when you arrive at your destination."

Okay. Take down the number.

Land at destination. Captain makes the phone call. I'm only aware of one side of the conversion but essentially Tower didn't like us switching to Departure on our own.

So, now I don't. At least not before trying to chime in on tower to let them know "eh, you forgot about us...and I'm about to switch...but I'm giving you a chance to tell me to switch first."

Nothing further was heard.

GASP - I didn't even file an ASAP for it!
 
Yeh I have a similar one I may well have posted about (from back in 2003).

Fresh PPL, flying to SDL in a Warrior with passengers, was looking for the airport, called it insight when I didn't have it, obviously messed up the planned entry they had for me. Called afterward, they said don't call unless you definitely have us in sight (vs think you see it). Nothing further.

No-one ever told me about ASAP (at the time) so nothing was filed.
 
I have a couple that I was part of a crew on. I'll have to write them up when I get to a real keyboard.
 
I was flying a 172 JYO-W29, through the SFRA but not the FRZ. I was communicating with Potomac Approach on Comm 1 and monitoring 121.5, per SFRA procedure. Abeam Tipton, the USAF on 121.5 instructs an unidentified aircraft at my position/altitude to exit the SFRA immediately, and ident. I ident, and ask Potomac why the Air Force is attempting to contact me. They tell me to proceed on course(after I confirm I'm actually on-course), and give me a phone number to call.

When I called, they explained to me that when I checked in on a new frequency my strip was not handed off to the next controller. When the supervisor asked about my aircraft, the controller working me was busy and did not hear the question. This caused the supervisor to alert HomeLand Security, who launched a helicopter to intercept me.

Potomac wanted to know if I ever saw the helo. I did not.
Potomac wanted to know why I idented. I told them I idented in response to an instruction from the USAF.

The supervisor told me I had done nothing wrong and that he simply needed some information for his report.
 
3rd week of instructing, I'm taxiing to the ramp and the ground controller (a supervisor that works TRACON, GND and TWR just on ground this time) asks me to call the tower when I get in my office. I'd been instructing 3 weeks, I couldn't think of what happened so I was terrified I broke a rule I was too stupid to be aware of. Quickest debrief ever, I was scared. I called him, he answers calls me by name and says "Hey [my name] were you cleared for the option on downwind? [I said yes] I was doing training and stepped away for a moment and didn't catch it. Sorry for the confusion but she wasn't supposed to clear you then"

I was scared and all he wanted to know was something for a trainee.
 
Departing the world's busiest airport in day VFR conditions with no aircraft ahead of us on takeoff - essentially we were the first one to launch in quite a while.

Rotate, climb, clean up, a lot of radio chatter going on as he is lining up, launching, and lining up a series of aircraft behind us. No switch to departure instruction as we continue the climb through 5k for 10k. At 7k I switch to departure on my own.

Contact Departure. Departure gives us a climb instruction. Passing through 11k for 14k Departure gives us the whole "ASQ...I have a number for you to call when you arrive at your destination."

Okay. Take down the number.

Land at destination. Captain makes the phone call. I'm only aware of one side of the conversion but essentially Tower didn't like us switching to Departure on our own.

So, now I don't. At least not before trying to chime in on tower to let them know "eh, you forgot about us...and I'm about to switch...but I'm giving you a chance to tell me to switch first."

Nothing further was heard.

GASP - I didn't even file an ASAP for it!

Got the number once for being cleared for takeoff, and not immediately responding because the previous aircraft was about half way through his takeoff roll. Probably hadn't even reached V1. Iistened to the call and Marty basically said (use your best Marty voice), "Well now, that airplane n'front uh us wasn't even fly'en yet, and you had cleared us ta go. We was gonna sit there 'n wait till he was done."

He kinda waited a while after the other guy was airborne to call, but I don't blame him. They have a tendency to run us reeeeeealy close together there when it's busy.
 
I had one departing the worlds busiest airport when I was a new captain.
Nasty storms were in the area. I started painting a wicked bow with attenuation behind it on my radar. Told ATC I needed vectors around it. He refused. A minute or two went by, we got closer. I told him I REALLY needed a turn. He refused due to arrival corridors. I told him I was turning left or right, his choice. He asked if I was declaring an emergency and I replied yes, it that was what it took. He got really mad at me, ranted about how I was throwing off their arrivals. Before changing me over he gave me a phone number to call when I landed.
Before calling the number I called my dispatcher when I landed. He said he was tracking my flight and was terrified I was going to fly into what he saw on his radar. He told me there were reports of tornadoes in the area (later confirmed to be F4's).
When I called the ATC number I got the supervisor. He informed me that he had already listened to the tapes and the controller in question had been pulled off line for training. Did I want to pursue this any further? I said no and thanked him.
 
I had a one hour meeting in Blythe CA and didn't want to drive the190 miles each way, my co-worker and I took my plane.

We departed Chino, it was clear and 50 miles before the tower opened. I didn't want to listen to ATC chatter so I didn't call anyone. We ducked under Ontario's Class C and climbed over March's Class C. Over flew the Palm Springs TRSA at 11,500. Followed the airway near but well clear of some restricted airspace and MOA's.

We walked into the FBO at Blythe and the employee was on the phone standing in the window reading off my tail number, color of plane. Describing me as the pilot and saying I was the only arrival so far that morning. He hung up the phone and seemed to take a lot of joy in telling me that was Homeland Security; I must have done something really wrong, right in front of my passenger.

When we got home I pulled the VFR GPS and downloaded the flight to my computer. Nothing... It was a perfect flight, well clear of all airspace both vertical and laterally. I proceeded to file every NASA form I could think of (the only time I've ever filed NASA forms). Expected a letter from the FAA in two weeks, it really bothered me.

Never got a letter, never heard a peep. I assume they were training and tagged my 1200 code at random.
 
Took one of my Chinese students to Fulton County (FTY) for his solo towered lesson (in our TSO/Not his first solo)). We had been there before but albeit at night. We arrive from the west and join a left downwind for 26. Land with no issues. We taxi over to the ramp and before we shutdown I let ground know that my student will be doing a few laps in the pattern. They say no problem.

I get out of the aircraft and my student fires up our fearsome DA20 and proceeds to call ground and taxi to 26. He does a quick run up, switches to tower, and is cleared for takeoff/left traffic.

By this time there is a little change in the winds. Starting to come out of the NW.

My student proceeds to turn left crosswind (or so I thought). I lose sight of him from where I am on the ground and start thinking, where the heck did he go). All of a sudden over the radio I hear "Diamond xxx, looks like you've lined up for 32, that's ok, cleared to land RWY 32".

Long story short: student went full on Chinese mode and practically forgot how to speak/understand English. He landed without any responses on the radio. Tower wanted him to exit on the right side so they could get him to taxi back to 26 without having to cross any runways. Kid turns left. . I hear/see ground finally get him over to the ramp and tell him to have the instructor call the tower.

I'm of course not looking forward to this at all... I'm embarrassed, frustrated, but glad that my student is at least safe. I call the tower and the guy just says "hey just wanted to let you know why we had him come back to the ramp, probably needs just a little extra practice. Have a good one!"

Phew!.. Now I make it a habit to do a couple laps the same day with my student before turning him loose.
 
First flight of the morning when I was a new FO with about 150 hours. I was doing all the morning duties they have us do after pushback and was head down the whole time. No ramp control so we taxi out of the ramp area to the holding point for calling ground or so I thought. When I looked up we had made it to the runway and were holding short. At the same time I was telling the captain I didn't make a call to ground, ground came on and said to give them a call. This was a major goof up but they said remember to talk before we go onto the taxiways and all was good after that.

Another flight I was apart of we were falsely accused by letter that we did not follow the departure procedure. After a little bit of investigating they used tapes from another flight because they mistook the zulu time for local time.

The best one of all. A student and I came back in from a great lesson. We are handed over to ground and the controller tells me to give them a call once we shutdown. This flight was absolute perfection so I have no clue on what could have happened. I call them up and they were inviting our FBO employees for a pizza party and tour of the new facilities!
 
Kind of the opposite to a call the tower, but a learning lesson that you never know whose on board.

I was finished with OE for Captain upgrade. One of the last motions was the FAA ride, and I actually had a Fed on board.

Very short flight in a Saab 340. Beautiful VFR day. Couldnt have asked for better. We load up, close the door, run the checklists and taxi out. Im holding short of the runway for departure as cleared. We notice a single engine prop on approach, so we just sit there with the parking brake set just waiting. The fed is bored looking out the window. My check airman probably just wants to get this over with so he can go home. The single engine is about a quarter mile away from the runway when tower clears us to depart. I look over at my check airman thinking to myself "does he really expect us to rush out there and get in front of this guy?" I then key up the mic and mention the guy on final. The fed, who hadnt really been paying much attention kind of perks up and does the old neck perched down and then up from the jumpseat bit. She begins to salivate at the impending violation. "We're just gonna go ahead and wait for the traffic to land. We'll remain holding short" I say over the tower frequency.

"Ohhh yea yea, hold short the runway, I thought that guy had landed already" tower responds. The fed speaks up "Can you see the tail number on that cessna?" "Yea" I respond. "Ok, read it off so I can write it down, then ask the tower for his phone number." I look over at my check airman, we're both thinking about how douchey this is going to sound over the radio, but what can you do? I ask the tower for the phone number. I cant remember if I mentioned that there was a fed on board or not. But as soon as the number was noted, we were cleared for take off.

We land and park it up, the fed says "well you must have done fine, I think I fell asleep for a few minutes."

I imagine the phone call didnt really lead to anything major, probably just a "keep an eye out next time."
 
Ok, Here’s one of mine:
I was single pilot in a CJ3, taking off from RWY 18 out of KLIT late in the afternoon. Just as I rotated, I hit a small group of birds with the left wing, I heard it and felt it, then I made a comment on tower frequency that I had just hit several birds. However, by that time, I was committed to the takeoff so away I went. As I was cleaning up the airplane, turning on course, and trying to see what damage I had sustained, I smoked through my initial altitude like it was a cheap cigar!

Tower asked me where I was going (I was on course but high), I replied “correcting”. I eased off of the power and corrected to the assigned altitude. The tower told me to copy a number for “possible pilot deviation”. I replied “Standby, I’m single pilot”. He said, “No problem, contact departure on 123.45 (?)”.
After I contacted departure, received a new altitude, and leveled off, departure gave me the number. I told him I would call in approximately an hour later. “O.K., please call upon landing….”
When I called, the tower told me that I “disregarded” my clearance. I told him my failure to maintain the altitude was NOT a disregard for an ATC assignment but rather the fact that I had hit the birds and in my attempt to manage the airplane, the route, the inspection of my wing, and the removal of a part of my seat from my backside, I failed to give the assignment the proper attention. He laughed a bit.
I apologized for my actions and asked if I needed to follow up later. He told me, “No, don’t worry about it. I appreciate the call and the explanation. Fly safe”.
He was very polite and professional and I felt pretty good about the entire situation. I completed a NASA Report anyway.

The only other one I had while flying, the Army delt with my infraction and took it out of the hands of the FAA.
 
I periodically do a program on FAA enforcement. I try to improve it a little bit each time i give it. The last time, one of the most positive comments was that I include stories about real events. Some of them are real enforcement cases, some are from personal experience.

What I am missing is a good story about receiving a message to "call the tower" or another ATC facility in which the pilot is worried about some potential violation. The pilot calls, discusses it with ATC, and it doesn't goes any further than that. I'm not interested in stories where discussion it with an ASI goes no further - I have plenty of those.

If you want to tell me the story but not post it on the public part of the forum, send me a PM. Your name will not be mentioned.




Thanks.
I have plenty of stories of "call the tower" and it doesn't go further than that, but what is the point you are trying to make? that one shouldn't be concerned if asked to call the tower?
 
Where do we get this program that you do? Is it a seminar or a newspaper like thing?

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk
 
I have two stories. Back in 2006 I think. I departed front range airport in CO to do Acro in a citabria. On the way home I was cleared for the straight in runway 26. The sun was setting in front of me and I drifted too far north and ended up lining up with runway 26 at DEN. I noticed it about 4 miles final, when I landed at Front Range I was asked to call DEN tower. Boy was I worried, I thought great, there goes any potential flying career. The controller was very nice and polite and just wanted to know what happened. Luckily they were not launching aircraft on from runway 8, so there was no mishap and that's as far as it went. I was being polite and extremely apologetic on my end. Ultimately the controller wanted to make sure I was aware of the airspace in the area and wanted to make sure there was not a repeat.

Second story, I was flight instructing out of Ft Lauderdale executive in a seminole. The practice area was over the everglades and it was hot, so we climbed to 7k to do our work. Later on I received the dreaded call MIA tower. I was sure I didn't violate any airspace, but you still worry. Again, controller very friendly and professional, all he wanted to let me know is that at 7k over that area I placed myself on a STAR and he simply suggested I do it a little bit further west. Nothing else. Apparently I set a SWA TCAS.

Both times I have been very fortunate to be talking to very nice people on the other end of the line simply concerned with safety.
 
I have plenty of stories of "call the tower" and it doesn't go further than that, but what is the point you are trying to make? that one shouldn't be concerned if asked to call the tower?
No. Not to not be concerned. Mostly that the decision whether or not to call isn't as simple as "always call" or "never call."
 
Back
Top